4 ms·
As a product, this looks super-cool. However, I've got to be honest: while I'd play around with it while it's part of Area 120, there's no way I'd use it in a
by crazygringo 6y ago
As a product, this looks super-cool.
However, I've got to be honest: while I'd play around with it while it's part of Area 120, there's no way I'd use it in a business until it officially became part of G Suite, as a core service. If Keep and Tasks are core services, then this needs to be too.
That becomes a guarantee that it'll stick around basically forever. So it's very exciting to see Google launch something like this -- but I hope they can align their internal politics and business goals here.
(Also, separate nitpick, but they're launching this as "beta", but with a paid plan. Since when is beta software charged for? What does "beta" even mean anymore then?)
- msapaydin 6y agoopenai gpt-3 beta private api is also becoming not free soon.
- kevas 6y agoUhhh what?
- pdx_flyer 6y agoExactly. Until it's part of the suite it doesn't have Google's full backing and no guarantee that they won't kill it. I use Keep to share lists with my spouse but even that I don't put anything important into because it could go away as quickly as it showed up.
- crazygringo 6y agoYou don't need to worry about Keep. It's part of G Suite core services, which means corporations have long-term contracts with Google that basically guarantees it stays around. Not to mention that Keep is deeply integrated with Gmail, Cal, Docs, etc. No matter how lightweight of a tool it may seem, Keep isn't going away. G Suite is very conservative and careful with changes they make around their core services.
- loteck 6y ago"Conservative" is one way to say it. Perhaps another way to view it is that development of some G Suite core apps has stopped [0], which should perhaps give one pause. [0] https://support.google.com/docs/answer/9228272?hl=en https://support.google.com/docs/answer/9228272?hl=en
- crazygringo 6y agoThat help article is just for Docs, and is also extremely limited. I suggest you take a look at the G Suite updates blog instead: https://gsuiteupdates.googleblog.com/ https://gsuiteupdates.googleblog.com/ You'll be fairly overwhelmed in reading it, I imagine.
- levesque 6y agoTell that to the early access crowd!
- jjeaff 6y agoWhile I am also annoyed by Google's discontinuation of products, I would guess that the failure rate of saas startups is still much higher than Google's cancel rate. I'm not sure how many years a startup needs to be around though before it's likelyhood of survival surpasses that of a new google product.
- jiofih 6y agoGoogle has discontinued a total of 205 products so far. I think their survival rate is pretty close to the startup average.
- panarky 6y agoHow many products has Microsoft discontinued?
- edoceo 6y agoThere have been well more than 205 failed startups in the last 10 years and so many more since G started. Google kill count is high but startup failure is much much higher
- AlphaSite 6y agoI, not sure if absolute numbers are worth looking at. What are the %s.
- jiofih 6y agoI thought that would be understood implicitly - how many google products do you know, maybe 10 to 20? That’s a < 10% success rate, pretty comparable to startups in general.
- mrkstu 6y agoThe difference is that originally there was a higher likelihood of trying out a Google product than a random startup's. Now that equation is flipped- I'd rather try a random startup's product than a Google one- at least the startup is going to live and die on making that product a success. Google? It has to be a massive world spanning success or its a guaranteed goner.
- benatkin 6y agoThat isn't a guarantee. Google killed Inbox. They also regularly kill features, like community captions on YouTube. https://www.theverge.com/2020/7/31/21349401/youtube-community-captions-deaf-creators-accessibility-google https://www.theverge.com/2020/7/31/21349401/youtube-communit... Also Reader and FeedBurner felt much like core services during their heyday.
- DoctorOW 6y agoIIRC Inbox, Reader, and Feedburner were never core products of GSuite. Just consumer products that were popular and/or well-liked. That's different from being a core part of the GSuite applications: https://gsuite.google.com/intl/en_us/features/ https://gsuite.google.com/intl/en_us/features/ .
- tyingq 6y agoApp Maker was part of GSuite. Killed off.
- baxtr 6y agoAnyone remember Google Wave?!
- gpm 6y agoWasn't Google wave always a closed (with plenty of invites available) beta?
- solresol 6y agoFusiontables was part of G Suite until it was terminated.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- haltingproblem 6y agoGoogle's internal politics and business goals are well aligned for their employees. Adsense/Adwords spews tens of billions of dollars in profits every year. Google's political economy incentivizes groups to build new products not for their revenue streams but to claim larger bonuses of the ad-revenue pie. The users who buy into these "new" products are just cannon fodder in that game. Remember Google+? Vic Gundotra made off with probably tens of millions or more to launch a failed product. Almost anything MSFT releases in response to Google or competitors is inferior but MSFT's products are preferable due to implied longevity. MSFT has inoculated themselves against this parasitic political economy while Google and its users are held hostage by it.
- fearface 6y agoWhich inferior product are you referring too?
- andrewprock 6y agoBing is the obvious product, but I'm quite confident that Bing will continue to exist for many years to come.
- manigandham 6y agoI agree with the first part, however Microsoft has been competing extremely well and has released very good products through both acquisitions and internal development.
- jrockway 6y ago> Since when is beta software charged for? Since forever. I will concede that the cool kids call it "early access" these days, however.
- carliny 6y agoHey there! Tables PM here -- thanks for writing an honest opinion about what factors you're considering before wanting to use it for a business; I really appreciate that feedback and it's very helpful for us to hear. I know our team would love to have people try Tables for lightweight work tracking use cases, even if it's not for a mission-critical business need. At the end of the day, we want Tables to help people and businesses make work a little easier, especially with covid forcing many to digitize and work remotely. If we're able to create a lot of value, that'll make for a strong case to graduate Tables into a larger Google product area, and we're only going to be able to do that with feedback from folks like yourself who can apply a healthy dose of objectivity. :) Thanks for sharing your thoughts on this, and we hope you'll give Tables a little time (even Keep took several years before finally joining G Suite)! I'll also take that feedback on the "beta" label back to the team.
- Terretta 6y agoHow are you addressing business data compliance? A kanban central like this essentially contains a snapshot of the company and its direction, “outside”. RBAC w/ segregation of duties on the admin side and least privilege assurances, audit trails, SOC2, HIPAA, etc. etc... ?
- carliny 6y agoHey Terretta, great question. Tables is already built on standard Google infrastructure so we have many of the default security and privacy protections built in. From a user-facing standpoint: Tables is really geared towards being more user-friendly than the traditional DBA type tools, so the sharing model aligns more closely with Google Drive, and offer similar permissioning roles like "Editor", "Commenter", and an additional "Writer" role for collaborators who should be able to edit the rows, but not the table schema itself. We also have table and row-level change history baked in, and while we don't specifically offer an audit trail within the app, users can implement a version of that themselves using our bots. We're also working to support the ability to use bots to essentially automate GDPR compliance, by having bots that will automatically delete table rows that are >X days old. From a customer-to-Google standpoint: we are very serious about your data privacy and security. We're not currently rubberstamped for HIPAA/SOC2, but we're already in the process of going through the internal reviews for FEDRAMP and HIPAA compliance. We do not at this time have advanced enterprise admin controls for customers, but it's absolutely coming in the future (we are only 1-day old to the public :). We're not going to have all the angles covered, but we're working towards it!