5 ms·
It's essentially the same situation with TikTok, however instead of outright banning Facebook, EU tries to regulate it. I strongly believe this is the right pa
by mrtksn 6y ago
It's essentially the same situation with TikTok, however instead of outright banning Facebook, EU tries to regulate it.
I strongly believe this is the right path forward, not the Chinese/US model of banning services. If the US way of doing things prevails, you can bet that Facebook and the rest will be banned all over the world because it is actually a security risk and it is a proven fact that US intelligence agencies are indeed snooping Facebook and other US tech companies. How do we know that? Thanks to Snowden. The revealed program is PRISM[0], who knows what else is out there.
I really hope that the EU way becomes the norm, otherwise the internet will get patchy, we won't have global communities anymore. There might be solutions like companies incorporating in each country like Coca-Cola opening a plant in every country but it will not be the same and will make the barrier of entry so high that very few will make it. No more global startups form a dorm room.
[0]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/PRISM_(surveillance_program) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/PRISM_(surveillance_program)
- bad_user 6y agoIt's really not the same thing. EU wants data privacy, and has regulations for it. European countries have always had strong consumer protection laws, it just so happens that the EU has unified them and it has teeth. To operate in a country, you have to follow that country's laws, period. At Facebook's scale, I don't think this is beyond their technical capabilities, or too expensive. The reason they are worried is that they've built their business on data surveillance, and they are worried that the EU with all their privacy regulations will invalidate their business model. As for Snowden, I remember the US president claiming that foreigners are not US citizens and thus we have no rights. Well, this is the EU protecting my rights, as an EU citizen. And US businesses will just have to comply if they want to do business here. Fine by me.
- kennywinker 6y ago> will invalidate their business model. make that "will make their business model less profitable" and I agree. With that many users, I'm very skeptical you need ANY kind of micro-targeting of ads to make good money. But the targeting allows you to make crazy money so they're pretty attached to it.
- pilsetnieks 6y ago> it just so happens that the EU has unified them and it has teeth Turns out, not always, though. One of the problems with GDPR is that enforcement is left with national DPAs, and it appears that the Irish DPA is really dragging their feet about it. Coincidentally, Ireland is where the European operations of many major technology conglomerates are established. https://www.irishexaminer.com/news/arid-40052177.html https://www.irishexaminer.com/news/arid-40052177.html
- bad_user 6y agoDPAs are currently understaffed, and the complaints and lawsuits are dragging, but I believe this is only temporary. The legal framework is there, lawsuits are happening, and it scares companies built on data surveillance, and we know because some of them have moved out of EU already. The big players are operating in a gray area that's harder to attack, but then again, they are bigger targets. Given past fines, and given GDPR's potential, I'm sure the EU wouldn't mind replenishing their budget in the future.
- lhorie 6y agoIsn't the business model to just sell ads? Is it not possible to do that without exporting people's PII and stuff out of EU?
- bad_user 6y agoI wouldn't be so sure. People pay for FB ads due to being able to target a demographic, eg women between 35-45 from California, interested in wellness. That's their whole value proposition. They could turn around and start serving ads based on the content viewed, but content and viewing on FB is very superficial, and compared with Google's AdWords, they don't have searches that signal intent. FB's ads convert pretty badly already. If those conversions drop further, might turn out to be a deal breaker. So what are they gonna do? Serve ads for Coke-Cola?
- lhorie 6y agoI mean, I'm sure norwegian dating sites have age/location info of their user base too. I thought the point of contention was that sending this data to a foreign country was the problem. Why does keeping data in physical servers within a country negatively impact an ads business that targets users based on their demographics?
- bad_user 6y agoMaybe because they want to stream that data to data mining servers in the US, possibly third-parties too? I was talking in general anyway. Between GDPR, requirements for safeguarding, and Apple destroying the mobile in-app advertising ID, they probably don't feel so good. Norwegian dating sites don't have permission to use age/location info, for ads, without explicit consent, and the ToS can't cover it, FYI.
