5 ms·
My new clothes washer has an app. It requires access to location, and phone settings or the app closes by design. I don't think this stuff stops without legis
by duxup 6y ago
My new clothes washer has an app.
It requires access to location, and phone settings or the app closes by design.
I don't think this stuff stops without legislation.
- chrisbolt 6y agoWhat brand? So I know what to avoid in the future.
- duxup 6y agoLG
- brewdad 6y agoThat's really disappointing as LG has been my go to brand for many of my appliance purchases including a washer and dryer a few years ago.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- woadwarrior01 6y agoIt's the same with LG TVs. The remote app on iOS for my 2018 LG OLED TV does not launch without granting it location access. I don't understand why a TV remote app would ever need location access?
- thecureforzits 6y agoDo you HAVE to use the app to use the machine though? Can you just not enable wifi on itand use it like a dumb washer?
- duxup 6y agoThe washer absolutely works without the app. The app provides some benefits, but they're not required.
- ripply 6y agoI'm assuming it uses Bluetooth, if thats the case location access is required by Android to search for Bluetooth devices because Bluetooth devices don't move around very much and its possible to get your location if the app has access to a Bluetooth location database.
- ethanwillis 6y agoAnd on top of that I guarantee they'd start sending lawyers if you hack your own device.
- beached_whale 6y agoI don't think that one could say that is acceptable under the App store review guidelines if that was for iOS.
- nichos 6y agoYou can't legislate morals. Don't depend on the government to solve your problems, vote with your wallet.
- toxik 6y agoYou can absolutely legislate morals, and a lot of laws are exactly that: codified morals.
- tgsovlerkhgsel 6y agoYou can't legislate morals, but you can successfully legislate many consumer-hostile practices out of existence. Germany was pretty successful when it came to many dark patterns trying to trick consumers into "agreeing" to "contracts".
- distances 6y agoDark patterns were successful, or the preventing legislation was successful?
- tgsovlerkhgsel 6y agoThe preventing legislation was successful. All those "* by using this free trial you agree to pay 19.99/month for at least 24 months" scams went away basically overnight. The key to this is not to be afraid to aggressively add new dark patterns to the list of banned practices. An alternative would be aggressively hitting scammers who clearly rely on people missing the fine print with criminal charges for fraud/extortion (when they try to collect on the non-contracts). No idea why that wasn't done - the legal system is usually a lot more resistant to the "well, TECHNICALLY" thing than engineers think. Germany is really good about these rules. For example, a long list of practices, including mandatory arbitration, is explicitly forbidden (or forbidden in standard contracts) in § 308-309 BGB. § 312j BGB mandates clear disclosure that and what you're about to spend money on. The whole set of § 312-someletter is basically "we found another shitty practice and we're ending it now".
- m463 6y ago
- tgsovlerkhgsel 6y agoMany Bluetooth actions are tied to the location permission on Android, because you can use Bluetooth to locate the user through beacons. The downside of this is that you can' distinguish between apps that just want to use Bluetooth, and apps that are trying to get your device location through location services, and users are trained that "bluetooth app = location permission is legit".
- lanecwagner 6y agoBuy a different washer? Send that one back? Don't make it illegal to fucking build IOT devices...
- userbinator 6y agoThings like this are why I buy "dumb" equipment, which will remain obedient to you and not the manufacturer. My white goods are all many decades old. Washer and dryer are both entirely computer-free (mechanical controls) and don't even contain a single semiconductor (unless you count the indicator bulbs I replaced with LEDs.) Many people often think the house/life of a software developer is filled with "smart" things, and are astounded when they hear what I use. Maybe the younger ones are indeed surrounding themselves with this sort of predatory "smartness" and couldn't care less about the downsides, but not everyone in the industry thinks that way; sadly, I think those who don't want this crap are a dying breed.
- foepys 6y agoSame here. I try to buy appliances as dumb as possible. I know how fast software is being deprecated and my washing machine, fridge etc. are supposed to work for decades, not months.
- ryandrake 6y agoOut of all the terrible trends in technology today, I’m convinced that “unnecessary cloud-tethering” is the absolute worst. I should not need to sign in and get permission from the device manufacturer to use or configure a device or software I supposedly bought. I should not need you as an intermediary when I’m using it. I should not need to give you analytics on how I’m using it. You should not even know I’m using it! I don’t want an ongoing relationship with your company. Our relationship ends when I swipe my credit card. It getting harder and harder to avoid this trash too. I fear it will be normal one day.
- wojciii 6y agoThere should be a warning on the box that you need internet for this to work or enable it. I guess we should talk to the lawmakers at the EU (or wherever you live) to make this stop.
- Animats 6y agoOut of all the terrible trends in technology today, I’m convinced that “unnecessary cloud-tethering” is the absolute worst. Yes. If not only because "cloud" services typically live for only a few years. Then the device is useless.
- totetsu 6y agoThey have to check your location to make sure the drum only spins at RPMs that are legal in your country...
- toyg 6y agoOn the other hand, a new firmware for my recent Brother printer added a bunch of cloud-based features that are pretty cool (scan to dropbox, etc). When done well, this sort of thing is great. > I don’t think this stuff stops without legislation I agree, but sadly I expect it would quickly boil down to “click OK to waive all your rights, which you really want in order to make the device actually do what you bought it for”.
- Netcob 6y agoI think any network connectivity related to high-power (2000W or more) household appliances is a big mistake. Imagine someone hacks their flimsy IoT service and manages to start those 3kW heater elements in hundreds of thousands of washing machines all at once, what that will do to the power grid.