10 ms·
Indian robot climbs trees to harvest coconuts
- blueblisters 6y agoLooks like this was an undergraduate learning project rather than a practical solution to harvesting coconuts. It reminds me of ABU Robocon, where undergraduates representing different countries compete to build the fastest robot using off-the-shelf parts that can solve an abstract problem. The point wasn't to fix a real-world issue but to serve as a learning tool, push technological boundaries and hopefully land a job while doing it. Some cool videos from the last few years: - 2019 Mongolia v/s Hong Kong https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1WVDXrlHUsA https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1WVDXrlHUsA - 2018 Vietnam v/s China https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_kPI_51cLpo https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_kPI_51cLpo - 2017 Vietnam v/s Malaysia https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=huzm9mrEZJE https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=huzm9mrEZJE
- anon9001 6y agoFrom the description: > The contest aims to create friendship among young people with similar interests who will lead their countries in the 21st century, as well as help advance engineering and broadcasting technologies in the region. That's pretty wholesome.
- aussieguy1234 6y agoI'd doubt this will end the exploitation of the slave monkeys that are forced to pick coconuts. They're likely cheaper than a robot. For this reason, I don't buy coconut products from Thailand. https://investigations.peta.org/monkeys-abused-coconut-milk/ https://investigations.peta.org/monkeys-abused-coconut-milk/
- slowmotiony 6y agoMonkeys being made to scale up trees? How inhumane. Better have some poor guy do it instead.
- accurrent 6y agoThe idea is pretty neat imo. Its a simple mechanism. Over the long term I suspect it may even be cheaper to use the robot cause the robot does not need to be fed or managed. I'm tempted to build one myself as the parts cost doesn't look like it'll exceed $1.5K. The music in the video though... According to https://www.wfft.org/wildlife-general/a-growing-trade-monkeys-sold-as-pets-in-thailand/ https://www.wfft.org/wildlife-general/a-growing-trade-monkey... monkeys cost between $1000-$4000/head Also do note that monkey based coconut picking is on the decline: https://www.pri.org/stories/2020-08-26/does-thailand-have-monkey-labor-problem https://www.pri.org/stories/2020-08-26/does-thailand-have-mo... Only a small proportion of coconuts are actually picked by monkeys.
- aussieguy1234 6y agoSo depending on the monkey the robot may be cheaper. Another cost farmers will likely look at is the cost of a monkey handler, which are widespread vs the cost of a specialised employee who can operate a robot. Unfortunately, the monkey handler is likely cheaper.
- ferbass 6y agoAs far as i know training this monkeys takes time, the robots will do the job right away if you put this in the long term the robots is cheaper than keep a monkey. But of course they should make it simple in the way that a non specialized employee can operate the bot without any problem.
- samatman 6y agoJust out of idle curiousity, are you the sort of person who would describe a pack mule as a slave? Sheep dog? Service animal? This isn't intended as a 'gotcha', everyone has a line. Given that you're willing to quote PETA without spitting on the ground, I'd infer that you are far into the animal rights, militant vegan camp? Is that fair?
- deathhand 6y agoSadly this illustrates the current state of Robotics - HARD. This was 3 years with multiple people's lives. The industry as a whole needs to go down the same route as computers did which are common platforms that fit together that get the job done. Sadly there needs to be a behemoth in this space first(1960s IBM) that does all this work that society as a whole then can profit from(Facebook today)
- magicsmoke 6y agoI'd say this reflects how problems in the physical world are hard in general. The robotics industry does have common platforms in the form of robotic arms used in automotive manufacturing. But they take away all the messiness and noise of the physical world by locking humans away and only allowing the arms to manipulate carefully designed prefab components. It's a similar situation in the world of computing because our silicon chips don't make full use of the analog design space. Rather, they stick to digital circuits with clearly defined voltage levels and clocking margins. By not pushing silicon design to its absolute limits and sticking with artificial restrictions that improve reliability, computer programmers don't have to worry about analog voltage drops across the chip and focus only on ones and zeros. Creating this same artificial environment for robots would involve turning the messy world we live in into a factory floor.
