5 ms·
I don't believe in irreplaceable geniuses that will solve every problem if given the time. Let's take the most archetypal genius: Einstein. First, he was here
by GuB-42 6y ago
I don't believe in irreplaceable geniuses that will solve every problem if given the time.
Let's take the most archetypal genius: Einstein.
First, he was here at the right time. Relativity was begging to be discovered, at the time we had observations good enough to invalidate the previous theories and fit the new ones. The mathematical groundwork was here, all that was needed was a spark of genius, which Einstein had, but I'm quite many others had it too. But maybe the others chose a topic other than physics, had a different education, or were born too early or too late...
Furthermore, Einstein essentially took 10 years to revolutionize physics. And then, not much. By not much, I mean he was still a top class physicist, but he couldn't restart the spark of genius, or he simply didn't have fuel for it.
So what if after finishing his work on general relativity, he just died, or pursued a career in management, or something like that. Many people would have probably said he would have discovered all the secrets of the universe, when in reality, it wouldn't have made much of a dent in history.
So don't worry and live your life as you want to, and don't expect too much of others. Things will get discovered eventually, and just because someone did great things in the past doesn't mean they will in the future, and vice versa.
- andreilys 6y ago“ just because someone did great things in the past doesn't mean they will in the future” I would say a Picasso or a Da Vinci is much more likely to create something meaningful given the track record at the height of their career, than some random person off the street. I think you’re underestimating the amount of effort it takes to master a given field, and the subsequent dividends that are paid when you achieve mastery.
- coldtea 6y agoNot necessarily. After some point, any new Picasso was just "more of the same". The reason his later works are still valuable is mostly because of our fetishism with the products of (already) famous artists + inflation by galleries and art merchants -- not because of any unique new insight/style/proposition/innovation/inherent value they had.
- andreilys 6y agoYou chose a bad example. Picasso is famous for reinventing himself and abandoning cubism (which he invented) to study and pursue classical painting.
- enkid 6y agoBut would those classical paintings be as famous if his earlier work wasn't? Probably not.
- gowld 6y agoAnd Billy Joel switched from Pop to Classical, but his Classical work wasn't as important as his Pop work. He's no Picasso but the pattern holds.
- coldtea 6y ago>Picasso is famous for reinventing himself and abandoning cubism (which he invented) to study and pursue classical painting. He abandoned cubism in his 20s or so. He afterwards had 50+ years of more boring work with less re-invention.
- pps43 6y agoThere's a good reason why many laws in math and physics have two or three names. They are oftentimes discovered simultaneously by several people and it's not always possible to tell who was first.
- ravitation 6y agoThis is essentially the theory of multiple discovery (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Multiple_discovery https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Multiple_discovery), as opposed to the heroic theory of discovery (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Heroic_theory_of_invention_and_scientific_development https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Heroic_theory_of_invention_and...). Additionally, I think the "inevitability of discovery" is more true now than it has ever been. In the early 1830s there were relatively few young naturalists and geologists looking at the islands and species of the south Pacific that were well positioned to develop a theory of evolution by natural selection. Today, looking at comparable questions, there are a great deal more young scientists competing to answer those questions. One thing that I think the original comment and this response both point out is that we as a society could still do a much better job of encouraging young thinkers towards challenging and meaningful problems, despite the fact that we do a much better job of it relative to the early 1830s. This encouragement influences not whether the problems get solved, but how quickly.
- bitwize 6y agoSo, in other words, it steam engines when it's steam engine time, and it relativities when it's relativity time.
- gowld 6y agoNot exactly. Steam Engine time doesn't come on its own; it's created by people. It's like any job -- we don't need all of the available workers, but we do need some. And in creative work, we need multiple perspectives to help improve the idea.
- enkid 6y agoThe funny thing is that the theory of evolution is an instance of multiple discoverers, one is just much more famous than the other. Alfred Russel Wallace is "the other guy." There are a few examples of truly heroic discoveries, but often they aren't recognized in their lifetime, the discovery needs other supporting discoveries to be identified. Mendel and Bayes are examples of people who should have revolutionized their field, but their importance wasn't recognized u til after their deaths. The progress of society is based on a lot of little discoveries over a few big ones. I agree that we need to be encouraging people to make those little discoveries.
- namenotrequired 6y ago> he couldn't restart the spark of genius, or he simply didn't have fuel for it. In other words, by the time he had proven himself for academia, it was too late to fund him. You are proving the OPs point that academia isn't the place to do novel research in.
- gowld 6y agoWhat do you mean? Einstein was well funded for decades, and his famous work wasn't funded at all.
- webmaven 6y ago> What do you mean? Einstein was well funded for decades, and his famous work wasn't funded at all. That's exactly what is being pointed out. His famous work wasn't funded, so perhaps funding at that point would have resulted in even more work at that level of insight and impact, or perhaps the we would have had the special and general theories of relativity sooner. Conversely, by the time he was famous and therefore well-funded, he was no longer producing work at that level. So, the idea is that funding doesn't go where and when it would do the most good. Personally I think generalizing from one famous person's track record isn't such a great idea, but there is certainly data that suggests that committees aren't particularly good at choosing which grant proposals to fund[0][1][2], and that it would be a good idea to choose at least some proposals randomly[3] (as long as they meet a minimal threshold of quality/sanity), if only to shift the incentives away from trying to game the system. [0] https://elifesciences.org/articles/13323 https://elifesciences.org/articles/13323 [1] https://www.pnas.org/content/115/12/2952 https://www.pnas.org/content/115/12/2952 [2] https://www.bmj.com/content/343/bmj.d4797 https://www.bmj.com/content/343/bmj.d4797 [3] https://mbio.asm.org/content/7/2/e00422-16 https://mbio.asm.org/content/7/2/e00422-16
- mathgladiator 6y agoI think there is another angle to it. After a major result, is the purpose to continue finding major results or broadcast, proselytize, and teach. One of the crazy things that I have found as a senior engineer, I focus much more on growing people in the space I created. Afterall, if the space I create can't be occupied by people, then I failed. For Einstein, how much of his time was dedicated towards the education of ideas versus trying to solve new problems. I don't know, but it is worth considering what the purpose of tenure. Is the idea of tenure to encourage people to find new results, or to continue teaching their ideas?