6 ms·
What software do people like for backing up Windows desktops? I really want something that ends with a full disk image that's easy to restore to a new device,
by toast0 6y ago
What software do people like for backing up Windows desktops?
I really want something that ends with a full disk image that's easy to restore to a new device, runs backups on a schedule (and will run a while after the next boot if the computer is off at the scheduled time), writes the images to a unix system on the LAN (either directly, or by writing to SMB), and doesn't cost an arm and a leg.
- theshrike79 6y agoI just went with Backblaze Personal. It's pretty much fire and forget. Doesn't provide a perfect full disk image, but it does store everything I need. I've done one full restore from them (fried motherboard from a power surge) and it went as smoothly as I could expect.
- aborsy 6y agoUnencrypted?
- ls612 6y agoThere's the option to set a password to encrypt it.
- aborsy 6y agoWell I should perhaps elaborate: does it offer end to end authenticated encryption with keys that never leave user’s device in an open source program? Another point, I suppose that backblaze comes with dedup and compression?
- jszymborski 6y agoRe: encryption, long-story short, the keys used to decrypt your data are stored in their data centers, but you can also encrypt those keys with a symmetric key which only you know. [0] Re dedup/compression, it's a bit irrelevant because their plans are unmetered. [0] https://help.backblaze.com/hc/en-us/articles/217664688-Can-you-tell-me-more-about-the-encryption-Backblaze-uses- https://help.backblaze.com/hc/en-us/articles/217664688-Can-y...
- bosie 6y agoregarding unmetered, i gave up on backblaze as their network connection seems incredibly slow. i think asking for compression and dedup is very relevant with them
- voltagex_ 6y agoYeah, their stock answer is "use more threads" but I could never use more than 30-50% of my upstream bandwidth. It doesn't help that the client is slow itself and seems to sometimes just stop backing up.
- tzs 6y ago> [...] but you can also encrypt those keys with a symmetric key which only you know ...until you need to restore from backup. You then have to sign in on the Backblaze website and enter that key, the files you are trying to restore are then decrypted on their end, and bundled up and sent to you. They say that the key is only ever in RAM, and only then briefly.
- philjohn 6y agoAs someone else commented - you can set a personal key. It's encrypted at rest (and in flight), but obviously Backblaze have that key.
- jaden 6y agoLast I checked BackBlaze only kept deleted files for a max of 30 days, making it a non-starter for my needs. I'm not sure if that's still the case.
- chinathrow 6y agoThat's what they say in their offerings/docs, but in fact I had data kept far longer than the 30 days (after the laptop registered for Backblaze was already scrapped and not been running for months).
- 4d66ba06 6y agoYou can pay more for year long retention now
- csnover 6y agoThis is not a great choice. The Backblaze client is extremely insecure—like, arbitrary remote root code execution insecure—and they seem to me to either not care or are too incompetent (or both) to be trusted.[0] [0] https://twitter.com/zetafleet/status/1304664097989054464 https://twitter.com/zetafleet/status/1304664097989054464
- encom 6y agoI like BackBlaze, but their client has always been absolutely terrible. Pretty shocked to hear that it's this bad, I and just paid for another two years in advance.
- paxswill 6y agoFor my personal machines I've been using Veeam's free version. It's not as full featured as what I'd like (I have it set for nightly backups), but it seems to do the job alright. It offers to make a bootable flash drive for you at installation to make full restoration easier. I have it backing up over SMB to a FreeNAS box, but it doesn't look like the backup images are easily readable (the look to be some Veeam-specific format, but I didn't look to hard at them).
- miked85 6y agoArq: https://www.arqbackup.com/ https://www.arqbackup.com/
- gruez 6y agoSeems to be file-based, which isn't what OP wants.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- huhtenberg 6y agoOh, man. No, just no. Arq 5 was OK. Arq 6 was shipped in a state that wasn't suitable even for beta. It corrupted and destroyed backups created with previous versions, couldn't complete new backups, wasn't working in fresh installs, had no documentation, no development plan and very poor communication from the dev addressing all these issues. The lash back was so bad that they closed their Twitter account and locked up Arq subreddit (only to claim later that it wasn't them, but Reddit itself that did that). A lot of people, me included, were expecting Arq 6 with a great deal of excitement only to witness one of the greatest dumpster fires in the recent history of ISVs. The news now is that they decided to just bury Arq 6 without trying to fix it and move on to Arq 7 - https://www.arqbackup.com/blog/next-up-arq-7/ https://www.arqbackup.com/blog/next-up-arq-7/
- miked85 6y agoInteresting, thank you. I have been using Arq 5 without issues and was not aware of this.
