12 ms·
Companies can track your phone’s movements to target ads
- afpx 6y agoIs this an ad piece? The company I work for has been doing this for 7 years.
- fsflover 6y ago...and you think this is fine?
- travisporter 6y agoOff topic, but recently I've been devastated to learn that every single address I (a US resident) ever lived at, my roommates, even my month and year of birth are available on sites like spokeo and fastpeoplesearch. I just don't know where this info is coming from and I want to stop it. Maybe the Equifax breach?
- jcomis 6y agoIt comes from a lot of places. Voter records is actually a big source, but also I believe some of the various breaches have made it in. And all of those sites continuously crawl each other and trade databases as well. I had my identity stolen and after a lot of research I determined they were able to gather the info from all of these public sources. I have been trying to scrub myself from them for 3 years now. It's like playing whack-a-mole. Some are quick to delete, only to pop right back up again months later. Some just don't respond. Some require physical mailed requests. A few are openly hostile. You need to submit forms with google to get search results cache updated for each page. You also need to clear "associates" such as spouse, parents, children because your info appears on their profiles as well. Tedious process! I believe the best defense is to have a common name or create a ton of spoof info to confuse them.
- quercusa 6y agoOuch. Could you say a little more about the scrubbing process: Where to start, how to do it? Thanks.
- jcomis 6y agoLots of googling your own name and email address. Finding all the hits and searching for "remove" or "opt out" links (search "sitename+opt out" etc). Repeating the process for close associates, phone number, address. Then closely monitor. Submit search results cache removal as soon as it changes (https://www.google.com/webmasters/tools/removals https://www.google.com/webmasters/tools/removals). I've found it's best to do one giant wave of removals to avoid propagating from one site to another.
- coffeemaniac 6y agoYou need to go to each of these sites individually and request an "opt-out". (This is superior to a complete deletion of your data which some offer, because an opt out allows them to keep your name on a "do not share" list.) You can hire services which will do this like deleteme, privacyduck, or onerep. What most people do is spend lots of time researching these services to decide which is worth the price. I'd recommend looking at the "which sites do we cover?" sections of each service, and go to each site yourself to submit the opt-out. Most of these sites have a paid tier -- don't fall for it, the opt-out process will provide you a form in most cases which will allow you to see whether or not your info is in their records. Keep a spreadsheet, and go back to them on some timeline, or alternately hire one of the aforementioned services afterwards. Focus on the major data brokers first: Acxiom, Experian, Epsilon, CoreLogic, Datalogix, Intelius, PeekYou, Exactis, and Recorded Future. Good luck, and let me know if you have any questions.
- atomicfiredoll 6y agoI've seen this posted in a few places now. It lists out several of these sites with information about how to opt-out. Results may vary. https://github.com/yaelwrites/Big-Ass-Data-Broker-Opt-Out-List https://github.com/yaelwrites/Big-Ass-Data-Broker-Opt-Out-Li...
- 6y ago
- novaRom 6y agoI think many agents are in place since many years tracking everyone, accumulating information leaked from different breaches. I believe it is widespread today at least in several countries their intelligence really have a kind of "global human database" where everyone is tracked and all digital traces are carefully collected and can be used at appropriate moments for different interventions (like elections, policy change, trade agreements, etc.)
- stateofnounion 6y agoWhy do you think it's due to a breach? There are thousands of companies who sell and re-sell that kind of information.
- Chirael 6y agoYou can opt out, but it's a grueling, site-by-site process and they don't make it easy - often you have to do it several times. See https://inteltechniques.com/book7.html https://inteltechniques.com/book7.html for some strategies. It's tortuous and should not be this way - we should really have national privacy legislation, but all the companies who are based on (or just get extra profit from) surveillance capitalism will fight such a thing tooth and nail.
