5 ms·
Amazon Is Strictly Liable for 3rd Party Marketplace Items
- MichaelZuo 6y agoPotentially huge. If amazon decides to appeal, which they almost certainly will do, and if the 9th circuit and supreme court declines to hear the appeal, or upholds the verdict, then this would be precedent setting. Online retailing will turn into physical retailing except in cyberspace. In this sort of environment then Amazon will likely have no competitive advantage over Walmart, or any other big retailer who sets up a good site, on the retail side. And Amazon doesn’t have a monopoly on smart tech/marketing/strategy/etc. folks either. No wonder they’re putting so much effort into other projects, it’s doubtful they’ll ever turn a significant profit on their core business in this future environment. The margins will stay near zero.
- patrickhogan1 6y agoWithout arguing the merits of distributor liability or supply chain liability. Why should Amazon not bear the same responsibility as a mostly physical retailer (eg Walmart - who currently is liable for products it sells - assuming a retail store transaction)? This ruling follows the same logic as sales tax. In 2020 there is no reason to argue an online transaction should receive special treatment from an in-person transaction considering a sale of the same product to the same consumer.
- hansvm 6y ago> Why should Amazon not bear the same responsibility as a mostly physical retailer The typical argument is that they're more akin to a farmers market, bringing buying and sellers together and facilitating a transaction, and most legal disputes should be handled between the parties who actually bought and sold items. It's not an online vs in-person distinction. The key point of the ruling seems to be that Amazon can't claim to be a neutral arbiter while simultaneously branding itself to consumers like an online counterpart to a physical retailer (as opposed to, e.g., eBay where it's abundantly obvious that you're interacting with some third party) and while substantially restricting the activities of and information available to sellers such that they are sellers in name only and don't actually have a relationship with the end consumer.
- paulryanrogers 6y agoExcept there is no co-mingling in farmers markets.
- hansvm 6y agoWell sure. I'm not taking Amazon's side on this, just trying to explain from my perspective why it's not really an online vs physical issue like the grandparent comment suggested. Other factors (I listed a couple; co-mingling also matters) are the points of contention.
- paulryanrogers 6y agoI'd say the co-mingling makes Amazon more than just an intermediary, regardless of whether customers are in person or online.
- verall 6y agoThis guy is a professor? He talks like he's very inexperienced in the law. Especially: > This kind of stuff makes my head hurt, because the court seems to imply that Amazon could avoid liability by taking fewer steps to protect consumer safety. Uh, obviously? It's a list of heuristics to separate a flea market from a walmart. Amazon is obviously a walmart. Ebay works pretty hard to be transparent about being a flea market slash auctioneer for this reason, Amazon is just trying to bully the state Gov.
- londons_explore 6y agoIf this ruling stands, I could imagine them just shutting the marketplace down entirely.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- rasz 6y agoShutting down would mean regulation worked. Sadly I expect the opposite, something as brazen-faced as establishing a fake insurance company in one of tax heavens like https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Action_Park https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Action_Park