3 ms·
> If we can charge a foreign reporter with espionage for the mere publication of something we consider secret He’s not being charged with espionage for “the me
by rayiner 6y ago
> If we can charge a foreign reporter with espionage for the mere publication of something we consider secret
He’s not being charged with espionage for “the mere publication” of secrets. He’s being charged with actively assisting a leaker in bypassing security systems: illegal conduct that took place in the US.
The attempt to gussy this up overlooks how Assange, if he did what he’s accused of doing, clearly crossed the line. The rules in the US are already very liberal here. If you’re really just publishing materials you got from a leaker, you’re protected. Going even further and saying someone should be protected even when they actively assist a leaker in obtaining materials illegally is a huge step further.
- gpm 6y ago> If you’re really just publishing materials you got from a leaker, you’re protected. My understanding is that they (the US government) have actually argued the opposite during the hearings.
- tehjoker 6y agoThey might be arguing the opposite, but my understanding is that he gave some tips for how to protect Manning's safety and maybe encouraged getting more documents if they were so inclined. That's something any journalist might do in the course of normal human behavior and legitimately so. All these documents turned out to reveal war crimes. The state shouldn't be able to hide behind these flimsy secrecy claims when they are murdering people.
- rayiner 6y agoPlease read the indictment: https://www.justice.gov/opa/press-release/file/1289641/download https://www.justice.gov/opa/press-release/file/1289641/downl... Assange was doing far more than giving a few tips and encouragement.
- tehjoker 6y agoWhich points do you find most troubling? It's a very long document and the beginning is filled with flim flam. It says he tried to crack a hash and didn't succeed and therefore didn't even give Manning anything useful. While cracking and giving info back could be problematic, getting info and cracking it is certainly not. In any case, it certainly does not rise to this level of indictment.
- rayiner 6y ago> It says he tried to crack a hash and didn't succeed and therefore didn't even give Manning anything useful. The indictment isn't clear whether he succeeded or not. But if you look at the March 10th communication, it's clear that Assange tried to crack the hash. If so, that constitutes an illegal conspiracy. Say your friend asks you to pick a lock so he can rob someone's house. You try to pick the lock and fail. Even though you haven't robbed the house yet, you're both guilty of conspiracy to rob the house. The attempted lock-picking is an "overt act" that completes the conspiracy: https://www.justia.com/criminal/offenses/inchoate-crimes/conspiracy/ https://www.justia.com/criminal/offenses/inchoate-crimes/con... > Finally, in most states, conspiracy requires an “overt act” taken in furtherance of the crime. This overt act does not have to be the crime itself, nor does it have to be an act that is illegal. Rather, the act must merely be a step taken in furtherance of the criminal objective, such as buying a weapon or holding a meeting to plan an attack. The act must also take place after the group of individuals has agreed to conspire.
- vbnaop 6y agoMy knowledge on the Assange case is limited (I have not read any leaked documents), but from the press I get the impression that he uncovered illegal acts. If true, it would be more like this: A friend sees that an illegal act is committed inside a house and asks you to pick the lock in order to go in and stop it.
- monocasa 6y agoBetter example, what if a journalist made a copy of a key for you so that you could continue to access a room containing classified documents after hours, as was the case for the pentagon papers?
- linuxftw 6y agoThe first part of what you're saying is true. I think the defense in this case has challenged that actually took place, and there's some questions about compelling the US to produce evidence or the UK courts considering the US's statements in trials as evidence to Assange's innocence. http://johnpilger.com http://johnpilger.com has lots of detailed information about all the proceedings and the complete lack of any semblance of a fair hearing in the UK.
- Fjolsvith 6y agoIts too bad that a jury cannot be expected to determine Assange's innocence at trial.
- shadowgovt 6y agoMeh, let the jury determine if his conduct was illegal. Unless America is a fascist country where we don't have juries, of course.
- linuxftw 6y agoThere are no juries in Guantanamo bay. Assange will likely receive treatment as an enemy combatant. We'll hold him indefinitely with no due process.
- boomboomsubban 6y ago>He’s being charged with actively assisting a leaker in bypassing security systems: illegal conduct that took place in the US. He's charged with attempting to assist his source hide her identity while acquiring files she already had access too. While he was allegedly doing this, neither individual was in the US. Assange was in Europe while Manning was in Iraq on March 8th, the date the conversation took place.
- thefucnjosh 6y ago> Assange, if he did what he's accused of doing, clearly crossed the line He exposed criminal actions that the U.S. was doing. He did so by using a source that had fully legal means of obtaining that evidence. >The rules in the US are already very liberal here. Why is Snowden in Russia then? Why is it that those people who are actually experienced with the US government, choose other countries rather than the protection of whistle-blower laws? Perhaps it's because the people who run our country don't actually abide by any laws and are instead just criminals?
- StavrosK 6y agoNot to mention that Snowden's only condition for returning to the US is that he receives a fair trial.
- jdeibele 6y agoWhy <is> Snowden in Russia? It seems clear that the release of the material was endorsed by Russia, whether they knew about it or not. Trump is not demanding his return. And Russia is not going to send him back because it would show a bad example for anybody else contemplating "doing a Snowden".
- laurent92 6y agoPause a second: I keep seeing the same arguments again and again about Assange. All of them have surfaced and settled. Next step should have been to invent some sort of court where those arguments are debated, dismissed or retained, and we should tally the arguments and determine who’s wrong. The justice system has existed from before Napoleon and it still seems it’s the fourth wheel of the shopping cart. Its role is to fix things in society by sanctioning malevolent people a posteriori, to prevent them from acting further and discourage candidates to malevolence, and determine where is the line in cases where there is no winner. So when is the last time our justice system fixed anything in our society, and why have we stopped innovating in terms of democratic advances?
- monadic2 6y agoIf it's illegal to report on a government clearly acting outside the interests of its people, what are the legitimacy of its laws in the first place?
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- MrsHippy 6y agoyou should take that rhetoric back to the agency PR briefing where you found it.