- ardy42 6y ago> You can opt out, but it's a grueling, site-by-site process and they don't make it easy - often you have to do it several times. See https://inteltechniques.com/book7.html https://inteltechniques.com/book7.html for some strategies. It's tortuous and should not be this way I totally agree with you about how unreasonably burdensome the process is (it probably took at least a solid 40 hours of effort for me to get my results mostly scrubbed from publicly accessible sites a few years ago). However, I think you have to put an asterisk next to "opt-out." In a lot of cases, your data might still be accessible in premium or specialized products (like those for law enforcement). I know of no law besides the California-specific CCPA that actually regulates opting-out, and a lot of these sites like like they're operated by sketchy people.
- coffeemaniac 6y agoYou're correct, but you're understating law enforcement's capabilities. They have access to all sorts of databases which you don't have access to "opt-out" from, if that makes sense, and many of which are illegal to provide misleading info to. (You can't put "John Doe" or a fake address on your drivers license, for example). I'd focus on the public data brokers and being much more careful about where you divulge your personal info.
- kevin_thibedeau 6y agoUSPS sends out address change info that you submit to them. Just like junk mail, this is a profit center so they won't stop doing it.
- foxdev 6y agoThis stuff was always public information. These sites collected it and charged to access it in detail. They basically replaced people who did this professionally. Gumshoe as a service.
- jp555 6y agoI think it's a little ironic people are so concerned about this kind of thing because so much of what annoys us about advertising is ads that are not relevant to us - due to the limits of targeting. Ads that are extremely relevant are not even considered adverting to us in the moment. Wont better targeting provide more of this sense and a perception of fewer ads overall?
- criddell 6y agoI find targeted ads extremely creepy. It's like I'm being stalked. I now turn off personalized ads wherever I can. Any politician that talks about regulating what data can be collected and how it can be used will probably get my vote. I want to see my browsing data protected as well as my video rental data.
- tetraca 6y agoI don't want to be sold products. I don't care how "relevant" it is to the particular subset of people I most resemble. I want precisely the information I asked for, and no more. Every bit of information extraneous to that, is another piece of garbage I have to wade through to figure out whatever I actually wanted to know or do. The most frustrating ads are ones that don't make themselves clear that they're trying to sell me something until the end and waste my time, when I have zero intention or desire of ever buying something to solve a particular problem. Or the websites that write content that is almost useful, just to get as many eyeballs on its ads as possible. Ads are the slurry of microplastic on the sea of information, of benefit only to whoever dumped them in the first place. And if I'm enjoying a fictional work, I certainly don't want to be interrupted with another person hocking another piece of junk, or worse, integrating the ads into the story and having Gandalf trying to sell me on Pepsi.
- ogre_codes 6y ago> I want precisely the information I asked for, and no more. Are you willing to pay for access to that information? Because ultimately whoever is providing content wants to be compensated for their time. I agree with your sentiment, but there is also a pragmatism here. (FWIW I am willing to pay for, ad free content and don't believe tracking/ profiling should be part of advertising or even legal without consent.
- donmcronald 6y ago> They’d rather not collect the data than send the message that they’re tracking users, “even if they may very well be,” he says. Because most people don’t have any idea of how pervasive the tracking is and very few people would be ok with it if they did. I don’t want my phone doing the kind of physical tracking talked about in the article and I don’t know anyone who would, especially for advertising purposes. Hard pass. I hope their company goes bankrupt some day.
- herodotus 6y agoI agree with your sentiment, but tracking is fundamental to mobile devices: for you to receive a call or message, the network needs to find your device. Therefore, your provider knows where you are (within some radius based on there cell tower triangulation anyway). I assume they keep this data and, possibly, monetize it.
- fsflover 6y agoIt is not true. Have a look at Librem 5: https://shop.puri.sm/shop/librem-5/ https://shop.puri.sm/shop/librem-5/ Even if your provider knows where you are (and Librem 5 has a hardware modem kill switch for that), it does not mean that the software can send your location to everyone, too.
- herodotus 6y agoI am genuinely interested in this, so I would appreciate your response. My assumption in the comment was that the phone provider keeps a log of device location information. It needs that information to cause your phone to ring. This is completely independent of any software on the device. Am I missing something?
