8 ms·
I wish Containers would get some love. Ability to set root domain for example would be great, so I could keep all Bandcamp sites in a single container without m
by magicalhippo 6y ago
I wish Containers would get some love. Ability to set root domain for example would be great, so I could keep all Bandcamp sites in a single container without micromanagement for example.
I also wish there was a simple way to suspend tabs, essentially turning them into the "ghosts" they are when you start the browser. So many times I want to keep a tab around for easy access, but they got some stupid JS framework running sucking CPU for no good reason.
That said, overall I'm quite pleased with Firefox and hope Mozilla keep developing it. We need a proper Chrome alternative.
- thrwn_frthr_awy 6y agoI agree on the containers. It's such a powerful feature, but it feels weird to need extensions to make containers work the way many feel they should intuitively. For instance I have a Google container, but I can't figure out how to make outbound search links open in a different container.
- gruez 6y agoafaik multi account containers should work, if you set google as "always open in google container". temporary containers (https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/temporary-containers/ https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/temporary-con...) would also work.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- thrwn_frthr_awy 6y agoI use multi account containers and it doesn't work for me. For instance, if I go to amazon.com directly, I get my Amazon container. But if I do a search in Google and then click an Amazon link I will still be in the Google container.
- bickeringyokel 6y agoYou can right click to open in a specific container. Take a bit of forethought though.
- mkskm 6y agoThis is fixed now with the Limit to Designated Sites feature. It's a little buried though: click the multi-account containers button in the title bar > the arrow next to your Google container > Manage This Container > Limit to Designated Sites.
- thrwn_frthr_awy 6y agoThank you. This is the what I am after. Unfortunately Limit to Designated Sites does not work when combined with the Containerize add-on.
- jhoechtl 6y agoGoogle feeds Mozilla. I am astonished this extension is even available in the store.
- solstice 6y agoYour could try this extension. I mostly use it for its auto suspend but you can also manually suspend tabs: https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/auto-tab-discard/ https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/auto-tab-disc...
- spiffytech 6y agoI use the Auto Tab Discard extension, which turns tabs I haven't looked at recently back into the same ghosts as they are on startup. There's a bunch of configuration for how it chooses which tabs to discard. I'm away from my PC now, but I'm pretty sure it gives a right-click option on the tab to suspend one manually if you want. https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/android/addon/auto-tab-discard/ https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/android/addon/auto-tab-disc...
- freedomben 6y agoDo you use this on desktop? The add on install page is saying that the extension is not intended for desktop, so figured it was worth asking.
- SAI_Peregrinus 6y agoNot the parent, but I do. It works fine IME.
- jtuente 6y agoHe linked the android version, if you click the warning it goes to the normal desktop page.
- OJFord 6y agoSidebery is primarily a horizontal (/tree style) tab lister, but this is also a feature of it (calls it 'unload' I think) on right click, really great if something's being a resource hog, but I might want it again later.
- mkskm 6y agoAuto Tab Discard works great for me as well. Would love to see something like this built-in, though. I've also found cutting the content process limit in half to significantly improve performance. Combined with the above add-on my machine doesn't start swapping or become non-performant even with lots of sites open.
- mxmilkb 6y ago
- addandsubtract 6y agoI just want temp containers. With all the cookie bullshit you have to pick and choose on each website, I just want to accept it all and then flush the container once I'm done with the website.
- npteljes 6y agoDo you know about the Temporary Containers addon? While it has some quirks, it seems to do exactly what you described, automatically and quite intuitively. I'm a happy user for two years now I think.
- pityJuke 6y agoMan, I love this plugin. Every time I open a link from HN, CTRL-Click (configured this way) and into a new container it goes. Combine it with Chameleon, and you can really confuse some sites.
- andrewl-hn 6y agoHow did you do that? Cmd+Click opens links in the same container for me, and I can't find the right setting.
- SAI_Peregrinus 6y agoIn Temporary Containers settings: Isolation tab, Global, Mouse click. Set "Ctrl/Cmd+Left Mouse" to anything but "Never".
- skykooler 6y agoThank you for this comment! That extension is exactly what I was looking for for a while.
- nicky0 6y ago"Cookie AutoDelete"[1] extension might be what you want. It flushes cookies after you close all tabs for a site. There's an allowlist of sites for which to retain cookies. It's nice when paired with the "I don't care about cookies"[2] extension which auto-accepts cookie requests and makes sure you never see any cookie permission dialogs. 1: https://github.com/Cookie-AutoDelete/Cookie-AutoDelete https://github.com/Cookie-AutoDelete/Cookie-AutoDelete 2: https://www.i-dont-care-about-cookies.eu/ https://www.i-dont-care-about-cookies.eu/
- ycombinete 6y agoI wish ctrl+tab would cycle through all recent tabs regardless of what container they’re in.
- ycombinete 6y agoI see this works. Either it always did, or has been changed since I first noticed it
- npteljes 6y agoThere's an addon called Containerise that seems to do what you describe. The basic usage in the description could be easily used to isolate the bandcamp sites. https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/containerise/ https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/containerise/
- waz0wski 6y agoWorks great in combination with multi-account + temporary containers extensions. Grants the ability to regex match on domains & url paths for sites that do auth redirects or to isolate corporate & personal accounts on the same domain (github, google etc) - MAC should have this functionality built in, and there are several open issues requesting it. Containerise does have builtin limited temporary container functionality, but I found the separate extension to have more useful configuration options for how temp containers are handled
- ihuman 6y ago> Ability to set root domain for example would be great, so I could keep all Bandcamp sites in a single container without micromanagement for example I think you can already do that, unless I'm misunderstanding you. If you use the "Always open this site in..." menu option while you're on the bandcamp website, it'll automatically change the container then next time you visit any bandcamp.com url.
