5 ms·
I’m much more worried about a corrupt state that has the power to take away my freedom, liberty, and life than a corporation. A corrupt company can’t take my p
by scarface74 6y ago
I’m much more worried about a corrupt state that has the power to take away my freedom, liberty, and life than a corporation. A corrupt company can’t take my property through eminent domain and civil forfeiture or declare some phony “War on $X” that disproportionately is used against one group. The current administration is not going after Big Tech “for the people”. It is doing it expressly because they think Google, Facebook, and Twitter are being unfair to conservatives.
In what universe is Twitter any type of monopoly that needs to be reigned in by the government?
- stephc_int13 6y agoI don't think Twitter should be a target. But Amazon, Google, Apple and Facebook have too much power in their hands.
- scarface74 6y agoI can much more easily choose to not by or use a product from any of those companies than I can choose to leave the US. But isn’t telling that the administration is going after Twitter and not Apple? Could it possibly be that Cook has kissed the golden ring plenty of times and Twitter is pushing back? You should be wary of government no matter which side you on. Since the government has started meddling in tech in the 90s, has any good law been passed by Democrats or Republicans?
- epistasis 6y agoTwitter needs to be reigned in when it is considered the only good option, and there's no chance for a competitor. Suppose some company had cornered the web search market, and nobody would even try to use some other web search, and used that position to control advertising and all sorts of other access to the web. Perhaps they even come to control the most commonly used web browser; the most commonly used mobile OS. In that environment, where a single company controls the OS and the search and the vast majority of access to the web, are you really more fearful of "eminent domain" than you are of the company wiping you out before you have a chance to capture a piece of the pie by our competing them? When was the last time a tech company had to worry about civil forfeiture or eminent domain?
- scarface74 6y agoYes I am very much worried about a government that will seize my property because I suspiciously have more money on me than I should without a trial (civil forfeiture). I’m also worried about a government that spies on its citizens (Snowden leaks) and tries to weaken encryption. You’ll have to excuse me if I am more worried about a corrupt government (Republican and Democratic) that repeatedly uses it power unfairly.
- nine_k 6y agoSearch, to tell the truth, is relatively easy to displace. Users are fickle, they easily migrate to whatever they consider a better option. See all these "I moved to DDG and it's OK" comments here Even controlling user data is not that much; one can move the entire email archive, and the entire documents archive, elsewhere. Not easy but doable, and has been done a lot of times. The real power is controlling the user's identity. Think about all the hundreds of places where one would need to replace a "@gmail.com" address. To say nothing of all the places where one used to use "login with Facebook" and where using another method of logging in means losing the previous account.
- stjohnswarts 6y agoI moved, I left my gmail address up forwarding my email to protonmail for about a year, I figured if someone hasn't switched over to my new address by then (or I've changed it with them) I don't need them. Everything has a price.
- notatoad 6y ago>In what universe is Twitter any type of monopoly that needs to be reigned in by the government? Reporters spend about 25 hours a day checking twitter. In most coverage of any tech politics, you're going to see twitter grouped in there as a tech leader, because most reporters feel like it must be just as important as facebook. The numbers obviously disagree, but the attitude can easily spread from the coverage to discussions like this.
- stjohnswarts 6y agoI don't think twitter needs to be shutdown but I do think they should take pride in their platform and remove the disinformation campaigns by foreign powers, trolls, and insane conspiracy theorists like qanon.
- jacobwilliamroy 6y agoYou gotta think of the government like a gang, except in a different timeline, it would be our gang. A government has human values and morals. It is a social organ. A corporation has only one value: increase profit; it has no morals. Government is a way for us to organize ourselves with the intention of improving life for all. In a corporation, the goal is profit. Any improvement in our standard of living is completely coincidental, and corporations will often take away these life improvements in an attempt to sell them back to us for no other reason than to increase profit. It's important to make sure the people in power have their priorities straight. The government is already set up to make the country a better place for all. Corporations cannot fulfill this purpose. And as for twitter, a lot of tech companies these days are vertically integrated monopolies. That means they have a diverse collection of proprietary services which lack inter-operability and stifle innovation and economic development. For example, how microsoft releases inferior versions of almost every kind of software imaginable, in an attempt to keep all people inside their ecosystem. This is what the original anti-trust suit against microsoft was about. Microsoft was found guilty of holding a monopoly multiple times. They only got away with it because they kept appealing until they found themselves in front of a weak judge. Does twitter have this kind of monopoly? I'm not sure. Amazon certainly could be broken up into a few different companies, as could microsoft, apple, google, easily.
- scarface74 6y ago> It's important to make sure the people in power have their priorities straight. The government is already set up to make the country a better place for all. Corporations cannot fulfill this purpose. In the history of the US, when have the people in power ever had their priorities straight? Before the Civil War? During segregation? The War on Crime? The War on Drugs? When interracial marriage (miscegenation) was illegal? When homosexuality was a crime (laws against “fornication”)? The only western country that still has the death penalty? Even in the context of “regulating tech” it’s clear that the current administration is only going against companies it doesn’t like for some reason.
- jacobwilliamroy 6y agoMost of the U.S. government was born to steal land and facilitate genocide. That's just a fact. It's where we come from as Americans. We are all beneficiaries of crimes against humanity. The government needs to change, no doubt about that. The government has public interfaces for change. We can change the government to make sure these interfaces are available to as many americans as possible. We could make them available to all, including our friends in Puerto Rico, just with a few signed pieces of paper. It's important for all of us to have goals and act in a way that is goal-oriented.