4 ms·
You've highlighted the problem with public discourse in the country. "I'm going to choose to ignore all scientific evidence because my brother can't get a job a
by paxys 6y ago
You've highlighted the problem with public discourse in the country. "I'm going to choose to ignore all scientific evidence because my brother can't get a job and it feels like H-1B is the cause" - sadly applicable to any policy topic where politicians & media are taking advantage of people's emotions.
- confidantlake 6y agoI am not ignoring scientific evidence. I read the paper, it is not convincing. This is not a double blind experiment, it simply looks at data and asserts causes. Take this paragraph: "An increase in the share of workers with an H-1B visa within an occupation, on average, reduces the unemployment rate in that occupation. The results indicate that a 1 percentage point increase in the share of workers with an H-1B visa in an occupation reduces the unemployment rate by about 0.2 percentage points. The findings suggest the presence of H-1B visa holders boosts employment among other workers in an occupation. The results provide no evidence that the H-1B program has an adverse impact on labor market opportunities for U.S. workers" There is nothing scientific about this. No experiment was performed. They simply looked at the data, saw there was lower unemployment in occupations with higher percentage of h1b, and then asserted that means there is no evidence that the program has an adverse impact on us workers. They are reversing cause and effect.
- robocat 6y ago> There is nothing scientific about this Soft sciences are harder than hard sciences to do. > No experiment was performed. > This is not a double blind experiment Do you really think experiments are a reasonable approach to political questions? I too dislike wish-washy science, but there really isn’t much other choice for many real world situations.
- mancerayder 6y agoSomeone above accused him/her being unscientific and they responded accordingly.
- karpierz 6y agoYou didn't read the methodology. They segmented the data by occupation, and then examined the data per occupation by year. Do you have a study that shows the adverse impact of H1-B visas on American workers?
- creato 6y agoI think an equally big problem is that a lot of "scientific evidence" like this doesn't pass sanity checks, and definitions of "net economic benefit" can vary and might not preclude strongly negative impacts to the average US citizen.