4 ms·
re-leaglize. It was legal until the 90s. When it became illegal, the diversity on campus dropped significantly. There is an argument to be made that the race
by jedberg 6y ago
re-leaglize. It was legal until the 90s. When it became illegal, the diversity on campus dropped significantly.
There is an argument to be made that the race-based admissions help make up for prior injustices.
- ciarannolan 6y agoI think you also have to determine the purpose of a university. It's either to take the top students, bar none, or it is to educate and uplift poorer students (economically and educationally). Mixing these two doesn't work.
- jedberg 6y agoWhy can't you mix the two? Admit 1/2 your class as top students, and the other 1/2 as people who are being uplifted. That is in fact exactly how admissions at the UC schools work. The first 1/2 of the class is admitted on test scores and grades alone, the second 1/2 is admitted via reading of their essays and considering other factors, such as extracurriculars, economic circumstance, and, until the 90s, race.
- microtherion 6y agoOr you can choose to define "top students" as those who performed best, relative to their starting conditions. You could make an argument that such student are most efficient at using the opportunities they are given, and thus would benefit most from the education.
- samatman 6y agoThat would work, if the last measure taken was immediately prior to admission. Alas, university doesn't work that way: students continue to be measured throughout their tenure, and those measures are an important component of the next phase of their life, be it work or further education. The evidence is unequivocal: lowering the admissions standards for some section of the student body, results in those students doing poorly relative to students who were subject to the full standards. This shouldn't be surprising, and no, it doesn't seem to matter why the standards were lowered, affirmative action, legacy preference, or otherwise.
- compiler-guy 6y agoTotally the fallacy of the excluded middle. There are many ways to work the two goals together. And understanding it in these very limited dimensions is a complete mistake. The very definition of what a "top student" is varies a great deal.
- ffggvv 6y ago>> it was legal until the 90s so it was legal until then but didn’t make a dent in inequality? but i’m sure it’ll work this time!
- dragonwriter 6y ago> so it was legal until then but didn’t make a dent in inequality? It did make a dent in inequality. It didn't end it, but then it wasn't around nearly as long as the structural disadvantages that entrenched inequality, and it was a much gentler push than those it sought to mitigate the effects of.
- ffggvv 6y agoit’s been legal since the 70s outside of california and outcomes for minorities have steadily gotten worse not better.
- paulkennedy 6y agoYou don't think it's possible that affirmative action isn't the only variable there?
- ffggvv 6y agoi think the onus on someone who wants to propose a discriminative policy to prove that it works.
- travisoneill1 6y agoYes, we need to rectify the injustices commited by Asian Americans by discriminating against them in college admissions.
- vkou 6y agoIs that the only result of affirmative action admissions, or are there a few you are leaving out? Do you have a better plan for dealing with systemic racism[1], that does not have the drawback you cite? Do you believe that systemic racism doesn't exist? Or do you believe that it does exist, but we shouldn't do anything about it? Which of those three options are you championing? [1] I understand that the mere mention of this concept is a dogwhistle for negative karma.
- travisoneill1 6y ago> Do you have a better plan for dealing with systemic racism Get rid of all the bullshit administrators to lower the cost of college back to what it was 50 years ago so that poor people can go without getting into a lot of debt.
- vkou 6y agoThat's a solution to a different problem. College could be free, it wouldn't solve this problem. Which of these three options do you propose?
- rcoveson 6y agoLots of arguments can be and have been made in favor of racially discriminating policies. I believe the response must always be "no, that's morally wrong". A good "Church of Satan" reaction to these policies in California would be a university that set the bar higher for Black applicants, with the justification that other policies have in fact over-corrected for past injustices, and now the injustice of that over-correction must be righted. The thing to keep in mind is that the justification for some of the worst racism in history has been injustice or past injustices. We should learn from history and pre-commit as a society to react hyper-negatively to any policy that involves racial discrimination. Get it the hell out of the Overton window.