- Const-me 6y agoThese multiple people were professor and their students. The main value for that particular project wasn’t coconuts nor product development, it was education. In that light the project is awesome, pretty sure the students learned tons of valuable things about hardware design debugging and testing, embedded software, coconut farming, and many others. From product development point of view, I think a team of 3-5 smart and experienced people is likely to deliver better result in a couple of months, given reasonable amount of funding to purchase commercially available components.
- 7171u 6y agoRobot looks very fragile and process seems very slow.
- Hokusai 6y ago> As the population increasingly moves towards tech jobs, there's now a shortage of coconut harvesters in India. This seems a very bold claim. I can believe that there is a shortage of people willing to do this job, but it is very hard to believe that the reason is the tech jobs. Even in the USA IT workers represent less than 5% of all jobs. Otherwise interesting how automation is increasing around the world.
- danans 6y agoIt is shifting the labor market though. For example, those tech workers are eating out far more often, so there is greater demand for the Indian equivalent of burger flippers (dosa flippers?), which could be considered preferable job compared to the higher risk occupation of coconut tree climbing.
- just4tscomment 6y agoI find that claim fairly dubious as well. The primary job killer currently is COVID-19, and it has hit India hard. There are numerous restrictions on labour and several farmhands \(migrant workers from other states\) have returned home. This news report, dated August elaborates: https://www.thehindu.com/news/cities/Madurai/future-looks-bleak-to-farmhands-in-madurai-district/article31258153.ece https://www.thehindu.com/news/cities/Madurai/future-looks-bl... Worth noting that the university in question is situated in the same province, Tamil Nadu. Section 144 has been imposed, which is a law that prohibits gatherings/assembly and gives the police sweeping powers to arrest/detain curfew breakers.
- jelliclesfarm 6y agoPoint to note: migrant workers from other states are needed to work in the southern farms. The missing farm labour force are invisibly employed elsewhere. I would wager that it is in the tech sector.
- just4tscomment 6y agoI disagree. I took a look at Labour Report by the Government of India, https://labour.gov.in/sites/default/files/Report%20Vol%203%20final.pdf https://labour.gov.in/sites/default/files/Report%20Vol%203%2..., which is based on the 2011 census data. A large portion of India's population is still poorly skilled. Besides, the tech sector has a higher barrier to entry compared to the blue collar and agricultural sector.
- afrojack123 6y agoI am Indian and I am no worried about my job.
- reindeerer 6y agoAre they trying to put trained monkeys out of the job there ?
- vikrantrathore 6y agoThis is good as a learning exercise and may be result in something useful in future. So for sake of learning and advancement good. As far as claims to replace coconut harvesters, a bit of a stretch to probably attract funding with marketing. Why not built a mechanical crane with a platform to help the worker to do better job with safety at heights to harvest a coconut and than apply the same for multiple tasks like repairing street lights. Cleaning the building facades and homes, cleaning and arranging work at heights. I believe existing technology can do it.
- dzhiurgis 6y agoCrane would be way more complex and something like 50x more expensive.
- satya71 6y agoAlso the crane probably can't reach 90% of the trees in an orchard (or is it grove?).
- vikrantrathore 6y agoThat’s where the innovation comes up, use materials and structure to bring down the costs. Even if initially it costs higher, it can pay back by it’s multi-use, maintenance, energy efficiency by using mechanical energy applied by human muscle with creative use of hydraulics and mechanical designs. Usually multi-purpose robots cost way higher and requires more maintenance and costs. Given the average labour costs in India with over 10% unemployment in urban areas and much higher in rural areas created by economic mismanagement for second term by the current government. I believe human labour is more versatile and cheaper, if supported by right amount of technology in India. It’s crucial for its development.
