6 ms·
A Patently Obvious Problem
- latch 16y agoSeems like a stopgap to actually fixing the patent problem though. This might help medium/large companies that are the victims of patent trolls, but small business/individuals would still have to deal with the realities of litigation and possible loss.
- wazoox 16y agoThat's nonetheless a step in the right direction.
- grellas 16y agoA few observations: 1. This is a sleeper case (i4i v. Microsoft) that has drawn relatively little attention in the public's eye. In reality, the stakes associated with it are huge and the interest it has drawn from key players in the tech industry is commensurate with those stakes. 2. The reason it is not a particularly exciting case from a headline standpoint is that it deals with what appears to be a specialist technical issue of patent law, that is, what is the proper "standard of proof" to be applied when a patent is challenged as being invalid? Should it be a "clear and convincing" standard or a "preponderance of evidence" standard? 3. In fact, the practical effect of this case on patents will be far greater than that of, say, Bilski, which dealt with the question of what constitutes patentable subject matter. Bilski covered business method patents only. The i4i case affects basically every case pending in the courts in which the validity of a patent is being challenged. 4. Among those in the tech world, just about everybody who is anybody has weighed in with a "friend-of-the-court" (amicus) brief asking the Supreme Court to throw out the clear-and-convincing standard in favor of a preponderance standard. The parade includes Google, Apple, Facebook, Intuit, Yahoo, Intel, Dell, HP, and others. A group of 36 law professors specializing in IP have also asked that the standard be changed, as has EFF. A superbly informative summation of the amicus briefs seeking to undo the clear-and-convincing standard is found here: http://www.law.com/jsp/cc/PubArticleCC.jsp?id=1202472695453&Patent_Litigation_Extra_Heavy_Hitters_Back_Microsoft_Supreme_Court_Bid_in_ii_Case http://www.law.com/jsp/cc/PubArticleCC.jsp?id=1202472695453&.... A good discussion also appears here: http://www.patentlyo.com/patent/2010/09/challenging-the-clear-and-convincing-standard-of-proof-for-invalidating-patents-in-court.html http://www.patentlyo.com/patent/2010/09/challenging-the-clea.... 5. By the way, the other side of the argument is well-articulated here: http://ipwatchdog.com/2011/03/13/supreme-court-patent-watch-i4i-files-brief-in-microsoft-case/id=15745/ http://ipwatchdog.com/2011/03/13/supreme-court-patent-watch-.... 6. So why is this so important and why do some companies (such as Apple) that frequently rely on patents to protect their competitive positions side with Microsoft in wanting to make it easier to find patents invalid? The simple answer: trolls. In essence, when a patent's validity is challenged and a jury is instructed to uphold it unless it finds "clear and convincing" evidence that it is not valid (owing to whatever ground, whether it be obviousness or existence of prior art or any other recognized ground for declaring a patent invalid), the challenge will almost certainly fail in the average case. The jury is basically told that the patent is presumed valid unless they can clearly find compelling evidence to invalidate. Since, in most cases, what is offered is conflicting evidence of varying types, jurors (typically not wanting to sort through a maze of technical evidence) will simply shrug their shoulders and say that the patent stands. If, on the other hand, the jurors are instructed that they are to determine the issue based on which way the preponderance of evidence tips, then they are to give no deference to the findings of the USPTO in upholding the patent but are to look at it fresh to decide whether the evidence shows that it is more likely than not that a patent is invalid. Thus, under current standards, trolls come into court heavily armed with law that says, in effect, uphold what the USPTO did unless you find a hellava reason not to. Microsoft, and the other tech companies, want this changed so that trolls have no built-in advantage when it comes to a litigated dispute over patent validity, i.e., they want a "level playing field" once the fight is on. 7. On the technical issue, patents laws are governed by statutes enacted by Congress but no existing statute requires that a clear-and-convincing standard be applied to this issue. The parties dispute the issue but Microsoft's position is that no such standard had been applied by federal courts (at least not with any consistency) before Congress created the Federal Circuit court to oversee patent disputes. Microsoft argues that the Federal Circuit has skewed patent litigation by arbitrarily making it more difficult to invalidate patents than Congress had intended. This was the same court, by the way, that had adopted the State Street test that led to a wild proliferation of business-method patents and that was struck down in Bilski. The Supreme Court is now being asked to bring a bit more sanity to the related area of standards for determining patent invalidity. It is hard to say which way this one will go. The patent bar is in an uproar that issued patents might not be deemed presumptively valid when challenged but might be much more vulnerable to challenge going forward, and so too are the trolls. Pretty much everybody else favors reform, including most of the tech industry heavyweights. My own sense is that this one is going to tip toward Microsoft and that we will get some measure of reform here. This would be a significant and very practical step toward undercutting a good measure of the power currently held by the trolls.
