4 ms·
This has been discussed many times and it's not a good idea - it adds friction to the discussion, more than anything else. The threads would be full of pointles
by pvg 6y ago
This has been discussed many times and it's not a good idea - it adds friction to the discussion, more than anything else. The threads would be full of pointless meta.
The fundamental problem is that getting downvoted feels kinda bad - nobody ever asks for explanatory notes on upvotes. It's reasonable to wonder whether getting downvoted feels, say, too bad too soon and if there are UI ways to address that. But it's worth remembering that for downvoting to actually work, it has to feel at least somewhat bad. It's going to feel somewhat bad with or without notes from others about why they thought you ought to feel a little bit bad.
- leafboi 6y agoThere was an experiment conducted on HN a while back where a AI generated post by GPT-3 was tested on the HN community. A few people realized that the post was generated by AI and they mentioned this but they were actively voted down. I think there needs to be friction on the downvote because mob mentality is often wrong. Disliked opinions are still valid opinions that aren't necessarily wrong.
- loceng 6y agoThat's the whole point - adding friction. It also sounds like you'd be a fan of a parenting style where a child is punished but not told why. It's odd that you feel downvoting should be seen as punishment and not a mechanism for disagreement.
- pvg 6y agoIt also sounds like you'd be a fan of a parenting style where a child is punished but not told why. No it doesn't. What in the everliving fuck? Someone who disagrees with you about how HN should work is a fan of child abuse?
- jessaustin 6y agoMost HN commentators are not, in fact, children.