4 ms·
This is meant for the person making accusations of racism, not @beevirus, but this is where I can reply and I think it's important to do so even to dead comment
by ineedasername 6y ago
This is meant for the person making accusations of racism, not @beevirus, but this is where I can reply and I think it's important to do so even to dead comments given the "racism" accusation.
@Kednicma asked for evidence: A basic google search finds it. [0][1][2][3]. They complain of downvotes & karma lost: Those may very well come from the desire of many in this community to take basic research steps before leveling very serious accusations.
There is no reason to jump to "racism" so quickly merely because a biological difference is asserted between people of different ethnic backgrounds. Ethnicity is intertwined with genetic background, and it's not up for dispute whether or not genetics influence biology, it's practically axiomatic within the concept of genetics.
I acknowledge that research finding biological differences between ethnic groups can be ammunition for racists, but that must not be the automatic assumption, especially in this community where it violates the community guidelines to jump first to an uncharitable negative interpretation of someone's comments.
[0] https://americanbonehealth.org/nutrition/african-americans-need-less-vitamin-d-and-calcium/ https://americanbonehealth.org/nutrition/african-americans-n...
[1] https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3894250/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3894250/
[2] https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC5954269/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC5954269/
[3] https://web.musc.edu/about/news-center/2019/06/20/vitamin-d-deficiency-in-african-american-children https://web.musc.edu/about/news-center/2019/06/20/vitamin-d-...
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- Kednicma 6y agoHi! Welcome to the hill. First, let's remember the original context: The top poster used an NPR article which explored the systemic racism of vitamin D tests. One of the key findings was that the test results can be very disconnected from actual metabolic processes and seem to only be accurate for people with specific genetic backgrounds. Your [0][1][2][3] use those same systemically-erroneous tests (click through and look for 25). To me, this confirms that the problem's endemic to the system of medicine. In general, it seems that you believe that we well-understand vitamin D and thus clearly the situation is that there's a difference between white and black people. To me, however, what the situation says is that we poorly understand vitamin D! We've taken something that seems important because it was historically important to white people and tried to extrapolate it cleanly to all people, but it first needs to be cleaned of the racist lens. Indeed, from your [1], "Data on vitamin D levels in healthy African adults is scant." From your [3], vitamin D levels are experimentally low in African-Americans and Hispano-Americans. Occum's Razor begs us to justify why this isn't a race-poverty correlation, yet another indication that our society is systematically disenfranchising folks based on skin color and country of origin. With better diet might come better vitamin D blood levels. You know why this sort of research is ammunition for racists, right? It's because racism is the belief that humans don't form one single species. By considering African-Americans as having exotic genetics, research like what you've linked implicitly and directly backs the racist agenda. Finally: You seem to think that racism is something which tars and stains people, but that is from the same bogus essentialism that spawns racism itself. No, it's a series of beliefs about genetics, and those beliefs can be refuted. The reason why racism is a "serious accusation" is not because of some danger of ejecting valued contributors from the community; it is because it leads directly to people being shot in the street, sterilized in concentration camps, harvested for organs, etc.
- beervirus 6y ago> The top poster used an NPR article which explored the systemic racism of vitamin D tests. No, it did not explore systemic racism. It explored physiological differences between races.
- mperham 6y ago> differences between races. Race is a social construct, it's not a scientific category. There is only a continuous spectrum of skin tone. If someone is mixed parentage, what "race" are they?
- beervirus 6y agoThe lines are blurry, but that doesn't mean they don't exist. Is sickle cell anemia a social construct?
- IgorPartola 6y agoUgh. Look ignoring race is why people of color systematically get worse medical treatment. Look at Sickle Cell Anemia. It is widely documented that people of color whose ancestors were from Africa and sub Sahara are much susceptible to it. This has been studied extensively and all potential confounding factors have been ruled out. Is it racist to study this? Is it racist to use our understanding of genetic research to try to figure out how to treat this particular syndrome? Race the social construct is a social construct. We are the same species. Period, the end. But differences in genetics and physiology do warrant study because this is how we can find treatments and preventative measures to a multitude of disease. This is a lot like saying that research that shows that men are more susceptible to heart attacks then women is sexists because gender is a social construct. Gender is a complex topic that evolves with our evolving understanding of wha it means to be human on a philosophical level. But the X chromosome isn’t a social construct and has very direct very tangible effects. You can’t call it a social construct. In short: when it comes to how we build a society, recognize differences and account for them to bring as much economic opportunity equality to everyone. When it comes to medicine, study everything including genetic differences in order to get the best understanding of the problem at hand. Getting offended doesn’t get us closer to for example a cure for COVID, does it?