4 ms·
>VSCode is growing which is concerning, not from a competitive point of view but actually from the point of view that there is clearly a lack of understanding o
by coldtea 6y ago
>VSCode is growing which is concerning, not from a competitive point of view but actually from the point of view that there is clearly a lack of understanding of what an IDE gives you. VSCode is a code editor with some features that you’d find in an IDE, and extensions that can provide additional functionality – so if people are turning to VSCode for developing it may imply that developers don’t know what a fully-featured IDE can give them.
I've found that VSCode can trivially be expanded to be more fully-featured than any IDE I've used -- includiding Eclipse, Idea and XCode.
It's not even the difficult kind of trying to make Vim or ST or even Emacs an "IDE-like" editor with a mismatch of third party plugins of varying quality and integration.
VSC has a few first-class, officially-supported (e.g. MS) plugins that immediately give you nearly all IDE superpowers (inline debugging, intellisense, build environments, git, remote development, testing, etc) with very tight integration.
In fact VSC is so well designed for extensibility / plugin integration, that even third party plugins feel native and integrated to the UI/experience. Despite it's origins as the Monaco editor or Visual Studio's "little cousin", it's more of a "a la cart IDE" today than a text editor + some plugins.
I'm not an Electron fan, but VSC is a great app.
- pjmlp 6y agoExcept for stuff like RAD tooling for native apps.
- coldtea 6y agoYeah, but nobody, statistically speaking of course, cares for those today :-) For most devs, and especially HN-mingling devs, it's either system work, embedded work, ML/AI/Data Science, backend work, html/js frontend, or Electron -- and as for native apps, most focus on iOS or Android (rather than desktop native). Somehow RAD native apps became the forgotten stepchild.
- pjmlp 6y agoStrange and me thinking that one of the selling points of Android Studio and XCode was RAD support for mobile native apps. Try to do iOS storyboards by hand in a text editor loved by the HN UNIX crowd.
- coldtea 6y ago>Strange and me thinking that one of the selling points of Android Studio and XCode was RAD support for mobile native apps. Strange, and me thinking I've already covered that: "as for native apps, most focus on iOS or Android (rather than desktop native). Somehow RAD native apps became the forgotten stepchild."
- oaiey 6y agoI think it helps that Erich Gamma worked on Eclipse before. Lessons Learnt I would call that. Also, treating VS Code as a Code Editor is naive from JetBrains. Visual Studio (the big one) is a technology dead end. It has a dozen tech stacks in it (COM, .NET, C++, ...) and faces challenges (macOS, Linux, Web, lightweightness, ...) that it can never overcome without a rewrite of most of it. Surprise: VS Code. I mean that is my theory ... and I think a lot of people share that theory.
- skocznymroczny 6y agofully-featured IDE only works well for languages that support these features, like Java and C#. In C++, I don't have reliable refactoring, I can't "extract a method to free function" with few clicks, so why not just use VSCode.
- leeman2016 6y agoAs much as I like smaller and faster editors like VS-Code, in case of Java and C#, I wouldn't survive a day without IntelliJ/Rider. * Better refactoring * Better linting and code cleanup; Most of the time I learn new language features from the IDE linting * Awesome diff/merge tool; Not just for git but for local history (undo/redo) * Debugging/running multiple projects at once is also nice * Better dynamic language support; Easier to use on a large wild Javascript codebase
- raxor53 6y agoI use Visual Studio for C# (haven't tried Rider yet) for the reasons you mentioned. However, I feel that VSCode more than capable as a platform. The intersection of tooling for C# and VSCode is really lacking compared to TypeScript.
- cmiles74 6y agoThe Java auto-completion plugin-ins for Emacs mostly call out to Eclipse in the background through Eclim. IMHO, you kind of are using an IDE at that point. :-P http://eclim.org/install.html http://eclim.org/install.html
- cle 6y agoThese days I use lsp-mode for Java--effectively the same thing used in VS Code--but it's still powered by Eclipse (https://github.com/eclipse/eclipse.jdt.ls https://github.com/eclipse/eclipse.jdt.ls).
- cmiles74 6y agoI did not know about this project! Thank you for mentioning it, I think I will check it out. I had weird issues with Eclim that kind of came and went and that was a big part of my dropping it. If this is more reliable I can see situations where I might prefer to try and edit my Java code in Emacs.
- cle 6y agoThere are still some warts but it works pretty well. It is definitely the future of cross-editor Java support.
- ozten 6y agoBlaming the customer isn't a great strategy. They should do customer research to understand these users and decide if they are a niche they should target or can safely ignore.
- StevePerkins 6y ago> I've found that VSCode can trivially be expanded to be more fully-featured than any IDE I've used -- includiding Eclipse, Idea and XCode. If you honestly believe this to be remotely true, then it tells me that you've never done any refactoring in your career. Which tells me that you lack any non-trivial experience with real-world Java applications (and perhaps any language).