- sreitshamer 6y agoI'm very sorry you had that experience. I feel really terrible about it. It's been an extremely stressful 5 months so far. I tried to communicate the best I could about what we were doing -- a blog post, responding to all the reddit comments on the arqbackup subreddit that somebody else controls, answering thousands of emails. For at least a week I answered 300+ emails/day while simultaneously trying to diagnose and fix the issues people were experiencing. At one point I deleted the Twitter account because I couldn't cope psychologically with all the hate and the personal attacks. We set about immediately working to make Arq 6.3 "backward-compatible" with old Arq data (rather than import it into the new format, which failed unexpectedly for quite a few people). A month into it we tried making a UI that's "native" (like Arq 5) and realized we like it better too. So, we missed our June 30 deadline of making Arq 6 backward compatible, and decided to just start over with a native UI. We were going to ship that as Arq 6.3, but a few weeks ago realized that just shipping it as a point release would be way too disruptive. So it's going to be Arq 7. Arq 6 users of course will be upgraded to Arq 7 for free. I know we screwed up. We're trying really, really hard to make it right. We promptly refunded every single purchase for which a refund was requested. It's not about the money. It's about trying to do the right thing. I don't know what else to do at this point. If you have suggestions please let me know. > bury Arq 6 without trying to fix it I don't understand this. Arq 7 is the fix for the Arq 6 issues. It's free for Arq 6 users. We're not trying to bury anything. We've been really open about saying we screwed up and we're doing all we can to fix it.
- rzzzt 6y agoI guess none of my suggestions will help :) but I sometimes run "Create a system image" from the Windows 7 backup and restore page that is still hanging around. It has an option to save to a network location. I think that even though some pop-up messages tell you that the previous backup will be blown away, it actually is incremental to a certain extent, and the recovery tool in the installer sometimes does list multiple dates to restore from -- although I'm not sure if and how data retention can be controlled. Also disk encryption is removed on restore, and I think the backup is not encrypted at rest either; you need to keep it in an encrypted location to begin with. For file-level backups, I'm using an rsync frontend, QtdSync, but I also had success with Borg running under Msys2's Python interpreter.
- EvanAnderson 6y agoWindows system image backups with "physical" disks backing the storage (either locally-attached disks or via iSCSI) is actually reasonably nice. On later versions of Windows you can encrypt the backup with Bitlocker. Mounting prior backup generations via command line tools isn't too hateful. Bare metal restores of the entire system are very straightforward, too. Using a network location is somewhat less useful. You lose Volume Shadow Copy so it becomes a single generation full-backup-every-time solution. It's still easy to mount and to restore from, but marginally more useless. It would figure that Microsoft announced (last year, I believe) that the feature is no longer being developed.
- MikusR 6y agoMacrium Reflect free to a Samba (Raspberry pi) share.
- anonymousse1234 6y agoVeeam Agent for Microsoft Windows Free Edition
- pgrote 6y agoAcronis True Image works well for me. Scheduling with notifications of success/failure. You can backup locally to whatever windows can attach to or to a cloud. I've used to restore twice: same machine and new machine. Worked without an issue once the USB boot is created. I think the cost is reasonable for 5 workstations.
- magicalhippo 6y agoSame here. I've set it to back up each night to the NAS locally and to their cloud. Had a SSD die on me a few years ago, the primary disk. With no warning it just bricked itself. Thanks to Acronis my computer was running again less than an hour later. Have also used it to restore documents and similar I accidentally deleted. Another nice feature they have is their malware protection service. It detects programs modifying a large number of files in a relatively short amount of time, blocks them until you say if it's ok or not.
- jhoechtl 6y agorestic. It's fantastic and more importantly did'nt let me down even on faulty hardware.
- intricatedetail 6y ago+1 for restic. Incredible tool.