- digikata 6y agoAlong those lines, seems you could design a far simpler, non-electric frame that could be rolled up a trunk with a mechanical cable/waldo cutter for the coconuts.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- causality0 6y agoFascinating. I didn't know coconut farming was still done so traditionally. I figured they were harvested using machines like an apple shaker or rolling platform.
- dxbydt 6y agoI grew up in a remote village in south India. We had over two dozen coconut trees in our yard. I made a long loop in the mud that went around all these trees. I'd pull water out of the well using a rope & pulley & pour it down the loop. The water would wind its way until it reached all the two dozen trees. About an hour of this water pulling & the loop would stay wet for a few hours. This sort of manual work was standard fare for a young teen. Even then, in the 1970s, there was a shortage of coconut harvesters. The ones who showed up to harvest coconuts were quite poor, thin with ribs showing, and were well known through the village for this skill. It was quite a dangerous task - due to rains some of the trunks could be quite slippery. There were snakes in many of these trees! As a kid I wanted to learn, so they tied a rope around my waist to get me to clamber up the coconut tree. I wasn't able to - you get calluses on your palms & feet & it cuts through the skin as well. If you stick a tall ladder next to the tree, and climb to the topmost rung, you can tie an iron sickle to a rod & using the sickle, chop off the coconuts - but you have to stay clear of the falling coconuts! So a robot harvester of this sort is quite welcome. Its a pretty ingenious device.
- weeksie 6y agoOne time as a tourist I stayed at a guest house in the Kerala backwaters. My host had several coconut trees and gave me a shot at climbing one. There was this contraption I harnessed to myself with a strap around the tree and I made it up a fair bit before realizing that there was no way in hell I was going to go any further, let alone perform any meaningful act of dexterity at the top of the tree. Everybody had a good laugh.
- grugagag 6y agoVery interesting way to climb. When I was a kid I used to climb various trees but nothing straight and branchless like a coconut tree. Just looked up this on youtube[0]. The safety harness makes sense and the the loop for the feet does as well. As it goes, in India the coconut climber job is dwindling fast so this robot climber is very good replacement at the moment. [0] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vTrjuL5WL9w https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vTrjuL5WL9w
- 6y ago
- wraptile 6y agoThere recently was a huge controversy in Thailand about using monkey labor for coconut harvesting which resulted in many shops and even countries considering banning thai coconut milk. [1] Since then I've been thinking: why is it so difficult to harvest coconuts? Surely a pair of long clipper or some sort of stick-like device ought to do it? I've popped a few coconuts myself of trees, it's not that complicated, right? > Coconut trees that are harvested for milk tend to be taller than 15m, so monkeys are often used instead. [1] So 15 meters is a lot of stick though, is it really not doable? Ladder and a stick? Surely there's a simple way to reach it? The only answer I manage to find is that coconut farmers generally can't afford _any expensive devices_ thats why they use monkeys or climb the trees or rig up these cheap dangerous devices. So reading the news about a bloody robot, the most expensive and complicated solution that can be applied to this scenario, just makes me laugh really. 1 - https://www.bangkokpost.com/thailand/general/1948652/slave-monkey-scandal-forces-rethink-of-coconut-trade https://www.bangkokpost.com/thailand/general/1948652/slave-m...
- solarengineer 6y agoThose who have coconut farms would afford and appreciate this device, though. It’ll help them harvest coconuts on time. Also, being a robot created in India, the price outs highly likely to be much lower priced and affordable compared to something invented and made in the US or Germany, for example.
- a012 6y agoNot all coconut trees are the same. And also harvesting coconuts are dangerous job. The established coconut farms (and backyard trees) are very tall, combining with too many heavy fruits, it's an incident waiting to happen both for harvester and people on the ground. So the safer way to harvest coconut is to climb to the top, tie a rope, saw the fruit branch and rappel. I can't say for Thai's method, though you can't just use a long stick and cut the fruits.
