4 ms·
Skipping a grade might seem like a good idea for a gifted child but then bullying appears. Not recommended.
by euroderf 6y ago
Skipping a grade might seem like a good idea for a gifted child but then bullying appears. Not recommended.
- caymanjim 6y agoThe bullying is going to happen either way. May as well get them out of school sooner by accelerating the entire process.
- yowlingcat 6y agoFirst of all, bullying happens anyways. In fact, it's safer to assume that bullying is the norm rather than a deviance -- some are just better at being subtle than others. With that said, the gifted child is just as likely to treat that as a crash course in how to bully, in large part because they will inevitably become aware that penalties for bullying are more lax for them than for others, and they will be rewarded for figuring out how to outwit the system.
- gen220 6y agoI think, like many things, grade-skipping can either make sense or not make sense depending on the school, student, and classmates. I skipped a grade in elementary school (joint decision between my parents, teacher, principal, and at least nominally myself!), and didn't suffer from any kind of bullying. In my case, apparently I was actually creating trouble in my assigned grade, by being a chatterbox. I would finish my work early, and then proceed to hinder my friends' learnings by talking with them (understandably, because I was bored! you can only twiddle your thumbs or doodle for so long). Instead of punishing me, my teacher recommended me for skipping. Through my extended family and their friends, I know many kids who are in the same circumstances these days: straight-A "troublemakers", especially in elementary school. But nowadays, skipping grades is seen as "unfair" rather than as a valid solution to a legitimate problem. Because of something as arbitrary as their birthday, children are restricted from participating in a sufficiently challenging environment. I think we as a society are potentially trending too-rigid, especially in elementary school. I have no comment on skipping 2 or more grades, though; I suspect the benefit of skipping grades drops off exponentially around 1 or 2 "skips", even for very gifted children.
- Viliam1234 6y agoBullying happens in most schools, but is there a correlation with skipping a grade? I don't think so. Personal anecdote: I skipped a grade, and I was bullied. But I was bullied for a completely different reason. And there was one short kid in our class, so when people heard that "someone skipped a grade", everyone assumed it was him, not me. (As far as I know, he wasn't bullied.)