9 ms·
And after an HN comment touched some nerve, he took a few hours out of the life "working on backups" to explain to the rest of us why he thinks his lifes activi
by londons_explore 6y ago
And after an HN comment touched some nerve, he took a few hours out of the life "working on backups" to explain to the rest of us why he thinks his lifes activities were impactful. (And it seems it was!)
I'm not sure HN comments (intentional or not) should ever put someone else in a position of feeling they need to explain the impact of their life.
- wendelfov 6y agoOn the one hand I agree with you: no one should be expected to justify their life. (Who would have the wisdom to judge, anyway?) But on the other hand, I do think it's useful to ask whether the limited supply of genius in our society is being well-employed. Thinkers in the finance industry worry about this a lot, for example. Is it really a "good thing" that huge pools of quantitative talent are being drawn away from math and physics towards complex derivatives trading? Is shaving a few fractions of a fraction of a fraction of a second off the duration of a securities trade a good use of their time and talents? While I agree the original comment could have been more sensitive to the real person on the other side of the screen, I still think it asked a useful question and we're getting a good discussion out of it.
- cperciva 6y agoI didn't feel that I needed to explain things. Indeed, I could easily have ignored the comment and -- buried in the middle of a large thread as it was -- very few people would have noticed it.