- thaumasiotes 6y ago> There recently was a huge controversy in Thailand about using monkey labor for coconut harvesting Well, I read the article. Why exactly is this supposed to be a problem? By all accounts, it's a good idea that works well.
- atarian 6y agoReminds me of a similar machine I saw for pruning tree branches: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=x6UZ_2OAHNI https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=x6UZ_2OAHNI
- jb775 6y agoThat's awesome...what a massive productivity jump from manual pruning. Requires a pretty expensive and modern tractor though.
- pflanze 6y agoI'm not sure you're aware, but this video has massively sped up the original recordings. It seems irregularly, too, like humans walking are only sped up about 2x, while the machines themselves more like 4x. Of course they had to cut the sound. I saw some (presumed) original recordings a while ago, and found the machines impressive, there was no need to speed it up.
- rootsudo 6y agoI enjoy the conversation here. So many people are assuming there is true thought in OPEX, CAPEX, and employer rights and employer safety in these operations. As others mentioned, Thailand used Monkeys. There is so much of a disconnect between this crowd and the farmers and the people this robot will actually replace. What is the average annual income of a farm hand in Thailand, Philippines, or any country that has coconut farms with farm hands? How about preventative maintenance? Tariff, taxes and VAT (yeah they're all the same thing.) "Additionally, while human coconut harvesters were found to work faster, Amaran could work for longer, potentially making up the difference." It's controlled via a human, so, not really "work" longer, and then to scale up, how many robots do you really need vs available farm hands from the local province? I don't see it succeeding or replacing farm hands for the reasons above.
- 01100011 6y agoI don't think you should interpret the article as saying they have solved automated coconut harvesting. This is a prototype which could eventually be integrated with other components to form a system which, at some point in the future, could replace manual labor. Of course there are many situations where automation may never make sense. Then again, an automated solution may enable more growing scenarios to be profitable. It is good people are working on things that may not bear fruit for decades.
- rootsudo 6y agoThe ironic part is, literally, it will not bear fruit for decades. "On fertile soil, a tall coconut palm tree can yield up to 75 fruits per year, but more often yields less than 30. Given proper care and growing conditions, coconut palms produce their first fruit in six to ten years, taking 15 to 20 years to reach peak production."
- culturestate 6y ago> There is so much of a disconnect between this crowd and the farmers and the people this robot will actually replace. I look at it this way: these machines allow farms to replace workers from one, evidently shrinking pool of semi-skilled labor (farmhands who can and are willing to climb a coconut tree) with workers from a different pool (people who can be trained to operate a remote-controlled robot) that's growing. This article and the comments here make it seem like coconut harvesters are mostly freelance farmhands, so I could imagine a scenario where you end up with, you know, Uber for coconut harvesting. There's no reason the farms need to really care about the costs associated with owning the machine, when other people can take on that responsibility and compete with one another to offer farmers the lowest cost per coconut.
- suyash 6y agoIn the meanwhile in Thailand, they have innovated differently https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lnnucgquEZ0 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lnnucgquEZ0
- dehrmann 6y agoI don't know that much about coconuts, but I grew up in an agricultural region of the US. Practically everything than can be easily mechanized has been, or people are working on it. Coconuts are large and hard, so they're much easier to mechanically harvest than something like berries. The big difference is coconuts aren't produced in rich countries where labor is expensive.
- culturestate 6y ago> Coconuts are...much easier to mechanically harvest than something like berries. The big difference is coconuts aren't produced in rich countries where labor is expensive. To harvest berries or olives or apples, something in the vicinity of "put a tarp down and shake the tree really hard" is usually a fairly reliable method. Coconuts don't quite work that way, as anyone who grew up in a place with coconut palms and tropical storms can attest. Not to mention that they're often 30 feet or more off the ground...
- dehrmann 6y agoI think only olives are harvested like that. Table (i.e. non-juice) apples are too fragile to knock to the ground. For berries, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bt73GOk4JRY https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bt73GOk4JRY. Strawberries are different because they're practically on the ground. Not to discount your point. Coconuts don't work like any of these.
