2 ms·
A lot of naming is misleading, in this case “extinct” should probably have been called “believed to be extinct”. Of course proving something is extinct is quit
by MichaelZuo 6y ago
A lot of naming is misleading, in this case “extinct” should probably have been called “believed to be extinct”.
Of course proving something is extinct is quite difficult, perhaps infeasible for the small organisms. So maybe also a “provisionally extinct” category?
- happytoexplain 6y agoThere are definitely cases where that distinction is made due to reasonable uncertainty, but there is no line. Proving it is more than difficult - it's impossible.
- MichaelZuo 6y agoWell impossible means that it can never be done, which I wouldn’t put past the capabilities of some far future civilization. There are a finite number of ways something can be alive, at least in the current consensus. ‘infeasible’ is probably a better way to describe our present capabilities.
- pvaldes 6y agoThere is a convention that an organism that can't be found anywhere by scientists (with a reasonable effort) in the last 50 years is classified as extinct. In the meanwhile is 'probably extinct' or even 'functionally extinct' (If only specimens of a sex, or unfertile remain) but is not the same category. This is a cultivar, not a species, but the idea is similar. If we talk of a fruit that was forgotten after 1920, yes, it was extinct. In any case the image of the dying tree with a last branch is suspiciously romantic, and wax fruits are not a real proof of anything. Without DNA analysis we can't guarantee that this is the real thing, could be also a seedling, a different clone mutated, or a forgotten cultivar that lost its tag, but is still sold in other place under a different name. When a fruit is forgotten there is normally a good reason. Maybe, being so similar to Cox's Orange, will show poor resistance to fungus diseases. There is no reason to reproduce a worse version of Cox (and in the article I would expect a genetic comparison between both apples at least).