3 ms·
We made lots of progress in treating the new disease (covid) while the baseline of pneumonia/influenza death is stable or even decreasing. What's troubling you
by lm28469 6y ago
We made lots of progress in treating the new disease (covid) while the baseline of pneumonia/influenza death is stable or even decreasing. What's troubling you here ?
edit: it seems like the blue line decrease could be explained by:
"A death can be registered with both COVID-19 and Influenza and Pneumonia mentioned on the death certificate. Because pneumonia may be a consequence of COVID-19, deaths where both were mentioned have been counted only in the COVID-19 category."
So all in all we just got better at treating covid + social distancing/masks doing their job
- dustinmoris 6y ago> We made lots of progress in treating the new disease (covid) while the baseline of pneumonia/influenza death is stable or even decreasing. What's troubling you here ? Nothing is troubling me. I am curious to understand why flu deaths > COVID deaths. I think this is interesting enough for a curious mind to want to further explore. I agree that we got better at treating COVID today than 6 months ago, but has it improved THIS MUCH that it explains flu deaths to be more than COVID deaths for 3 months now? If that was true, then why would COVID ever become more deadly than flu again? Seems like a very unlikely reason which you've provided and I find it slightly unsatisfactory as it doesn't make quite sense. > "A death can be registered with both COVID-19 and Influenza and Pneumonia mentioned on the death certificate. Because pneumonia may be a consequence of COVID-19, deaths where both were mentioned have been counted only in the COVID-19 category." This just further highlights the strangeness about the higher number of influenza deaths than COVID deaths, because it proves the point that if someone was tested positive for both, they will be counted as a COVID death, so possibly hiding an even higher flu death rate at the moment.
- lm28469 6y ago> why would COVID ever become more deadly than flu again? We're still in the middle of a partial (or full in some cities) lockdown, if we stopped the numbers would most likely go up again. Don't forget that the peak of death at the beginning was due to high number of cases + hospitals being completely unprepared to handle it + no idea on how to treat the disease itself. I don't see anything that can't be explained by very restrictive measures (lockdown + masks) + better understanding and treatment of covid tbh.
- dustinmoris 6y agoEither I don't get what you try to say, or you don't get my question. I am not sure where we talk past each other so I'll try to re-clarify my question. I'm not interested to understand why COVID deaths have come down. That's quite obvious to me. I'm also not interested why flu deaths have come down, that's also quite obvious to me. I'm interested why flu deaths are currently higher than COVID deaths. Measures to fight COVID are also applicable to flu, so things like lockdown + masks do not explain why flu deaths are higher than COVID deaths, despite COVID being more virulent and more deadly. I hope my question makes more sense :)
- lm28469 6y agoYou'd need better stats to assert that though, you can die of pneumonia without having the flu. We don't know how many people got the flu vs pneumonia
- impendia 6y ago> What's troubling you here ? Given that many people are wearing masks, avoiding social gatherings or public places, practicing social distancing, and/or being meticulous about handwashing, one might expect the incidence of influenza -- and of every other contagious disease -- to drop precipitiously. But apparently this is not the case?
- lm28469 6y agoFrom one month ago : "Flu levels are unusually low right now, even for the summer. And the number of death certificates mentioning influenza or pneumonia is currently below the five-year average" https://fullfact.org/health/flu-covid-deaths/ https://fullfact.org/health/flu-covid-deaths/ I tried to find more stats but it's clear that no two sources are using the same protocol to count deaths and death causes, op's website doesn't seem to give data pre 2020 for this report so really there is no easy way to tell what's going on. All I can find is that flu is lower than usual and covid is going down, which both support the fact that masks and lockdown work. https://www.cdc.gov/mmwr/volumes/69/wr/mm6937a6.htm?s_cid=mm6937a6_w https://www.cdc.gov/mmwr/volumes/69/wr/mm6937a6.htm?s_cid=mm... https://www.theguardian.com/world/2020/aug/10/lockdown-england-reduced-flu-colds-bronchitis-coronavirus https://www.theguardian.com/world/2020/aug/10/lockdown-engla... edit: btw OP's graph only goes back to the beginning of the year, it doesn't matter if influenza goes up or down in that timeframe, what matters is to compare it to the average at the same time during the last few years