- fsflover 6y agoYou are right, this is what happens. However, with Librem 5, you can switch your modem off at any moment if you need privacy. Obviously, calling won't work when it's off, but you at least can balance your privacy with the availability for calls. At the same time, the phrase "tracking is fundamental to mobile devices" does not tell the full story. Yes, it is fundamental for calling [0], but the parent comment said: "most people don’t have any idea of how pervasive the tracking is and very few people would be ok with it if they did". This is not (just) about the modem tracking, but also about the tracking built into the OS itself. There is no such thing in Librem 5: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yHcHi0TBFv4 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yHcHi0TBFv4. [0] and tracking is not fundamental for IP-native communications, which is what Librem 5 is trying to make the default option. Upd: "the phone provider keeps a log of device location information. It needs that information to cause your phone to ring" This is also not true. The log is not necessary for the phone to work, only its current location.
- AlexandrB 6y ago> "The old world of these predefined segments like soccer moms or other [ad] categories will start to decrease" Every time I hear someone in the ad industry talk, I have to laugh. "Soccer moms" is a stereotype, not some scientifically defined demographic. And they're targeting based on this after years of tracking and data harvesting?
- rchaud 6y agoWhen media organizations call up their contacts for a quote, more often than not, they'll get a stock quote that could have sounded somewhat relevant 10 years ago. People in the know about industry's state of the art are not in the habit of just giving that information away to the papers.
- mikece 6y agoFrom a civil liberties perspective, government agencies interested in investigating someone can simply buy location data from marketing companies to build a pattern of life or construct a social graph of a target, all without a warrant and without needing to answer anything via FOIA since the data was collected and processed by a non-government data broker. The FBI spends millions of dollars a year buying location info about people from the cellular companies and data brokers... this isn't an edge case.
- dtauzell 6y agoDo you know if foreign governments and corporations are able to purchase this data?
- klvino 6y agoShort answer, yes. The concept of "foreign governments" is very US-centric. This tracking is not a US-only concept and the connection of these data points is already being used in non-US markets by companies which cross these boundaries. The only differences with each market is the number of signals available for capture. For example one party operating in the US is capturing DNS activity while in Brazil they are capturing telecom data.
- LinuxBender 6y agoSo Vladimir Putin can track all US and EU politicians? Surely they might be interested if someone explained it to them in a way they could understand. Are there any limitations on what countries can acquire the data?
- gumby 6y agoSure. No restrictions and I don’t see why there should be — why would some random company in the US be assumed to be any more trustworthy than a company not in the US? There should be greater restrictions on info release and racking by US companies, but those restrictions should protect against all antagonists (corps, governments) both foreign and domestic. However there seems to be little impetus for protection at the moment outside some minor efforts in california.
- ffpip 6y agoI'm sure many people (even on HN) don't really realise when and where their phone calls home. If anybody is interested install this on Android and just run it for an hour to see the DNS logs. You can uninstall it later. https://github.com/AdAway/AdAway/releases https://github.com/AdAway/AdAway/releases Install the APK, turn it on and turn on the DNS logs. Run it for an hour or two.
- novaRom 6y agoCan you please be more specific? What should an average Android user expect to see in those DNS logs?
- ClikeX 6y agoNot the OP. But as I understand you would be able to see all the outgoing requests. And thus how much your device phones home. Considering it's an adblocker app, I'd imagine you'd specifically see all the times it tries to ping back to ad companies.
- ffpip 6y agoInstall the app. Then close all apps and don't browse any sites for 1 hour. Then open the app and check the logs. Just see if it phones home to Facebook, Taboola, Google, Adjust and some other 200 or so companies.
- crispyambulance 6y agoWhen you say "phone home", how can we determine what kind of info is it sending to places like Facebook, Taboola, etc? What does "phone home" actually mean?
