4 ms·

Because: 1. Elon Musk has admitted many times since that point that he was wrong (something Trevor never does) about factory automation. 2. The solar tiles ex

Because: 1. Elon Musk has admitted many times since that point that he was wrong (something Trevor never does) about factory automation. 2. The solar tiles exist. 3. Turns out making super good AI takes more time and Elon is always too optimistic, that is still their goal however that they are working towards. 4. That's still their goal and they're working towards it. You can't call someone a fraud just because they haven't reached a goal yet and it's taking longer than expected.

1MoreThing 6y ago
Good advice that is applicable towards doomsday cults as well.
FireBeyond 6y ago
Is there any evidence to suggest that a "brain chip" will ever "cure" autism?
- valuearb 6y ago
  What would limit a brain chip from accomplishing that goal?
  - FireBeyond 6y ago
    Current understanding of autism is that it is a developmental disorder, and not something characterized by excess/insufficient hormones. It is hard to imagine how a disorder that challenges information processing in the brain could, with our very limited understanding of how such things actually work, be handled by a chip saying "You should respond to such stimuli in X manner, not Y manner". It's not a case of "X is handled incorrectly, tell the brain to do Y instead". I could potentially see such a thing working for, say, epilepsy, where we might be able to "mute" or counter a stimuli that causes seizure, but, at least for the forseeable future, I don't see "brain chips" working in contexts other than concrete causal links, stimuli, reaction/response mechanisms - I think one hint is that there's nothing we can do to "medicate" autism. Medications currently used are for "byproducts" of ASD, such as ADHD, anxiety, not the disorder itself. Indeed, the closest (and we're not particularly close) we have come to thinking of how to manage ASD is gene therapy, which wouldn't be manageable by a "brain chip".
    - valuearb 6y ago
      Autism is a broad spectrum of behaviors, but one consistent symptom is not being able to “quiet” excess stimuli (as I write this my daughter exhibits her self stimulation behavior by running back and forth across our family room).

1MoreThing 6y ago

Good advice that is applicable towards doomsday cults as well.

FireBeyond 6y ago

Is there any evidence to suggest that a "brain chip" will ever "cure" autism?

valuearb 6y ago
What would limit a brain chip from accomplishing that goal?
- FireBeyond 6y ago
  Current understanding of autism is that it is a developmental disorder, and not something characterized by excess/insufficient hormones. It is hard to imagine how a disorder that challenges information processing in the brain could, with our very limited understanding of how such things actually work, be handled by a chip saying "You should respond to such stimuli in X manner, not Y manner". It's not a case of "X is handled incorrectly, tell the brain to do Y instead". I could potentially see such a thing working for, say, epilepsy, where we might be able to "mute" or counter a stimuli that causes seizure, but, at least for the forseeable future, I don't see "brain chips" working in contexts other than concrete causal links, stimuli, reaction/response mechanisms - I think one hint is that there's nothing we can do to "medicate" autism. Medications currently used are for "byproducts" of ASD, such as ADHD, anxiety, not the disorder itself. Indeed, the closest (and we're not particularly close) we have come to thinking of how to manage ASD is gene therapy, which wouldn't be manageable by a "brain chip".
  - valuearb 6y ago
    Autism is a broad spectrum of behaviors, but one consistent symptom is not being able to “quiet” excess stimuli (as I write this my daughter exhibits her self stimulation behavior by running back and forth across our family room).