3 ms·
I think your problem is that you assume free will is a prerequisite for accountability, consequences, or justice. When my computer breaks, I either fix it or r
by s1artibartfast 6y ago
I think your problem is that you assume free will is a prerequisite for accountability, consequences, or justice.
When my computer breaks, I either fix it or replace it. I don't ask if the computer actively chose to break.
Assume there is a robot programmed to walk around punching people, do you ignore it because it isn't making choices?
Similarly, if a person is walking around punching people due to a combination of random and deterministic factors (no free will), do you ignore them?
- yetihehe 6y ago> Similarly, if a person is walking around punching people due to a combination of random and deterministic factors (no free will), do you ignore them? I will ask why they are punching people and might join if cause is valid. I'm not yet convinced if we have free will or not, whole concept looks a little meaningless when you look at it too closely.
- s1artibartfast 6y agoI think it is largely a philosophical question, but it does have some cultural ramifications. For example, it can change how most people think about and punish crimes.