- huhtenberg 6y agoYep. One of the most thoughtfully designed backup tools in existence... and actively developed at that!
- huhtenberg 6y agoThere are two go-to options, at least as far as /r/sysadmin and /r/datahoarder people are concerned - Veeam Endpoint Backup [1] or Macrium Reflect [2]. However, another option is to back up just the data and reinstall the OS + programs in case of a disaster. I've been set up this way for nearly a decade, now using Bvckup 2 [3] as a replicator. This is faster and lighter on the system and it creates backups that are readily accessible. [1] https://www.veeam.com/windows-endpoint-server-backup-free.html https://www.veeam.com/windows-endpoint-server-backup-free.ht... [2] https://www.macrium.com https://www.macrium.com [3] https://bvckup2.com https://bvckup2.com
- voltagex_ 6y agoFor home use, I use Macrium and OneDrive. A good pattern I've found is to have a "clean" Windows 10 image (maybe with a few utilities), my personal data on OneDrive or a NAS and then something like PatchMyPC [1] to reinstall apps quickly. I also have bvckup2 (worth buying almost for the amazing UI alone) but I use it more for syncing some folders to and from a NAS. [1]: https://patchmypc.com/home-updater https://patchmypc.com/home-updater
- ycombinete 6y agoHey, just wanted to come comment here to say that since reading this 2 days ago, I've setup bvckup2 to sync all my important stuff. This is exactly what I've wanted for a long time now. Thank you so much. It's really exciting. Up until now I've been manually doing it via 7zip. But doing it manually is so unreliable that it doesn't even count. Or using Macrium, but it always felt like overkill. Bvckup2's archive/keep eveything feature for handling deletions is really great! Someone else in this thread mentioned Duplicati, which also looks really great. I might add that to my backup flow. I thought it was you, but now I can't find it anywhere in the thread. I guess they either delted or edited their comment.
- remote_phone 6y agoWindows already comes with a Backup and Restore. And it does both incremental backups and full disk images. I do both to my Synology nas every week. Maybe you’re not using the “Professional” version?
- tbyehl 6y agourbackup is proper client-server, multi-platform, does Windows well as both client and server, is trivial to get going and keep running, and is free.
- toast0 6y agoI didn't find urbackup trivial to keep running. For some reason I can't figure out, it stopped being able to backup the systemvolume, and I can't figure out how to get it to at least backup the C drives either. Other than that, it did seem like it fit my needs. :(
- Falkon1313 6y agoI've tried a variety over time, some of which seemed cool at the time, a couple of which I like. - Unison was a command line tool, like a better rsync, designed for backups. But it feels quite kludgy doing backups/restores from the command line in Windows. - DriveImageXML not only backed everything up, but created an XML file listing what was backed up where, so in the event you didn't have the software to restore stuff, you could still conceivably recover it (if you could write something to parse the XML and extract). It worked well, though it was slow. It got me through a few computer changes, and I had no problems restoring. - Windows' built-in backup software worked really nice until you upgraded and then wanted to restore something from a backup made in a previous version. Being able to restore is kind of critical though. - One of my employers required us to use a cloud backup solution which I won't name, but it was about as heavy as having McAfee Antivirus or similar on your system wasting most of the resources most of the time. - When I backed up my last computer (Windows 7) prior to upgrading to Windows 10, I had a free copy of Acronis TrueImage just for that purpose, and so far it has seemed to work beautifully. I have zero problems recovering files from that backup. - Currently I'm using Paragon Hard Disk Manager, which is fast and simple. So far it seems ok, but I haven't had to restore from it yet. So with that experience, I'd probably look at Acronis and Paragon. My concern always though, is - when I need to recover these files, how do I do so if my computer doesn't have the software that created the backup? (Assume new computer or freshly reinstalled system.) That's tricky and a spot where the things like Unison and DriveImageXML may still hold some value. If you can make a backup of your backup software separate from your backup so you can be sure to have it available to restore, then that might not be a concern. But it's always been a concern of mine - having a full backup of my data but in a format that I can't access. I think there's one that can make a virtual hard disk as a backup that mirrors the real one, so without anything but the OS, you could boot and mount your backup as if it were the system disk, but I don't remember what it is.