5 ms·
Phosphine, Life, and Venus
- aaron695 6y ago"There are small and variable amounts of phosphine in Earth’s atmosphere, and its origins have been the subject of much argument." They mention this in their press release video. We only think phosphine on earth is from life. I think step one would be to find the life on earth that creates phosphine.
- detritus 6y agoFrom another HN thread last week: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Will-o%27-the-wisp#Natural_explanations https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Will-o%27-the-wisp#Natural_exp... ( https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24493306 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24493306 )
- aaron695 6y agoCryptozoology aside, we don't know that phosphine would have come from life. We need to reproduce the current experiments that have suggested it's life and more importantly track down the organism, now it's become a big deal.
- parksy 6y agoI think this is the exciting thing, even if it turns out to be some abiotic process on Venus, there's will need to be new studies leading to improved understanding of planet-scale chemistry, in addition to new studies of life here on Earth. All of which will help refine the search for potential biosignatures on other planets.
- anadem 6y agoIn the video linked by dghughes [0] above Professor Sir Martyn Poliakoff outlines the mechanism by which life produces phosphine: bacterial breakdown of plant DNA. [0] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24543575 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24543575
- dghughes 6y agoProf. Martyn Poliakoff on Periodic Videos has a great explanation of phosphine discovery and in general. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NKWiOwt7eCo https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NKWiOwt7eCo
- someperson 6y agoGreat video, thanks for sharing
- julienchastang 6y agoGreat video indeed and Professor Poliakoff's hair is simply stunning to boot.
- tikititaki 6y agotldw: Rats cannot vomit.
- dghughes 6y agoHorses can't either.
- Kalekoa 6y agoThanks for sharing - good to know
- cmrdporcupine 6y agoThe author says: "these things could mean that microbial life gets underway pretty readily" -- Or given that both Venus and Mars are close neighbours it could just mean that interplanetary debris from Earth seeded these places. I recall reading that this kind of debris is actually quite common. I suspect we won't know until we can get samples back to earth to look at.
- Beltiras 6y agoMight have started on Venus too.
- dredmorbius 6y agoRecent thinking is that Hot Venus is a relatively new phenomenon, possibly within the past billion years. Its previous incarnation would have been more hospitable to familiar forms of life. https://zenodo.org/record/1253896 https://zenodo.org/record/1253896
- saalweachter 6y agoSo assuming the phosphine is in fact indicative of life on Venus, there's a wide range of possibilities on where life started how many times and where it spread, but I think the most hilarious possibility would be if we realized we'd accidentally seeded Venus with extremophiles on one of our early probes. (Which would basically be the least exciting option, although still kind of exciting WRT the possibility of terraforming.)
- cmrdporcupine 6y agoIt would surprise me given the low chances that a) the particular bug that hitched a ride was capable of surviving 1. interplanetary space 2. the atmosphere of Venus and 3. happened to be one to produce phosphene (according to TFA we don't even know what that is yet); and b) reproduced so quickly and efficiently that within 40ish years was able to be detectable from earth... Would be neat tho
- julienchastang 6y agoThis story reminds me of the Viking lander biological experiments where NASA initially discovered carbon chemistry favorable to life on Mars. But it turned out, there were inorganic explanations to the observed data. In short, they had not done the preliminary work of understanding the inorganic chemistry of Mars. The recent life on Venus story reminds me of that Viking experiment in that our understanding of inorganic chemistry of the atmosphere of Venus is probably far from complete.
- pmiller2 6y agoI agree. As much as I would like there to be microbial life in the atmosphere of Venus producing this excess phosphine, I suspect that there is some abiotic process happening that we don't understand as yet. Also, I didn't have "finding alien life" on my 2020 bingo card. :P In any case, even if this should turn out to be a previously unknown, abiotic chemical process, it is still a significant discovery. It's just not time to run out and say "we found aliens!" yet.
- tuna-piano 6y agoLayperson, but my intuition is the same. Also, as far as I understand it, phosphine is seen on other planets (gas giants?). If phosphine is seen on these planets, is it really a stretch to think anything but similar explanations? Is there a TLDR for why we understand that phosphine can be on other planets without life but not on Venus without life?
- ta8964586 6y agoThe temperature and pressure near the center of gas giants is crazy high. For Jupiter [0]: > The temperature at the core boundary is estimated to be 36,000 K (35,700 °C; 64,300 °F) and the interior pressure is roughly 3,000–4,500 GPa. It's similar to why you wouldn't be surprised to find diamonds deep underground in a mine, but if you found tiny diamonds forming in clouds that would be a major revelation. [0]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jupiter#Physical_characteristics https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jupiter#Physical_characteristi...