- izacus 6y agoIn most cases this comes from mobile ad/analytics frameworks (Facebook Ads/SDK, Google AdMob, StartApp, Chartboost, MoPub, etc. etc.). They usually ping back with usage counters and probably other analytics data. In many cases those SDKs even join data between apps on your device (e.g. you give your age to app A, your name to app B, your location to app C and they merge it on the backend). This data is then shown to users and in a lot of cases also sold in bulk. Note that most of these frameworks target iOS first and Android second - due to population and revenue.
- satokema_work 6y agoThis one's obvious. I've gotten ads ON OTHER PEOPLE'S DEVICES targeting me (a habitual blocker of ads). They were very industry specific and I was hanging out with people that would have nothing to do with that industry.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- fsflover 6y agoFun fact: Apple tracks your location and keeps its history, too: https://support.apple.com/en-us/HT207056 https://support.apple.com/en-us/HT207056, see "Significant locations". They claim that this info is only stored on the device. My watch is always in Airplane mode, bluetooth is always off, only wi-fi is on. And the watch actually has a pretty precise location history in the settings. How?
- orisho 6y agoPresumably through WiFi beacons. Apple and Google can give you approximate location using a list of nearby WiFi beacons
- fsflover 6y agoWhich means the location is actually transferred to Apple, does not stay on the device!
- ActorNightly 6y agoThe whole goal of Google/Apple "increasing privacy" in this way is to basically have a monopoly on user data, and thus gate any mobile advertising behind them. This is all revenue based, nothing to do with actual privacy. When I can take a smartphone, uninstall any apps that phone home, and then block/uninstall any apps that listen for external traffic, all without breaking core os functionality, then I would believe that those companies are truly concerned with privacy.
- fsflover 6y ago> When I can take a smartphone, uninstall any apps that phone home, and then block/uninstall any apps that listen for external traffic, all without breaking core os functionality, then I would believe that those companies are truly concerned with privacy. Here is the phone you are searching for: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yHcHi0TBFv4 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yHcHi0TBFv4.
- gruez 6y ago>Fun fact: Apple tracks your location and keeps its history, too: https://support.apple.com/en-us/HT207056 https://support.apple.com/en-us/HT207056, see "Significant locations". isn't that opt in?
- ogre_codes 6y agoIt is disappointing when articles like this provide only vague/ incomplete implementation details. Is this something we can mitigate? I don't think all apps are given access to this movement data which occurs in the background so it should be something we can disable for specific apps or just not turn on for any apps.
- gruez 6y agoAFAIK gyroscope/accelerometer data aren't gated behind a permission prompt on ios or android, so it's not something you can "turn off".
- ogre_codes 6y agoWhile your app is running, this is true, but if the tracking is limited to times when the app is running, the value is going to be quite limited. They specifically mention getting information about whether you are a runner or riding the subway. If you are out running, you don't have an app open, your phone is in your pocket. I'm pretty sure on the iPhone, getting this kind of data while your app is in the background requires access to the health data which is behind a permissions dialog. This is why I'm frustrated about the article. It doesn't say how the data is gathered or even really hint at it. The implication is it's a ubiquitous, unavoidable problem, but I don't think that's the case.
- Nextgrid 6y agoI remember reading the privacy policy of Snapchat and refusing to install it because they explicitly mentioned accelerometer data. I’m pretty sure they (and a lot of other scummy companies) are using this data to track location and/or relationships between users based on correlated accelerometer data. If you are in a moving vehicle, the accelerometer patterns would be very similar and would reflect the movement/vibrations of the vehicle, which can be matched similarly to how Shazam is able to identify songs based on partial and noisy audio waveforms. If you have one user whose location and accelerometer pattern is known and then you have another user whose location isn’t known but their accelerometer pattern matches the first user’s one in the same timeframe (with some margin of error to account for clock skew) you can infer that the second user is in the same vehicle (thus location) as the first one. Multiple measurements over time would eliminate any potential errors.
