4 ms·
I wouldn't argue that it's not "fascistic", except in the sense of semantic gamesmanship, but it wouldn't surprise me to discover that it's not illegal. The law
by jfengel 6y ago
I wouldn't argue that it's not "fascistic", except in the sense of semantic gamesmanship, but it wouldn't surprise me to discover that it's not illegal. The law is like a billion lines of Javascript, written by high school students, over decades, without even a single unit test, with the server running continuously.
"Legal" consists entirely of the opinions of lawyers, who are literally trained in law school to see both sides of every problem and construct a defense either way. I suspect the DoJ would have no problem constructing a brief that it's legal.
Ultimately the decision rests entirely with more lawyers on the court, and if they happen to be predisposed, there is no higher power to tell them otherwise. Even a flagrant, direct contradiction of the text is completely irrelevant.
I'm not a lawyer so I don't know how that applies in this case. I just have little doubt that it already has been.
- karmakaze 6y ago> The law is like a billion lines of Javascript Best explanation--it's a huge collection of patches. There are key moments that revisit the spirit or unintended consequences but it's a largest legacy codebase that grows faster than the tech debt can be cleaned up.
- charwalker 6y agoIf you label a rival political other as an enemy of the state, especially when groups that support the state are known be more violent and deadly to Americans (police/white nationalists), that is inherently fascistic. A fascist government will not announce it is but rather that antifascists are enemies of the state. This has already happened and is simply ramping up. It will lead to stochastic terror and more bloodshed.
- mansion7 6y agoInteresting; So when Democrats label Trump a Russian agent, effectively treason, they are being inherently fascistic. And when the Democrats and their militia, Antifa, call their critics/disagree-ers/dissidents "Nazis" (who are also the enemies of our state) they are also being inherently fascistic. I have wondered why they support doxxing and harassing their enemies, strict ideological compliance, and looting/rioting/arson as a means of political influence. But now that you've explained it's due to their inherent fascism, it makes a lot more sense.
- perl4ever 6y agoI would suggest instead of arguing on the internet, going and reading letters, diaries, etc. from people who were living through WWII which would give some perspective on what fascists were like, what the propaganda was like, etc. "I know you are but what am I" was a very fundamental and common propaganda line of the fascists then, and there were good reasons at the time to not dismiss it entirely. I've been reading George Orwell's letters recently along those lines, where he grappled with British imperialism and why it was necessary to fight the Nazis. It has never been any more easy and obvious at the time to determine the bad guys than now. Oh, by the way, Orwell himself spent some time being a propagandist for the British.