4 ms·
He's confused or misinformed. He's correct that the UK did ban slavery within the UK rather early (or, more specifically, it was found to be illegal by the cou
by rsynnott 6y ago
He's confused or misinformed.
He's correct that the UK did ban slavery within the UK rather early (or, more specifically, it was found to be illegal by the courts), and did ban it in its colonies rather early, but absolutely there was slavery in the UK a long time after the Romans, though not in particularly large numbers after the Normans. The UK was, however, the second largest participant in the Atlantic slave trade (Portugal has the dubious honour of being first).
Also, English people were never enslaved by the Normans. More or less the opposite; the Normans phased out chattel slavery, which was quite common in England when they showed up.
Or, alternatively, of course, he could be referring to the United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland (the current one) which has only existed since the early 20th century. The slavery was all under the United Kingdom of Great Britain and to a lesser extent the United Kingdom of Great Britain and Ireland! (Of course, the reference to Romans and Normans would argue against that rather silly interpretation...)
It's fairly common for British people to fixate on the fact that the UK was largely single-handedly responsible for abolishing slavery in the west (via the Navigation Acts in particular), while somewhat discounting the fact that the UK had previously been a huge part of the problem.
- tombert 6y agoOk, this proves that at least one other person thought this sounded strange; I thought maybe I was missing some minutia since I'm just some goofy American.
- 5thaccount 6y agoAFAIK there were no African slaves brought to Britain. In British colonies but not in Britain, and certainly not in numbers that lead their descendants being a significant minority of the overall population. Most black people in the UK are recent immigrants from either the Caribbean or Africa. And that isn't splitting hairs as that is important in the context Cleese wrote about. Americans are hyperaware of and hypersensitive about slavery, whereas the British don't have day-to-day reminders, and slavery is not as defining in the culture as, say, 2 world wars and one world cup. Think of it like Seattle vs New Orleans. The cultural consequences of geography and settlement/migration patterns creates a slightly different culture in each city, despite a shared US history.
- DanBC 6y ago> It's fairly common for British people to fixate on the fact that the UK was largely single-handedly responsible for abolishing slavery in the west (via the Navigation Acts in particular), while somewhat discounting the fact that the UK had previously been a huge part of the problem. And also ignoring the fact that banning the trade in slaves isn't the same as banning slavery; and ignoring the fact the when slavery finally was banned it wasn't banned everywhere; and most of the slaves became "apprentices" (ie still unpaid) for a few years before becoming free; and that reparations for slavery were paid: to the slave owners, not to the slaves. There's a bunch of stuff about colonialism that people in the UK refuse to engage with.
- vimy 6y ago>It's fairly common for British people to fixate on the fact that the UK was largely single-handedly responsible for abolishing slavery in the west (via the Navigation Acts in particular), while somewhat discounting the fact that the UK had previously been a huge part of the problem. The West didn't invent slavery, something that existed on every inhabited continent for thousands of years, but it was responsible for it's abolishment. Don't you think that's something to be proud of? “What was peculiar about the West was not that it participated in the worldwide evil of slavery, but that it later abolished that evil, not only in Western societies but also in other societies subject to Western control or influence. This was possible only because the anti-slavery movement coincided with an era in which Western power and hegemony were at their zenith, so that it was essentially European imperialism which ended slavery. This idea might seem shocking, not because it does not fit the facts, but because it does not fit the prevailing vision of our time.” ― Thomas Sowell, Black Rednecks and White Liberals
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- rsynnott 6y ago> Don't you think that's something to be proud of? Er, I mean, if I was William Wilberforce or someone I suppose I'd be moderately proud of that, yes! As someone who had no involvement in it and was born nearly two centuries after the first steps, I think it'd probably be a little bizarre for me to be proud of it. Seems totally irrelevant to whether the UK had slavery or not, anyway.
- vimy 6y ago> As someone who had no involvement in it and was born nearly two centuries after the first steps, I think it'd probably be a little bizarre for me to be proud of it. It works both ways though. By the same logic, the West shouldn't feel guilty for slavery and stop the self-flagellation. It's relevant to what you said. You implied that people from the UK try to wash their hands of slavery by saying they played a big part in ending it. And I'm saying they are right to use that as an argument against those who ignore history and try to pin slavery soley on the West. Without Western Civilization slavery would still be acceptable today. It took the Middle East until the 1960s! to abolish slavery. And it took Western pressure.
- oh_sigh 6y agoFrom the context immediately following his statement, it seems fairly clear that he meant we didn't have slavery...to the extent that it happened in the Americas. His statements imply knowledge that slavery actually existed in some form in England: > When I was studying law, there were three key dates. There was a legal case in which it was established, I think in the seventeen-hundreds, that slavery was wrong in the U.K. Then there was the slave trade, which I’m proud to say William Wilberforce and the Quakers did a great deal to stop. And then there was the final thing about actually using slaves in the Caribbean territories, which stopped quite some time before [the United States]. So the idea of slavery is not as carved into our conscious and unconscious as it is into an American’s.
- rsynnott 6y agoYes, he goes on to contradict himself a bit. The initial statement is clearly incorrect, though. And while it might be true that slavery isn't as much a part of the national psyche in the UK as in the US, it, er, probably _should_ be. 30 years isn't that much of a difference. There are plenty of practical reason that it _isn't_; the ending was of course far less dramatic, and it was far away. But I do think there's a tendency to de-emphasise it a bit too much. > From the context immediately following his statement, it seems fairly clear that he meant we didn't have slavery...to the extent that it happened in the Americas Only if you discount the colonies. (It probably is fair to say that British colonial slavery tended to be a _little_ less nasty than American slavery, mind you).
- gnufx 6y ago> The UK was, however, the second largest participant in the Atlantic slave trade (Portugal has the dubious honour of being first) How does that square with the fact that the bulk of the enslaving for it was by Africans, by all accounts, which surely counts as participation in the vile business? (Barbary pirate slavers also ravaged the south coasts of the British Isles, as well as southern Europe.) That seems important context, which is either not known or ignored, amongst the beating up over what previous generations did.
- rsynnott 6y agoThe individual entities involved were _far_ smaller, and mostly don't have successor states. In terms of numbers, Portugal and the UK were clearly the largest offenders, unless one treats Africa as a single entity (in which case it would also be proper to treat Europe as a single entity).