- move-on-by 6y agouBlock Origin blocked 34 requests/elements on that page alone. Requests to Amazon, Google, Oracle. Tracking pixels, segment tracking, Ad displays, cookie notifications, you name it. This is all on a computer web browser where data collection is somewhat limited when compared to a mobile app.
- microcolonel 6y agoAfter scrolling to the bottom and back up, Brave blocked 69 (nice) “ads and other creepy things”, on the phone. I honestly barely go to sites like this anymore. Big media is just gross. The quality is dirt-poor, the business models are abusive, and as the Facebook era draws to a close and the money dries up, the production value is trash too. Ars is good in this category, but still bleh.
- rchaud 6y agoIf this was 30 years ago, Ars would have been a print magazine you'd have to pay maybe $4.99 for. And they'd still struggle. Magazines with ads and subscription-based models went out of business all the time. The ones that survived either appealed to the widest possible demographic, or had a deep-pocketed benefactor keeping them alive.
- aschatten 6y agoI disagree that the quality is dirt-poor. I can still find a decent amount of good articles on Ars Technica, but they also have a lot of noise dedicated to generating clicks and likes. The article posted above is a good example.
- codeisawesome 6y agoApple - please address the Background App Refresh vector of leaking location data constantly.
- skarz 6y agoAndroid and iOS should add a user permission for sensor access.
- doopy1 6y agoThe problem is that people blindly grant the access needed.
- jb775 6y ago> Google and Apple have taken steps this year they say will help users shield themselves from hundreds of companies that compile profiles based on online behavior In other words, Google and Apple are using their platforms to eliminate advertising-profile competition.
- swiley 6y agoAbandon smartphones, everything about them is centered around selling your behavior. If you actually want a handheld computer get a pinephone.
- pluspp 6y agoAre there any good nonprofits to give money if I'm interested in fighting this kind of stuff?
- rchaud 6y agoWhat does "fighting" mean in this context? Money will not change anything if the lobbyists on the side of the advertising behemoths continue to have the ear of lawmakers. Facebook and Alphabet are two of the world's largest corporations; they, and the giant cottage industry of analytics and ad arbitrage companies are entirely dependent on maintaining this status quo. Even Apple, a company not reliant on ads, succumbed to advertiser pressure and held off on introducing changes that would limit their ability to collect tracking data.
- alexwatson405 6y agoGood point in the article that barring apps from aggressively tracking users (which is a good thing IMO), creates more power for companies like Facebook/Apple/Google/Amazon that already have access to the data
- jtsiskin 6y agoDoes the iOS/Android permissions model really allow accelerator access at all times? Otherwise this article sounds alarmist
- pkulak 6y agoTelephone companies are the ones keeping track.
- tomasreimers 6y agoIt's fascinating to me that gyroscope and accelerometer data don't seem to require permissions or explicit user opt-in on smartphones (at least that was true a few years ago and still seems true from a quick Google search, although I'm not sure if things have changed). As a side-channel, I've read about them being used for: - This. - Audio recordings of users (https://arxiv.org/pdf/1907.05972.pdf https://arxiv.org/pdf/1907.05972.pdf) - Keystrokes (https://medium.com/@tomasreimers/axolotl-a-keylogger-for-iphone-and-android-a8b7b62cdab4 https://medium.com/@tomasreimers/axolotl-a-keylogger-for-iph..., this one is shameless self-promotion and also why I'm interested in the topic) To me it seems that there are so few legitimate use-cases for device motion (mostly fitness related and https://www.cyberdefinitions.com/definitions/SMTH.html https://www.cyberdefinitions.com/definitions/SMTH.html) that it's almost shocking you can access them by default.
- matheusmoreira 6y agoPermission requirement should be generalized to all sensors, if not all sources of data such as the file system and internet.
- causality0 6y agoIndeed. I myself have hit significant roadblocks trying to block access to my device's compass. Between storage in a magnetic-clasp case and its car mount not facing directly toward the direction of travel, bad compass data significantly interferes with the ability of my navigation apps to tell the direction my car is going. I wish I could just force them to orient based on my direction of travel.