3 ms·
Isn't Atwood one of the types who get all indignant about the "Blub" argument? Maybe he should think twice before utterly confirming it.
by gruseom 18y ago
Isn't Atwood one of the types who get all indignant about the "Blub" argument? Maybe he should think twice before utterly confirming it.
- jrockway 18y agoThe good news is that Atwood's blog is targeted at Joe Average Code Monkey. He's probably right to tell his audience to ignore metaprogramming; if they are willing to do what he says, it's probably a good thing they're not trying to write good code. All they would do is break things horribly, and then complain about how badly powerful tools suck. His writing mostly exists to make the people writing PHP pages with SQL queries mixed in with <table> tags feel like they are good programmers. Whatever. For those of us that actually know how to use powerful tools without cutting off our fingers... we have other blogs to read, and can safely ignore pretty much anything Atwood says. I even like XML a little more than I used to, just because he wrote a blog post against it ;)
- davidmathers 18y agoWhat you just said is exactly what Atwood is saying, and what Raganwald is arguing against. If you freeze any moment in time then elitism always seems like the most rational choice. But if you take into account the passage of time then elitism is a losing proposition.
- raganwald 18y agoStrangely, I find myself nodding in agreement with both of you. I simply must get back on my meds. Thinking... I don't know what Atwood really meant, it's just a blog post, but I do think there is a real distinction between "Hey you! Don't do that, it's dangerous!" and "You shouldn't be allowed to do that, you're not qualified." After all, I wrote this: http://weblog.raganwald.com/2008/04/is-strictly-equivalent-to.html http://weblog.raganwald.com/2008/04/is-strictly-equivalent-t... Which is definitely a kind of "Don't do such and such" article. But while I actually write code to make things I like easier, I have no interest in sitting down and writing code to make the things I don't like harder or impossible.
- jrockway 18y agoSure, but writing good code isn't "elitism". There are people that program for a living, but don't really "get it". They think "the elites" made up functional programming (and similar things) just to make programming harder. That's not true, the good programmers know that these abstractions make things easier. That's why we use them. However, if the "I hate thinking when I could be cutting and pasting" programmer is your blog's audience, it makes sense to agree with them. More ad revenue. I don't really see this as elitism, I see it as reality. For what it's worth, I have no problem trying to educate these developers and turn them into good programmers. My blog is mostly instructional, I give free talks at every conference I can, and I teach paid classes if companies really want to make sure their developers learn good practices. Some people can be educated, and I am always happy when people realize that writing good code is fun. However, some people really don't get what programming is about, and those people are going to criticize things that are "hard". (I really don't want to imply that Jeff Atwood is one of these types, but I don't really have any arguments disproving it.)