5 ms·
> They do not give a fuck Something that the Democrats need to realize is that they (especially Obama) assumed too much good faith in the congressional GOP. Y
by mhh__ 6y ago
> They do not give a fuck
Something that the Democrats need to realize is that they (especially Obama) assumed too much good faith in the congressional GOP.
You can stick to your principles while doing it but, when you are against a party who now considers its last nominee (Romney) a radical BLM leftist, when they go low you need to be ready to kick them in the head.
- tyre 6y agoPrecisely. There is a desire, specifically and especially on the left, to get so caught up in their principles that people believe it is the primary source of change. For example: What should be the first acts and priorities be of a democratic administration? Healthcare? Nope. Climate change? Nope. A federal holiday for election days? Yes. Passing legislation mandating mail-in ballots? Yes. That’s how you think about politics. About power. Lock in any advantage and expand it. Democrats have popular support for their policies but cannot for the life of them think strategically.
- mhh__ 6y agoBeing embarrassed about wanting to be in power is a perpetual problem for leftism (It's understandable - it involves saying yes to the institutions you probably want to reform). Consider Corbyn in the UK - Awful polling from day 1, doesn't help much with Brexit, loses 2 elections (One meh, one disaster) but the lessons learned is that they won the "argument" and it's all good?
- nerdponx 6y agoTo be fair, most American "left" politicians are hardly left, with the exception of Sanders and the handful of DSA-affiliated Congressmen. Although popular support for more-left policies seems to be forcing them (reluctantly) farther leftward.
- nsajko 6y agoTo be fair, it is hypothetically possible that Corbyn did the best he could have done, considering he was being terribly smeared, even vilified, by all the big media organizations in UK AFAIK.
- mhh__ 6y agoField a candidate with a riposte then. The Corbyn fans love to talk abut media smears but they neglect to mention that he never polled above 0% net approval in his entire term as leader. Starmer, his replacement, is a man of intellect, principle, and service to the public - he is already doing better than Corbyn ever did - i.e. the media who didn't like Corbyn were writing amicable praise of Sir Keir (the mail love a nickname) even when he was making a mockery of their man (Boris)
- flamble 6y agoThe reason for that is that Starmer is a corporate stooge who doesn't present any threat to the merciless extraction of value from the working class. Of course they have no objection to the kind of competition which would have no adverse effect on their interests if it prevailed; their praise is evidence of Starner's complete lack of merit. The media besmirched Corbyn BECAUSE he was a decent man with the interests of the public at heart, which is unacceptable to the owners of the media apparatus.
- toyg 6y ago> Starmer is a corporate stooge Now, now. Starmer might not be a militant marxist, but he spent a good chunk of his life fighting for workers' rights in court. He also served faithfully in the shadow cabinet under Corbyn - are you saying that Corbyn chose a "corporate stooge" as his shadow minister, and on the hottest issue of the day at that (brexit)? One of Corbyn's lackings was that he was unable to make friends in his own party, to the point that half of his own rank & file literally sabotaged him at the last election. By calling good people all sorts of unwarranted names we're only going to see a repeat, and $deity knows this country deserves better than yet another Tory government.
- wyldfire 6y agoVoting and gerrymandering are the metagame. We should pay people to vote, that would help turnout (up to about as much as it would ever get).
- worker767424 6y agoControversial view: no, we shouldn't. Have you see how stupid people are? How easily they're manipulated? How little they understand about how government works? Any you want politicians pandering to these people? If it weren't to the stigma of "literacy" tests and how the were historically used, I'd be fully in favor of "licensing" voters.
- papeda 6y agoPaying people to vote is pretty out there. I think we should at least put election day on a weekend. Spread it over both days, even. This feels to me like a relatively easy small step that would really help make voting easier in a way that doesn't open itself up to voter fraud arguments (as far as I know).
- wyldfire 6y ago> Spread it over both days, even. Early voting (in several states already?) does a good job of this IMO.
- malandrew 6y agoThe literacy test that I took wasn't even controversial. Back in middle school my civics teacher actually had us take one of these literacy tests. While very few people in the class passed the test (I think just myself and one other person), anyone actually familiar with the text of the US Constitution should be able to pass it. Sadly almost no one in our class was familiar with the US Constitution. I'm totally okay with a test where the only document you need to study from is the US Constitution.
- ransom1538 6y ago"We should pay people to vote" Reminds of me of 3rd grade when kids would make a christmas tree out of their scantron tests. That is what we need -- randomness added to voting.
- toastal 6y agoHaving more people able to vote in winner-takes-all elections in gerrymandered districts won't help as much as you'd like.
- tyre 6y agoI am under no delusions about what I mentioned as panaceas. But in terms of direct action that democrats could pass in the first week (the bills exist already), those are my picks. Gerrymandering would take a constitutional amendment. Yes, it would help more, but that’s a moot point if the people we’re talking about can’t do it.
- toastal 6y agoSure. I was pointing out that there's up-and-down fundamental issues with the American voting system that would take a massive reform to fix as mere tweaks alone won't suffice. I think we'd agree on this.
