3 ms·
Calling the progression and availability of technology a “lottery” is definitely a confusing term. It implies concepts totally unrelated with how hardware devel
by MichaelZuo 6y ago
Calling the progression and availability of technology a “lottery” is definitely a confusing term. It implies concepts totally unrelated with how hardware development actually works.
Hardware and software co-evolve! There is no such thing as people creating hardware ex-nihilo. This reads more like a researcher venting about his limited budget and development capacities.
- ncmncm 6y agoHer. And you miss the point. Obviously they co-evolve, and the consequence is deeply sub-optimal systems, as a result of essentially random, momentary conditions.
- MichaelZuo 6y agoThanks. Yes it is possible that the systems are deeply sub-optimal, though calling ‘Hardware’ by itself a lottery is still misleading. ‘computer lottery’ or ‘hardware-software lottery’ or ‘systems lottery’ would all make more sense though that would make for a less catchy title. Though since not all the optimization parameters are known for complex systems with multiple stakeholders, or at least not known outside of a select few, i.e. what academic researchers face, we shouldn’t be too hasty in saying it’s definitely deeply sub-optimal. For example, there could be unknown, private, criteria that have been highly optimized for.
- ncmncm 6y agoUntil ~2002-5 we optimized for 8080 backward compatibility, at ruinous expense to performance. We still maintain it, albeit with less ruinous effect, except in GPUs and phones, which today do the majority of the computation, albeit to little effect. Those last maintain backward compatibility with a different, 1980s, design, albeit with another break at 64 bits that sacrificed the worst aspects. Essentially all mainstream processors emulate what amounts to a hypertrophied PDP-11, in order to produce good scores on benchmarks coded in C. A better language that does not attempt to model C might be able to use better processor designs that C cannot fully exploit, but we have no practical way to do the experiment.