8 ms·
MCAS does not typically activate at all. It only activates when the flight control systems think the plane is nearing a stall, the flaps are up, and the autopil
by tzs 6y ago
MCAS does not typically activate at all. It only activates when the flight control systems think the plane is nearing a stall, the flaps are up, and the autopilot is off. Most commercial flights should not come near conditions triggering an MCAS activation.
It activated in the two crashed flights (and the earlier flight by one of those same planes) because of bad data from an AOA sensor leading the flight control systems to think the plane was about to stall.
- KingOfCoders 6y agoBecause AOA sensors > 1 (2?) was an option but not in the base model.
- comeonseriously 6y agoGood grief, what is Boeing, the mafia? "Nice airplane ya got there. Should would hate for something to happen to it."
- VBprogrammer 6y agoThe parent is incorrect. They all have 2 AoA sensors. The option was a "AoA disagree" warning. It's probable that given the wide variety of warnings the pilots were experiencing in both instances it would have made little difference.
- KingOfCoders 6y agoThanks, I wasn't sure "(2?)".
- jacquesm 6y agoWhether it didn't have to or not is immaterial, it did activate, and did so within minutes after take-off. If it was rare then we would not have had any crashes at all.
- linuxftw 6y ago> MCAS does not typically activate at all. You don't have that data, and the FAA did not release the data. I looked for this information specifically in their report, they did not report this data whatsoever. So, making ANY statement about the rate of activation is pure speculation, and it's merely a Boeing talking-point.
- vilifiedtwin 6y agoThat's a classic fallacy. "I couldn't find it, therefore nobody can".
- VBprogrammer 6y agoThe circumstances under which the MCAS system are precisely described. Are you disputing that those circumstances are unusual in commercial flights?
- linuxftw 6y agoThere's no need to speculate. The FAA should be proving these statements. "Unusual" is an empty phrase when you're talking about millions of flight hours. Is it 1/100 flights unusual? 1/10 million flights unusual? The FAA can and should have obtained data on the activations of MCAS from the world wide fleet, and also compare on other similar aircraft (other 737s) how often MCAS activation conditions would have been met.
- jacquesm 6y agoI suspect that is because that would really blow up. It would show how many 'near misses' (thanks, George Carlin) there were and that number is likely a lot higher than the number of crashes. Keep in mind that without that data we are all focused on the two times MCAS led to crashes, we are all in the dark how widespread the problem really was and once that data is out in the open the FAA's reputation (or what is left of it) will be further down the drain.
- VBprogrammer 6y ago