6 ms·
Their conclusion is that we should emit less CO2. Certainly a good idea, but their data clearly point to better ventilation. Better ventilation is something we
by GuB-42 6y ago
Their conclusion is that we should emit less CO2. Certainly a good idea, but their data clearly point to better ventilation.
Better ventilation is something we can do right now, that will improve things immediately and 100 years from now.
Maybe the best thing would be the mandatory installation of powerful ventilation systems with heat exchangers for new buildings, and incentives to upgrade existing installations. That would help with both problems: getting more fresh air and limiting energy expenditures which can, in turn, reduce CO2 emissions.
- fyfy18 6y ago> mandatory installation of powerful ventilation systems In my country that's already been a thing for the last few years. The HRV system is around €1000, so it isn't a major cost for the benefits you get. From this year all newly installed units need to be 90% efficient. Also "powerful" is probably not needed, the system I have at the lowest speed changes the air in my entire apartment every 3 hours, and is basically the same noise level as a barely audible computer fan.
- zdragnar 6y agoThe difference in scale between your apartment and most schools is no trivial matter. At my high school, our one building, with tall ceilings, large cafeteria and so forth, housed around 1300 people every day. Some are smaller, some much bigger. Moving all of that air at least once a day would require powerful exchangers indeed. If nothing else, it would probably be cheaper and better for students to have plants everywhere. One of my teachers' classrooms was like a tiny jungle. I can't say that it made a significant difference, but it was pleasant at least.
- baskire 6y agoPlants sadly don’t make a significant impact to indoor co2. I see a future indoor co2 sequestration device being incredibly popular
- londons_explore 6y ago> indoor co2 sequestration device If you're happy for it to have rechargeable cartridges, you could easily build one with a once/week cartridge change. The cartridge needs to be ~the same weight as all the food eaten by all the people in the building. The material the cartridge is made from is dirt cheap (literally limestone!), and recharging is a simple matter of heating it up. With a pipe to the outdoors and some vents on a servo, the machine could even auto-refresh its cartridge every day, making it almost maintenance free.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- ActionPlankton 6y agoI'm curious about this cartridge idea. I'm picturing a pipe with quicklime inside and coffee filters on the ends, with a blower to force air through. How tightly would the contents be packed? This is a little different from what I'd been thinking before your message, which would be more of a fluidized bed reactor -- like quicklime swirling around in air in a garbage can. I think that's closer to how some powerplants treat exhaust. I've read that there are microscopic changes to the quicklime particles after a couple absorbtion/heating cycles (their pores fill up or something), after which you need to do something to further refresh it, maybe by dissolving it and precipitating it back out of solution. This led me to considering whether aqueous chemistry might be better. The simplest would be to react air with calcium hydroxide (would you use a bubbler? Or a packed counterflow tower? Or a spray tower?) and collect the calcium carbonate that precipitates out. But, based on my shaky chemistry, I understand solubility of calcium hydroxide is low, so you do better with a two-stage process like the Kraft Process: 1. Absorb CO2 in contactor: 2NaOH + CO2 -> Na2CO3 + H2O 2. Regenerate solution in causticizer: - CaO + H2O -> Ca(OH)2 - Na2CO3 + Ca(OH)2 -> 2 NaOH + CaCO3 3. Decompose calcium carbonate: CaCO3 -> CaO + CO2 The concentrated NaOH solution would be very caustic, so you'd have to be careful with that, but apart from that none of this seems too terribly scary? Some parts of the above are endothermic, others exothermic, so maybe this could even let you shift energy from the summer (solar furnace?) to the winter when you need it, as part of the deal. Or maybe this is all too complicated and you should just use a canister of soda lime granules, like an anesthesia machine? ( https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Soda_lime https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Soda_lime ) I'd be interested to hear more from people whose chemistry is better than mine.
- stirbot 6y agoHuman's ability to concentrate is just one of many, many problems associated with increasing atmospheric CO2. We can't ventilate the troposphere.
- throwaway316943 6y agoLarge scale carbon capture would be more economically beneficial and would provide more direct control over atmospheric levels of CO2. Bonus points if you can find a good use for the carbon.