9 ms·
If this is their secret weapon for the election then it's not a very good one. If we make a simple division of the population into 4 groups, we'll have 1. Peop
by mhh__ 6y ago
If this is their secret weapon for the election then it's not a very good one. If we make a simple division of the population into 4 groups, we'll have
1. People who are ambivalent i.e. don't care or aren't familiar with the app
2. People who are strongly against it for a variety of reasons
3. People who are in favour because it's a blow scored against the Chinese
4. People who are in favour due to their feelings about the app specifically
It seems likely to me that the second grouping will be the largest. I don't think much will come of it but it will take much, much more than this to neuter China. It's not quite as vacuous "Build the wall" but it's not far off - if you want to battle china economically, get trading with their competitors (i.e. vote for centrists - Bernie is almost as protectionist as Trump)
- sterlind 6y agoI'm concerned about China's policy of heavy-handed protectionism and censorship internally while benefitting from global markets externally. But I don't like this tit-for-tat action by the US. Cutting off Tiktok will only further accelerate the balkanization of the internet. Keeping US companies from kataoing to the Chinese regime with special concessions (e.g. Dragonfly) and making services too important to easily firewall off (e.g. GitHub) seems like a better strategy. At least I hope so.
- DiogenesKynikos 6y ago> I'm concerned about China's policy of heavy-handed protectionism and censorship internally while benefitting from global markets externally. Foreign companies benefited enormously from the opening up of the Chinese market, and China is not nearly as protectionist as it's made out to be. Western media has trouble entering China because of political censorship, but Western businesses in general have very good market access. China is a very significant market for most major US tech companies.
- philliphaydon 6y agoWestern business do not have good market access. Just look at what’s happened with Disney. Spend years and years censoring movies and gaining favour of the CCP to get access to the market and a single movie ends up destroying their reputation overnight.
- whoevercares 6y agoCompletely BS. When I was walking through shopping mall in Beijing, for a moment I thought I’m in New York, all western brands. What are you talking about?
- philliphaydon 6y agoSo you see some brands in china and that means that brand’s have 0 issues getting into china market? But ignoring that those brands can’t easily get the money they make out of china, they don’t own the subsidiary in china, and if china decides to boycott the brand, it actually means something compared to boycott in the west which is just something people say and don’t follow through on.
- DiogenesKynikos 6y agoYou don't just see "some brands" in China. They're everywhere, on a completely different scale than Chinese brands in the US. In practice, American companies have a much larger presence in China than vice versa. > they don’t own the subsidiary in china This is a common misconception. Foreign companies can own their subsidiaries in most sectors of the Chinese economy. > those brands can’t easily get the money they make out of china China has capital flow controls. Foreign companies are still able to expatriate their profits. Apple takes in about $45 billion in revenue per year in China, and there must be a hefty profit associated with that revenue. Do you think Apple's profits get trapped in China?
- philliphaydon 6y agoYou cannot just start a WFOE business inm china. You can’t just take money out of china. Apple is a giant company with an insane amount of money to pay off whoever they need to.