- AlanSE 6y agoThe whole electoral college is non-intentional gerrymandering. The candidate with fewer votes has been winning since 2000, and winning with a wider and wider vote margin. A major political goal should be getting the National Popular Vote Interstate Compact done.
- sanj 6y agoObama won both elections in electoral votes and actual votes.
- AlanSE 6y agoYes, and was very centrist. I don't think the changing media landscape can be disentangled from this, which is a trend happening for unrelated reasons. If the only thing happening was urban concentration, then the mathematical predicted response of politicians would be that the liberal part becomes political-center and the conservative part skews further right.
- User23 6y agoDemocrats’ policy of importing tens of millions of future reliable Democrat voters is some solid strategic thinking.
- nerdponx 6y agoUntil Trump does something zany and unexpected like abolishing ICE next month, and suddenly they all flip red. Edit: That said, I could think of much worse outcomes.
- evan_ 6y agoIf republicans don’t like that non-white people more frequently vote for democrats they could try courting their votes with their policies and actions rather than trying to kill/deport as many as possible
- nerdponx 6y agoOn the flipside, if Democrats didn't think they had a solid voter base in immigrants, they wouldn't give a shit about immigrants.
- User23 6y agoThat Democrats identified the Republican inability or unwillingness to either woo or eliminate the new voters only further argues in favor of their strategic acumen.
- tasty_freeze 6y agoGerrymandering is at the top of my list. Solve that problem and it is easier to attack the other problems.
- tyre 6y agoThat would take a constitutional amendment. The top three amendments (in my opinion) that the US needs most: - ending gerrymandering - taking money out of politics (federally financed elections) - forcing votes on nominees within a certain time period, otherwise they are assumed confirmed
- nerdponx 6y agoDemocrats have popular support for their policies but cannot for the life of them think strategically. You think they don't understand this stuff? Democrats have been deliberately "failing" to get shit done for 20 years. They keep holding out progressive and populist policies, tantalizingly close to enacting meaningful change -- but nope, somehow it always seems to be a matter of political strategy, badly run campaigns, and bad messaging that derails things. Surely the Republicans haven't somehow had the better political strategists for decades. They aren't always better funded and they aren't always better organized. And certainly they don't have access to some kind of magic politics potion that the Democrats lack. The only plausible scenario that I can see is that the Democratic party leadership has no interest in actually getting policy enacted, as long as they keep their cozy niche in power. Another 4 years of Trump will help them do very well in the 2022 midterms, and it will help keep their friends at the NYT, CNN, and MSNBC in business. It would also explain why they hated Sanders and the DSA candidates so much. Liberals (not to mention leftists) who actually wanted to take power at the national level and actually do something? That would fuck up the whole game. Basically you'd have to show me some actual evidence that Democratic party leadership actually wants to do anything other than campaign on a progressive platform and consistently almost-win. The whole thing seems worked to me.
- bscphil 6y agoI don't think you need anything that conspiratorial, it's not that centrist Democrats really don't want to get anything done, it's just that they really are basically okay with the current neoliberal consensus.
- shanhaiguan 6y agoWhat's the distinction?
- bscphil 6y agoWell, one is the claim that Democrats don't get anything done because they have a secret commitment to keep things the way they are so that voters have a reason to come back to the polls for them, and I'm saying maybe the reason is simply that Democrats are mostly fine with the way things are. Maybe your point is that this is a distinction without a difference, which I guess I'd mostly have to agree with.
- ALittleLight 6y agoI don't know about head kicks. I think you just need to be a political realist. The reality is that you need (edit: cooperation of the) Senate and Presidency to get a Justice nominated. Obama didn't have the Senate and didn't get his pick for Justice. Trump does, and will get his pick. The whole "Republicans are hypocrites" thing is true - but obviously so. Whatever was said about not doing it in election year was simply a political lie they felt they had to say to avoid the "We are doing this because we can" reality.
- gdubs 6y agoKennedy, Souter, and Thomas were all approved by a senate of an opposing party. Apparently you have to go back to the 1800s though to find a case where a Democratic president had a nominee appointed by a Republican Senate.
- ALittleLight 6y agoYou have to have the cooperation of the Senate I meant. Obviously, in cases where a President of one party has a nominee appointed by a Senate of another, the cooperation of the Senate was there.
- 8note 6y agoLooking earlier than the 60s or so seems irrelevant for comparing the republicans and democrats
- cmurf 6y agoMerrick Garland was recommended to Obama by Republican senator Orrin Hatch as a reasonable candidate, before the death of Scalia.
- ghufran_syed 6y agoDemocrat senators Chuck Schumer and Harry Reid first introduced a filibuster for judicial nominees, and then ending the filibuster for judicial nominees when it was politically convenient for them. https://www.politico.com/magazine/story/2017/04/mitch-mcconnell-charles-schumer-nuclear-option-judicial-filibuster-214991 https://www.politico.com/magazine/story/2017/04/mitch-mcconn... Do you think that might have affected the ability of the current president to successfully appoint a supreme court justice now?
- res0nat0r 6y agoNo
- gilrain 6y ago> Democrat Childish. Come on.
- evan_ 6y agoDo you think the republicans would not have ended it for Kavanaugh?
