3 ms·
Is there any practical way to have less indoor CO2 than outdoor CO2, without needing to buy expensive single-use scrubber chemicals? Maybe presuming you live so
by derefr 6y ago
Is there any practical way to have less indoor CO2 than outdoor CO2, without needing to buy expensive single-use scrubber chemicals? Maybe presuming you live somewhere with cheap electricity and/or a cheap fresh water supply?
Basically I’m asking whether there’s a Maxwell’s Daemon-like device for separating the CO2 from the air, and venting the CO2 back outside, while bringing in the rest of the air. Like a CO2 scrubber, but without any need for CO2 sequestration, since you exist inside an open system instead of in a space station/bunker/submarine.
- beefield 6y agoThere are these things called plants that do that kind of stuff, so maybe if you have enough of them inside your house, they eat the CO2 away... :)
- derefr 6y agoI don’t think there’s any practical level of plant-having that would result in there being less CO2 in the house than in the atmosphere. IIRC, there’s some point in running an indoor grow-ops where you start needing to worry about spraying CO2-enriched air on the plants; but that’s just to accelerate growth, like a fertilizer. Or, sometimes, it’s because OPSEC requires you to not vent your smelly waste air — and because no human or animal lives in the grow-op house to convert O2 to CO2, the air becomes gradually CO2-poor. But that wouldn’t happen if even one human lived there; humans convert metabolize a lot faster than plants do.
- quaa55 6y agocame here for this.
- w1 6y agoI don't think this exists on a small scale yet. On industrial scales, CO2 is commonly removed with reusable scrubber chemicals, referred to as a group as amines. The amine acts as a CO2 solvent, removing the CO2 from the bulk gas. The 'rich' amine is then cycled to a separate location in the process where it is heated up, causing the CO2 to bubble out of solution, regenerating the amine for reuse, etc. I don't see any reason in principal why this can't be miniaturized, but it would be a challenging engineering problem. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Amine_gas_treating https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Amine_gas_treating
- dumbfoundded 6y agoAnother solution would just be to pump in cleaner air. You could imagine a truck that drops off a few tanks of CO2-free air.
- sfkdjf9j3j 6y agoPerhaps we can install oxygen lines next to our natural gas lines.
- dumbfoundded 6y agoI get your sarcasm but it'd probably mostly nitrogen.
- petertodd 6y agoRegenerative CO2 scrubbers exist: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Carbon_dioxide_scrubber#Regenerative_carbon_dioxide_removal_system https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Carbon_dioxide_scrubber#Regene... Sounds like aquariums sometimes use CO2 scrubbers, so regenerative CO2 scrubbers might be commercially available for that market: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5_GM5ZBzvdk https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5_GM5ZBzvdk
- calcifer 6y ago> Regenerative CO2 scrubbers exist AFAIK those still need consumables. NASA says there are ways to reduce the amount of consumables, but not eliminate them [1]: In the current [...] configuration, carbon dioxide is removed from the cabin and discharged overboard. The gases lost during venting must be replaced, and thus represent a consumable. By comparison, a closed-loop CDRA system could selectively remove carbon dioxide from the cabin air supply, and the concentrated CO, would be routed to a carbon dioxide reduction system, where the oxygen would be recovered, thereby reducing the consumables. [1] https://ntrs.nasa.gov/citations/20050210002 https://ntrs.nasa.gov/citations/20050210002
- petertodd 6y agoI think that quote is considering the oxygen in the CO2 to be a consumable, not the scrubber material itself. That's relevant on a spacecraft. But here on earth we've got plenty. :)