2 ms·
> Instead we're stuck with ephemeral IPv4 addresses that geo-resolve to cities hundreds of kilometres away. Yay! This reduces the amount of information mega-co
by throw0101a 6y ago
> Instead we're stuck with ephemeral IPv4 addresses that geo-resolve to cities hundreds of kilometres away.
Yay! This reduces the amount of information mega-corps can glean from me with minimal effort. Given that I'm in Canada, I often get French-language ads served to me because somebody thinks I'm in Quebec (I'm not).
> Why-o-why wasn't IPv4 64 bits long to begin with?
Because it was a research project whose designers didn't expect it to escape the academia and take over the world; Vint Cerf:
> As we were thinking about the Internet (thinking well, this is going to be some arbitrary number of networks all interconnected — we don't know how many and we don't know how they'll be connected), but national scale networks we thought "well, maybe there'll be two per country" (because it was expensive: at this point Ethernet had been invented but it wasn't proliferating everywhere, as it did do a few years later).
> Then we said "how many countries are there?" (two networks per country, how many networks?) and we didn't have Google to ask, so we guessed at 128 and that would be 2 times 128 is 256 networks (that's 8 bits) and then we said "how many computers will there be on each network?" and we said "how about 16 million?" (that's another 24 bits) so we had a 32-bit address which allowed 4.3 billion terminations — which I thought in 1974/3 was enough to do the experiment!
* https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=17GtmwyvmWE&t=26m18s https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=17GtmwyvmWE&t=26m18s
IPv4 with its 32-bit addresses was the "test" system which, if it worked, would then be turned into a production system later. "Later" turned out to be 2012 when World IPv6 Day was announced.
So per Vint Cerf, if you want to run the "production Internet", use IPv6.
- dublin 6y agoAnd yet, despite far-from optimal allocation, no one is worried about running out of 48-bit MAC addresses, which need to be globally unique. That's because 64K the size of the Internet is more than adequate.
- throw0101a 6y agoThe original (experimental) Ethernet paper published in 1976 only had 8-bit addresses. They then went into 'production' with the DIX Ethernet II standard in 1980 with the now well-known 48-bit MAC, however the standard states that at the Physical Layer the maximum number of stations was 1024 (§1): * https://ethernethistory.typepad.com/papers/EthernetSpec.pdf https://ethernethistory.typepad.com/papers/EthernetSpec.pdf So while yes, the address space was bigger, the scope over which Ethernet had to work was much smaller and less ambitious (IMHO). No routing involved for example.