4 ms·
Counterpoint: That makes bad comments take more space in the discussion, which is the opposite of what they are intended to do. (e.g. is it really better instea
by detaro 6y ago
Counterpoint: That makes bad comments take more space in the discussion, which is the opposite of what they are intended to do. (e.g. is it really better instead of one downvoted comment to have one downvoted comment and 4 replies telling them they are an asshole/wrong/...? HN IMHO already has a problem with too repetitive commenting, that'd make it way worse)
- notahacker 6y agoIn theory these comments could be auto-collapsed or even hidden by default, but yes, this would escalate flamewars. I think it's often courteous to explain why people are being downvoted (and even more courteous to generally not downvote people simply because you disagree with their opinion), but a lot of the most downvoted comments are very obviously low effort, trolling, spamming or on divisive subjects and I'm not sure a comment from each downvoter adds value there