- culturestate 6y agoYeah, I took a bit of literary license there. My point was that for most crops, the hardest part of mechanical harvesting isn't[1] actually getting the thing off the tree or the bush or the stalk, it's what happens after that. A combine doesn't do its magic at the head, right? Coconuts are the opposite, and I think it's a more difficult problem than it appears to be. 1. Full disclosure, I'm not a farmer or an engineer, just a guy who has spent some time studying agricultural automation.
- ssaannmmaann 6y agoI wish the students and the teacher the very best. Here is another one that Youtube suggested: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=c7ip4G-QwDw https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=c7ip4G-QwDw
- aaron695 6y agoI'd be going drones if doing anything techy as a solution to pick coconuts. I feel like specialist equipment is going to cost to much IRL. Drones will continue to advance and have more people who can work with them. Not saying drones would be cost effective either, but I think at least you can pivot. Also see Sreamers - https://m.imdb.com/title/tt0114367/ https://m.imdb.com/title/tt0114367/
- jb775 6y agoDrones aren't currently feasible. They don't have good battery life, they can't carry much weight (for a saw or w/e to chop the coconuts off), and precision cutting would be very difficult without propellors eventually clipping something.....then you have an electric saw dropping 30-50ft out of the air which is terrifying.
- aaron695 6y agoYou can just tether a power line to a drone so weight and batteries don't matter. And don't use a death saw. This is why you'd do a drone. It's a good learning experience directly to industry. A tree climbing robot is way more abstract. Which might be good depending on the degree. But you'll never work on tree climbing robots in real life. Neither will ever be used by farmers to pick coconuts, so it depends on what you want.
- gnicholas 6y agoTethered power + laser cutting would solve the weight issue and the don't-drop-a-saw issue. Not sure how thick the branches are that need to be severed, though. But drone solutions seem much more efficient, especially given how long it takes to set up the robot featured here (15 mins per tree). This time would undoubtedly be reduced in production units, but variability in trunks will always complicate things. With a drone, it doesn't matter.
- mkl 6y agoA drone-carried laser powerful enough to cut branches that thick seems like a pretty big ask, not to mention the accidents when the laser shoots past the branch! Dropping a drone that heavy would be dangerous whether or not it had a saw blade. I think you could get the setup down to 30 seconds with parts that clip tightly together, e.g. how folding bikes work. The controls seem like a bigger problem, as automating that for the wide variety of natural trees, conditions, and lighting seems challenging. Having it crawl to the next tree and wrap itself around it to climb would be pretty neat too.
- MurMan 6y agoIs this contraption actually a robot? A robot has some automatic function or autonomy. I would classify this thing as a coconut harvesting machine.
- axaJay 6y agoThey still Poo in Loo. They need to fix their problems first
- tcoff91 6y agoAre you for real? If this article was about some roboticists in west virginia inventing this, would you say "They still smoke Oxycontin and die of fentanyl left and right, they need to fix their problems first". San Francisco has more than its fair share of human feces that isn't where it belongs and I doubt you'd make the same comment if this was invented there. India has plenty of issues, but that doesn't mean that people there can't freely pursue things like robotics because there are problems.
- jamisteven 6y agoI feel like a drone with image processing and a saw blade is a far better solution here.