- cmurf 6y agoThey did. Reid's cloture vote to end the filibuster applied to federal judges, not Supreme Court justices. Before the vote on Kavanaugh there was a cloture vote to end the filibuster.
- evan_ 6y agoOh well if he hasn’t done that surely the republicans would’ve sat on their hands this whole time
- glenstein 6y agoThere are so many unpacked assumptions and unevaluated arguments here it would take a book to work through them all. To give a short version - if you oppose a filibuster, then don't use it to prevent Merrick Garland from being on the court. Nothing about Schumer's position on the filibuster in 2002 can be used to argue that the trajectory of court appointments since then is a culmination of any logically consistent argument in response to it.
- zanny 6y agoObama didn't assume anything. He was a senator for 12 years (federally for 4) and had plenty of experience by that point to know how partisan legislative bodies are and how members will die for their parties perceived glory. I don't believe for a second that in the aftermath of Clinton's impeachment & Gore's 500 vote loss in the state being governed by his opponents brother with tens of thousands of votes lost or miscounted that any prospective politician anywhere in the US would expect good faith from their opposition. He was a great orator and liked using that come together message as an attempted bait to push popular support in his favor, though. It was also a great excuse for pushing an extremely conservative healthcare bill through congress as if it were some major achievement for his more progressive supporters.
- tyre 6y agoI agree on Obama. Biden played a large part as well. Remember that they got rid of a public option in negotiations to win Republicans over. And got zero Republican votes. Obama was many things, but he was not good at congressional politics. He saw himself as about the fray, and it showed.
- chris11 6y agoJoe Lieberman killed the public option in Obamacare. He threatened to vote against the bill if a public option was included.
- StanislavPetrov 6y agoYou mean Joe Lieberman, who was Al Gore's choice for Vice President when he won the Democratic nomination for president in 2000, and went on to endorse Republican John McCain for president only 8 years later? The facts are that Democratic Senator Max Baucus, Chairmen of the Senate Finance Committee and Obama's pointman in the Senate who was responsible for writing the language of Obamacare (Romneycare) invited a cabal of insurance industry lobbyists into the negotiating room to write the bill and specifically excluded all single-payer advocates from the negotiating table. Its pure revisionist history to suggest that Obama and his minions did everything they could to push a public option (let alone single-payer or even a Medicare-for-all type provision). The facts are that Obama and the Democratic leadership caucus were determined to pass a bill that enshrined the predominance of the for-profit, employer-based health insurance industry. Obamacare (Romneycare) was designed from the beginning as an effort to preclude real, substantive change and improvements to our healthcare system by implementing some very minor improvements (such as the pre-existing conditions clause) and some cosmetic changes. This was abundantly clear to everyone who was paying close attention at the time and not getting their information from corporate news outlets. https://pnhp.org/news/max-baucus-should-not-be-deciding-health-care-for-america/ https://pnhp.org/news/max-baucus-should-not-be-deciding-heal...
- colordrops 6y agoThis idea that either the Republicans or Democrats have faith or principles is absurd. The Democratic brand is one of principles and altruism, but their actions do not reflect this.
- colinmhayes 6y agoWrong. Democrats are principled to a fault.
- nerdponx 6y agoIt's getting hard not to believe that it's mostly a front.
- mhh__ 6y agoIn what way?
- refurb 6y agoOh, the old "the reason my party can't get anything done is because they are too principled".
- colinmhayes 6y agoEverything is relative. Obviously politicians aren't principled in an absolute way. But democrats absolutely are more principled than republicans. They have failed to lie like republicans do. They don't gerrymander as effectively. They refuse to utilize fake news to energize their base like republicans do.
- colordrops 6y agoThey did all of that during the primary against Bernie Sanders. They went so far as to call him a Russian plant. And the rigging of the Iowa caucus result reporting was unconscionable. They only reported districts that Sanders was not leading in, making it look like he lost. It took a week to report results districts he was popular in and he ended up winning the popular vote. https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=nDO2kHGEoY0 https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=nDO2kHGEoY0
- anm89 6y agoOr maybe present a better alternative that gets people to vote for your side? Your party aggressively screwed over a candidate who could have energized the base and still would have captured 99.99% of the center in a trade for a principle-less barely coherent snooze fest of a human being who would toe the old party line and then you claim the only remedy is to play as dirty as the other side? Excuse me for not buying it. I voted for Obama but the democratic party is bordering on as repulsive as the republicans these days and this type of thinking is to blame.
- mhh__ 6y agoBernie? He lost to Hillary by almost 4 million votes, then lost to Biden by 9 million votes (The largest margin since 2004) - how is that motivating the base. He's a protectionist idealist who the republicans were dying to run against because they knew he'd be easier than Biden.
- anm89 6y agoI'm not a Bernie supporter. Just pointing out that the party repeatedly screws itself over. Also just because a person loses a primary does not mean they are they weaker candidate in the general election. The math can easily go the other way.
- DuskStar 6y agoAt the same time, from the Republican perspective... They won "fair and square", and then largely liberal-staffed agencies and other organizations delayed and resisted the implementation of Republican policies as much as possible. The other side wasn't playing fair, why should they?