3 ms·
Urbit is also not a federated system, but rather, a true distributed system. Each urbit instance is a peer. The stars and galaxies provide discovery and initi
by samatman 6y ago
Urbit is also not a federated system, but rather, a true distributed system.
Each urbit instance is a peer. The stars and galaxies provide discovery and initial routing, which is a pretty neat solution, they're basically fancy DNS servers.
What I think is exciting about urbit, is that each identity can host services. So you can launch a chat room, and it's yours, other peers can show up and say things in it, but this is very different from federation, where there is a sharp distinction between administrators and users.
Anyone who comments in your chat room can have a chat of their own, and the cryptographic identity of you and them is identical and consistent, wherever in the fleet you may encounter each other.
Stability and performance have improved, but there's a long way to go before a smooth one-click user experience is a reality.
But the basic design is solid, and it has a chance precisely because it isn't federated, but distributed. Secure Scuttlebutt is another truly distributed system, of very different design; it's locked in some bad architecture but I found it quite pleasant to interact with.
Don't expect anything useful from Holochain, ever. Just... I don't want to get into inside baseball, but, nah. Never gonna happen.
- dpc_pw 6y agoYeah, for me a federated system taken to its logical conclusion turns into p2p system. SSB is neat, but ineed could use rearchitecting. I could imagine ssb-like system + handshake to work quite OK for certain things. Thanks for info on Holochain. I've been only lurking in there and reading docs, so my understanding is rather shallow and theoretical.