- stronglikedan 6y agoThe similar idea I've been pondering for a few years now is a drone with a laser-scalpel of some sort, paired with a ring shaped net to prevent the coconuts from splitting when they hit the ground. The laser would cut the whole cluster, instead of individual coconuts, for power-consumption's sake, so the net would have to be strong enough to accommodate that. I pondered it with a saw blade at first, but the cluster's stem is not firm enough, making it hard to even saw by hand with a pole saw.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- egghese 6y agoIt is quite interesting to read through the threads here. Most people generalize India in terms of society or income. The south of India is pretty different from the northern part. The state in the video here especially is vastly different in terms of socio-economic structure from the rest. The caste discrimination is almost non-existent in the Southern part of Kerala. In the context, it won't affect your choice of life or jobs available to you. Or won't face any discrimination in day to day life. Thanks to a strong Communist/Marxist political presence. In terms of economy, the southern part is well off, there are few pockets of poverty. But poverty isn't as visible as rest of India https://www.thehindu.com/news/national/southern-comfort-indias-global-poverty-rank-improves/article23866587.ece https://www.thehindu.com/news/national/southern-comfort-indi... Coming to the robot/contraption. Growing up in an environment with an average-sized coconut farm. The device is completely useless. The assembly time per tree, even if its 5 minutes, would take 5*200 trees -> 16 hours in just assembly. And this amount of trees get covered in almost 2 days of 6-hour labor in a season by manual labor. Also, coconut harvesting isn't just about plucking the coconuts, but also involves cleaning the top. Picking the right coconut to be plucked etc. In that aspect, the robot would do more harm to the farmer. Though the cost of labor is high, a serious farmer is going to convert a portion of his yield into oil, which gives a decent margin. Also, this won't be the only crop they depend on. My family had a rubber plantation along. Labour shortage is a real issue and it isn't economically profitable for someone with about 20 trees or so. But this device under the current design solves only one problem, i.e plucking and solves it very badly.
- Bang2Bay 6y agoEven in TamilNadu where there is no maoist presence, and strong right wing sentiment, poverty has diminished. poverty was because of denial of education by the british system, that favored the rich.
- Abishek_Muthian 6y agoI'm from Southern India as well. We have four coconut trees in our house, it's as common as having a lawn in U.S. but having coconut trees has economic benefits to us as coconut is part of our daily diet. The trees are over 25 years, it's taller than a two storey building[1], it's getting harder to find someone who can bring down the coconuts as the article states and also to maintain the trees(debris). Many of our neighbours have removed their trees for the same reasons and we have started to contemplate it as well, but it's hard to think about as these trees are like our family members. So, naturally I've thought of mechanical devices which could solve this problem, there have been numerous attempts to solve this problem by various institutions and independent inventors incl. use of robotics like in OP; but those without human intervention hasn't made it mainstream and only those devices which help a climber climb fast/safe has seen some success. [1] https://imgur.com/gallery/1KBjCcj https://imgur.com/gallery/1KBjCcj
- ensiferum 6y agoWhere i come from utility poles used to be (probably still are in fact) made out of wood and the electricians who would need to climb them in order to conduct their work would use special built contraptions attached to their legs. https://www.finna.fi/Cover/Show?id=lusto.M011-138214&index=1&size=large https://www.finna.fi/Cover/Show?id=lusto.M011-138214&index=1... I wonder if something like those would also work for climbing coconut trees?
- Bang2Bay 6y agothe reason why these coconut jobs pay less is because, the product does not fetch too much. there is stiff competition for the produce to be sold within few days. some posters discussing discrimination have no sense or understanding. the discriminated 'part' was the entire country. I grew up with coconut trees. I do all the hardwork mentioned and would take the coconuts to be sold and would get no more than 1 rupee in the late 80s. people did not have money to pay for coconut. if it costed more they would go without coconut for a couple of weeks.
- zhengiszen 6y agoEven monkeys are gonna be layed off...
- andi999 6y ago"As the population increasingly moves towards tech jobs, there's now a shortage of coconut harvesters in India." Is this really true? Is there a shortage of low skilled labor in India?
- makach 6y agoVery interesting work! I didn't see any cameras or any obvious sensors, is the robot autonomous or being remote-controlled? I always heard tell-tales about how dangerous it is to harvest coconuts and be near coconut trees. If the device can harvest quick and safely nothing is better.
- ShradhaSingh 6y agoWe Indian's love coconuts
- htnsao 6y agoBoston Dynamics should make a monkey robot for this application.