- nicoburns 6y ago> Maybe because they want to stream that data to data mining servers in the US, possibly third-parties too? Facebook could still make plenty of money without doing this.
- r00fus 6y agoI don't see how we avoid a balkanization of the Internet - I predicted this years ago on HN. I think the US-centric model of a borderless Internet relied heavily on there not being a multi-polar state, and with the rise of China, Russia, India, etc this breaks down.
- HenryBemis 6y agoFair point on the fear of balkanization, but on the other hand USA cannot bully the whole planet. Perhaps bribery (aka lobbying) is legalised in the USA where people's needs are vigorously disrespected, but EU has a different (better) set of standards. USA likes to give everything to companies including neglecting all sorts of privacy matters for the common good (wealth of large corporations). Money is good. People have rights. USA will either respect the laws or other lands in the same manner that USA wants ITS laws to be respected. Can't have the pie and eat it. "You" (USA) can't twist EU's arm. We are partners, it we aren't.
- Jon_Lowtek 6y agoThe USA doesn't have any concept of privacy in the digital environment which corporations could disrespect. They deal with digital data like it's a gold rush: whoever mines it, owns it. There is a fundamental difference between the constitutions, laws and ultimately the sentiment of these two "unions of nation-states": the USA simply has nothing like this: From the Charta of Fundamental Right of the European Union: Article 8 - Protection of personal data 1. Everyone has the right to the protection of personal data concerning him or her. 2. Such data must be processed fairly for specified purposes and on the basis of the consent of the person concerned or some other legitimate basis laid down by law. Everyone has the right of access to data which has been collected concerning him or her, and the right to have it rectified. 3. Compliance with these rules shall be subject to control by an independent authority.
- piva00 6y agoThe concept of data privacy exists, the difference is that there are no legal framework to protect that concept so it's moot. It doesn't mean that the concept itself isn't possible to be disrespected, there is a lack of respect (and even considering the informal definition of disrespect to be an "insult") to data privacy in the US, there are no legal consequences to it though.
- addicted 6y agoIt’s the same thing other than in every way. The EU-Facebook situation is built of laws passed by the EU, and court rulings over the span of over a decade with proven and known access of data by American spy agencies. Facebook also has been given time and a clear path for resolution that they could follow to resolve this situation. None of this is true in the Tik Tok situation.
- mrtksn 6y agoThese are implementation details and of course nothing is the same because EU is not the USA and USA is not China and TikTok is not Facebook. The core of the issue is the same though. This one instance can go away but the core issue is there and it will keep coming in different forms. And If TikTok actually gets banned, I am afraid that anti-americanism and anti-globalism might get strong enough that the banning become the norm. These things are not like controlling cheese imports, people will actually suffer from these things just like Chinese citizens suffer from the Chinese internet censor. The moment the USA give the example is the moment when suffering becomes acceptable for the greater good(the greater good will vary, some will say it is to protect local businesses other will say national security or simply rejoice that it is an opportunity to stick it to the yankees). This is not a future I am looking forward to.
- Zak 6y agoThis leads to essentially breaking the internet. Do we want that? A degree of being difficult or impossible for a country that isn't hosting the servers or business operations of an internet service to enforce laws and regulations on it used to be seen as a feature. We already have a situation where reading most US local news from Europe requires the use of a VPN. Is an expansion of that situation desirable? When most of the population starts doing it, will banning VPNs be the norm outside of countries the West largely regards as totalitarian? I don't like the path this has to go down for enforcement to be effective.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- oska 6y ago> we won't have global communities anymore We can easily have global communities if social media is based on open standards and transparent data sharing, rather than corporate offerings with jealously guarded, covertly collected, personal data silos. I'm personally really happy to see these challenges to corporate social media, whether it's TikTok in the US, or Facebook in the EU.