- magicalhippo 6y agoSo close yet so far. If I go to https://mayflowermadame.bandcamp.com/ https://mayflowermadame.bandcamp.com/ and select "always open this site in...", and I then open https://vandrer.bandcamp.com/ https://vandrer.bandcamp.com/ having not visited it before, it doesn't open the site in my Bandcamp container.
- mozillamaxx 6y agoMAC Containers developer here. This treatment is done by default in the Facebook Container add-on. It's more of a question of how to handle the setting on a per domain/Container in the UI. Follow along for the root domain issue here: https://github.com/mozilla/multi-account-containers/issues/1833 https://github.com/mozilla/multi-account-containers/issues/1...
- briffle 6y agoNot for the root domain, no. It treats www.acme.com and mail.acme.com seperately
- okso 6y agoSuspending tabs would be very useful. I used to suspend tabs in Chrome by freezing the process of the tab (kill -STOP | kill -CONT), but Firefox shares the same process for multiple tabs. Has anyone tried to implement a "suspend tabs" extension that would pause the debugger ?
- clairity 6y agoyes, if firefox gets ornery (with entirely too many tabs open all the time), i just kill some/all of the "FirefoxCP Web Content" processes (on macos) and then reload only the tabs i'm interested in at the moment. not the ideal level of granularity, but works ok in a pinch to reduce memory/cpu usage.
- cvrjk 6y agoThis is something that bothers me a bit. On my PC memory usage spikes even after having tabs open for a short while. I've recently shifted to Firefox and I noticed that after opening 10-15 tabs on about 3 separate firefox windows the memory usage is way higher than Chrome's. I have seen lesser memory usage on Chrome for way more tabs and windows. I have very similar observations on my android phone as well. I've had 100+ chrome tabs open on my phone with no hiccups, but about 20-30 in, on Firefox, my entire phone slows down to a crawl and tabs start crashing etc. Is it just me?
- clairity 6y agomy impression is that all browsers are pretty greedy about memory for the first few dozen tabs. once you get to hundreds of tabs, the serious optimizations and compressions kick in so that the per-tab memory use curtails drastically. but i'm no expert in this area, just a user.
- mFixman 6y ago> So many times I want to keep a tab around for easy access, but they got some stupid JS framework running sucking CPU for no good reason. Why not keep it as a bookmark? I don't understand why people live inactive tabs open.
- andrewl-hn 6y agoI'm a tab hoarder. I open several tabs releted to some task and keep them opened for weeks and months. Later when I search for it in address bar and Firefox offers me to jump to one of the tabs, I do that and instantly see related tabs to the left and right of the current tab. My current tab may not always be the exact one I was looking for, but the one I need is still easilly trackable. If I don't do that and try searching the web my search may not be precise enogh to bring the needed page. Overall, it's just a different mode of browser use. It suits some people and doesn't suit others. Good thing that Firefox can accomodate both types of users.
- magicalhippo 6y agoTake Gmail. I want it easily accessible, but I don't need it running in the background as my phone will ping when I got a new mail. When developing, I'll open a new window and keep some tabs relevant for what I'm working on. Frequently it involves me piecing together bits from different APIs or parts of APIs, so require switching between multiple tabs. Often I'll have to come back, and it may take a day or two. No need to keep the tabs running, I just want to quickly pick up where I left. Stuff like that.
- SAI_Peregrinus 6y agoBookmarks discard a lot of (potentially valuable) context that tabs don't. History, for one. Parent & child tabs, if using Tree-Style Tabs, for another.
- at_a_remove 6y agoHonestly? As a tab hoarder, I have wondered why I do this so many times. I think the answer is that Firefox's bookmarking is ... not great. It is always slow and clunky-feeling to use. You're forced to put these bookmarks into a tree structure, which isn't awful until you realize that you have to remember just how you stored it later. Just for reference, I often find myself running SQL commands against Firefox's places.sqlite DB to locate a page I visited. I think tab hoarding could be greatly reduced by a series of thoughtful improvements to bookmarking.
- j1elo 6y agoYou've been recommended Auto Tab Discard. Another one I use, and it works very well, is UnloadTabs [0]. I discovered it because it's one of the addons recommended by Tree Style Tab [1]. [0]: https://addons.mozilla.org/firefox/addon/unload-tabs/ https://addons.mozilla.org/firefox/addon/unload-tabs/ [1]: https://addons.mozilla.org/firefox/addon/tree-style-tab/ https://addons.mozilla.org/firefox/addon/tree-style-tab/
- mkskm 6y agoRelatedly, it would be great to be able to edit site lists manually. Often sites redirect to a short URL briefly at login, which breaks when using containers. Seems to be most common for me with banks.
- perfectstorm 6y agomy only complain about containers is that it doesn't work well when you want to authorize an app. For example, I want to sign in with Google on my Zoom app but since i told them to always open google domain on my B container, it opens it in B while my gmail account for personal use is in A container. My workaround for now is to change the default browser app and revert it back once i'm logged in. I wish there was a solution for this.
- firecall 6y agoThe way Chrome has integrated the switching between 'Google account' is super useful and well done. I've got a lot of marketing clients I work with, and having everything in the context of a google account for that client is deeply embedded as part of my workflow. I could do the same with Firefox accounts, they just need to implement it!
- GekkePrutser 6y agoThe whole idea of having everything in the context of a Google account is the exact reason I use Firefox and not Chrome :)
- GekkePrutser 6y agoYes the containers are amazing but I kinda miss the way to change settings in each container. Sometimes I mistakenly chick allow notifications in a container but can't find any way to undo it without deleting the whole container.