- 6ren 16y agoIn practice, this opens an avenue for jurors' ethical sense to come into play, especially regarding non-practicing entities; and likability/worthiness of the patent-holder and their business practices. Of course, legally, this is a strong argument against the change. Can't have community ethical standards messing up patent law! Also: if more patents are held invalid, companies might apply for fewer, freeing up patent examiners to spend more time on each one (assuming their funding wasn't cut because of fewer applications...)
- gruseom 16y agogrellas, these analyses that you post here are a treasure. I always learn from them. Thank you for sharing your expertise in a way that we can understand.
- jayzee 16y ago[off topic] but this is why we should go back to be seeing karma points. The only reason why his exceptional comment stood out was the length. It is hard to read every comment on every post. But some people post valid interesting links and quick comments and I am sure I am missing them because I can't zero in on them w/o seeing the upvotes
- scott_s 16y agoAnd it's the top post, and will likely remain so.
- jayzee 16y agoIts funny. PG likes conciseness. But the only way you can get heard on HN these days is by being verbose.
- scott_s 16y ago"Verbose" is not the same as "long." It means using many words when a few will do. Grellas's posts are long, but they are not verbose. Their length comes from the fact that they thoroughly cover subtle concepts. They have remarkable clarity, which is the opposite of being verbose.
- pkteison 16y agoOnce again, reporter engages in static analysis to ignore a good solution. Article confidently states that they get so many inventions that a thorough review would cost too many billions for fees to support. But why isn't charging whatever a proper review actually costs a good option? Raise fees a bit, raise standards a lot, and this half a million each year volume problem goes away too. I can't stand the idea that the patent office is so bad that we should only consider courtroom based solutions. Courtrooms are terrible too - way too much expense, too much uncertainty, and too large $s getting risked on what a jury decides or when a judge last had a snack break. They should have their place, but it shouldn't be the first line of defense or general solution for the problem.
- daydream 16y agoThe author is "is a professor of law at the University of California, Los Angeles." Not a reporter.
- Palomides 16y agosurely raising the fee is just going to screw over anyone without corporate backing, and do nothing to the corporations who already can afford to file most of the spurious patents?
- ataggart 16y agoBecause the FDA is such a good model for fostering innovation from individuals and small firms?
- arghnoname 16y agoIf one of the conceptual problems with a jury over-ruling a patent's validity is their lack of expertise, what if the jury in patent cases were composed of practitioners or experts in the field at question?
- vishaldpatel 16y agoIt mentioned in the article that it costs the patent office more money than what they charge for processing patent claims. Why is that? Why don't they just charge the full amount?
- daimyoyo 16y agoToday, you can file a patent for under $1,000(not including attorneys fees) depending on how many claims and drawings you have. If they charged the $10B they said it costs to review the number of applications they get now(around 500,000) your $1,000 becomes $20,000. At that price most independent inventors couldn't(or wouldn't) file. Remember that the entire purpose of the uspto is to encourage innovation and if it costs you a year's salary to get a patent on something that might not ever make you a dime then you're not going to be encouraged to innovate.
- cabalamat 16y ago> Remember that the entire purpose of the uspto is to encourage innovation While patents could in principle be reformed, in practise any reform is unlikely to work because people would game the system. The best way to encourage innovation would probably be to abolish patents altogether.
- dennisgorelik 16y agoAbolishing patent system would be an overkill, but shrinking it, say, ten-fold, would help.
- dennisgorelik 16y agoI specifically do NOT want to see patents for "innovations" that would never make a dime.
- JimL 16y agoWhy not just have an escalating fee system? Make it cheap for the first few submissions and increase to above the actual cost as the number of submissions for a single entity increases. (And put provisions in to avoid ownership by proxy submissions, or at least to make those approaches comparably expensive.)
- jakewalker 16y agoMy law firm (which is arguing Microsoft v. i4i before the Supreme Court) is hosting an event on the morning of May 4 in Palo Alto to discuss i4i along with two other major patent cases before the Supreme Court this year. Both of the attorneys who are arguing the case will be there. If you are interested in attending, get in touch with me.