3 ms·
Email is particularly broken regarding spam for at least two reasons: - it's a distributed system and not really a federated one: you can set up your own SMTP
by littlestymaar 6y ago
Email is particularly broken regarding spam for at least two reasons:
- it's a distributed system and not really a federated one: you can set up your own SMTP agent and send mails to anyone without prior registration to a federation.
- anyone can impersonate anyone: if I want to send an email pretending I'm bill.gates@apple.com there's no built-in mechanism to prevents that.
Theses aren't fundamental features of federations, and came from a design which just overlooked how many bad actors email would attract when it became mainstream.
- remram 6y agoYou can set up your own Mastodon or Matrix server and send messages, I am not sure which federation you're thinking of that requires "registration". The way the impersonation problem is dealt with in ActivityPub is very similar to DKIM in the SMTP world: the sender uses a cryptographic signature (HTTP signature) to prove that he is allowed to send messages from that actor. Of course this doesn't prevent someone from sending spam from their domain, in either case.
- TeMPOraL 6y ago> I am not sure which federation you're thinking of that requires "registration". Which makes me wonder, how come we call these systems "federated" in the first place? Federations I'm familiar with feature a central authority composed of representatives from the member states. That authority controls admissions and membership, and usually has some level of additional authority over members, along with capability to enforce it. None of that is present in these "federated" systems.
- wmf 6y agoSince many federated systems use DNS, technically ICANN is the central authority. But looking at how the terminology is used in practice, "federated" refers to systems with N users per host while "P2P" describes systems with one user per host.
- remram 6y agoThe "central authority" is the working group which authors the protocol specs, similar to how a federation of states' central authority would edict laws. There is actually some debate as to whether it's really a federation if the central authority can override member states (as per https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Federation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Federation)
- bantunes 6y ago> it's a distributed system and not really a federated one: you can set up your own SMTP agent and send mails to anyone without prior registration to a federation. One could say publishing an MX record on your domain is that registration.