6 ms·
"The contrarian dynamic" by dang, from around a month ago. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24215601 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24215601 > The "
by dgellow 6y ago
"The contrarian dynamic" by dang, from around a month ago.
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24215601 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24215601
> The "contrarian dynamic" is that HN threads (and internet comments generally) are largely propelled by people making objections. Cunningham's Law touches on this [1].
The objections come in waves. In the earliest stage of a thread, they tend to be rapid negative reactions to the article. It's not that these are a community consensus, it's that they're the fastest reactions to feel, and the fastest comments to write—especially when the topic is provocative, when most of us are reacting from cache [2].
> Then a second wave of objections is generated by the first wave. Readers come to the thread, see the comment section dominated by those initial 'triggered' responses, and feel some version of surprised-shocked-dismayed at how the commenters all seem to be reacting in that way. This propels them to write defenses of the article, often carefully expressing more moderate or balanced views than the first wave—but they probably wouldn't have been motivated to post anything if there hadn't been the first wave of comments to object to!
> These second-wave comments tend to get more upvotes, perhaps because more people tend to share the more moderate view, but also because those comments tend to be more reflective [2] and therefore better written.
> This explains why the top comment in a thread so often begins (ironically) with "Wow, I can't believe the comments here"—or from the current thread: "All of these comments make me think HN has never interacted with a 5 year old" [3]—followed by a defense of whatever those objections were objecting to. Eventually you get objections to the objections to the objections—which reminds me of the line "My complication had a little complication" from Brazil [4], and also epicycles.
- MaxBarraclough 6y agoIt would interesting to study these phenomena quantitatively.
- dgellow 6y agoAny idea how that could be done?
- MaxBarraclough 6y agoNot something I'm qualified to comment on I'm afraid - I'm strictly in 'lazyweb' mode here.
- op03 6y agoUsually people who design interaction spaces know something about human behavior, spectrum of personality types/needs, social psychology, group dynamics etc and then design the space. But what has happened in the tech world, is obviously the reverse. All kinds of contrived/arbit spaces have been created and then behavior of the lab rats within are studied.
- tlb 6y agoCould you point to a good example of an interaction space designed this way?
- op03 6y agoStart with Jan Gehl or B.V. Doshi. EDIT: Also check out and explore - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Third_place https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Third_place
- tlb 6y agoAre you claiming that pubs and barbershops were designed based on an understanding of human behavior? It seems more like they've evolved over centuries, with everyone copying features that worked. Every time some architect tries to reinvent them based on theoretical principles of human interaction, the result sucks.
- op03 6y agoHere's a good write up of what I meant while responding to the comment about dangs insights - https://points.datasociety.net/how-not-to-know-ourselves-5227c185569?gi=b724fda54f42 https://points.datasociety.net/how-not-to-know-ourselves-522... "Third Place" is just one example of understanding what spaces people need and using it to drive design. Studying and understanding where people congregate and why, is what inspires and leads to the design of "Third Places" like the Starbucks store.
- loceng 6y agoI'm not sure if I'm surprised that dang didn't touch on to mention downvotes as an even more rapid "contrarian dynamic" mechanism; wouldn't it be nice if downvotes had a little more friction, effort required for the action - like qualitative text from the downvoter as to why a comment is being downvoted to then allow OP the opportunity to clarify or expand on their comment - "to be more reflective and therefore better written"? The downvote-comment doesn't have to be identified as being a downvote-comment, showing up as a regular reply. That added cost/friction may also act as a filter for lazy readers/skimmers or those misinterpreting what's said at first glance, and therefore if forced to include some critical text response along with their downvote then OP and other readers can begin to get to the bottom/foundation of the distaste, giving OP at least some guidance as to why someone/people are downvoting - arguably a valuable learning/crowdsourcing moderation tool/mechanism. I feel the added cost of time and mental effort for downvotes would add a great balance.
- vendiddy 6y agoI like the idea. Perhaps asking users why they are downvoting could help. Maybe not necessary to show their reason to others, but add friction and force someone to think twice.
- loceng 6y agoIf there's no witnessing or critique/scrutiny by the community possible then I don't think there will be the pressure necessary for quality comments to be made - and leaving a moderator to privately review them would likely have more comments left toward the spectrum of "this guy's an idiot" then toward side of constructive or useful criticism.
- ghufran_syed 6y agoHmm, what about being able to see a list of downvotes and explanations on a user’s profile? With maybe some minimum karma before you can see that on someone else’s profile? So there is potential scrutiny by the community, but not in a way that disrupts the original discussion?
- chris_st 6y agoI wonder if there's any value in having a post to HN be, in effect, a "Draft", with a timeout of (say) half an hour. You write it up, but you have time to reconsider and edit before it "goes live" and you're (at least psychologically) committed. Perhaps you have to come back after half an hour and officially approve it? This is starting to sound like work :-)
- nchelluri 6y agoI think they already do this, with the delay setting in your profile.
- jlevers 6y agoI think this is a great idea, with one issue -- it seems to me (and I haven't looked at this quantitatively, it's just an impression) that later comments sometimes get buried, so there's an incentive to comment sooner rather than later.
- chris_st 6y agoI guess I figured that everyone would be delayed, so the relative posting time would remain the same.
- jorgesborges 6y agoA dramatic solution, assuming this phenomena is something to be abated, is to simply remove replies. Why does every internet community by default have a feature that steers us to negativity and confrontation. I often find myself scrolling past the replies on here anyway to find the next comment that may be unique, useful and well-thought - not just an objection or tepid agreement to something that’s already been said. EDIT: suddenly aware of the irony
- pabs3 6y agoI found the approach taken by pol.is to be interesting, it is used in various places to develop rough consensus in multi-stakeholder situations. https://pol.is/ https://pol.is/ https://github.com/pol-is/ https://github.com/pol-is/ Taiwan use it for their multi-stakeholder decision making to find points of agreement. Their application of it to the Uber vs Taxis situation was quite interesting. https://debconf18.debconf.org/talks/135-q-a-session-with-minister-tang/ https://debconf18.debconf.org/talks/135-q-a-session-with-min... https://blog.pol.is/pol-is-in-taiwan-da7570d372b5 https://blog.pol.is/pol-is-in-taiwan-da7570d372b5 https://blog.pol.is/uber-responds-to-vtaiwans-coherent-blended-volition-3e9b75102b9b https://blog.pol.is/uber-responds-to-vtaiwans-coherent-blend...
- mlthoughts2018 6y agoThis is a poor model of Hacker News comment phenomena. It requires all this extra complexity in the theory (comment “waves” and “triggered” reactions, highly generic stereotypes of whether a responder is reflective and thoughtful, and whether this correlates with moderate opinions). From an Occam’s Razor point of view, this is a very poor theory, and I’d even go further and suggest it indicates unfair bias on the moderators’ part to implicitly subscribe to this judgment about early / quick responders. A competing, much simpler theory is that Hacker News, like everything else on the planet, is tribal and political. People add comments to support their tribe, and people use upvotes to support their tribe, while they use FAQ & guideline legalese, downvotes, shadow bans and timeout periods to punish opposing viewpoints and tribes they don’t like. I think the reason people look past this much simpler theory that comports much better with the evidence is that they want to protect a false sense that Hacker News is democratic and tolerant of unusual views, but it so deeply isn’t.
- dang 6y agoYou're making it sound more complicated than it is. The idea is simple: users like to make objections. Since users like to make objections, the initial comments tend to object to the article/title (because there's nothing else to object to yet), and later comments object to existing comments. Poof, "waves".
- claudeganon 6y agoDang describes dialectics.