5 ms·
My understanding is that there are quite a few perceived threats, but all of them apply to large US corporations as well. If you collect enough information on
by nrmitchi 6y ago
My understanding is that there are quite a few perceived threats, but all of them apply to large US corporations as well.
If you collect enough information on people, they can be manipulated to certain beliefs or actions. This is the same information that Facebook and Google use for advertising purposes, similar information to the Cambridge Analytica events, and the risk is China (or a nefarious actor with this information) using it to "meddle" within the US.
Apps collecting sensitive information (which maybe TikTok content counts as?) can also be used for blackmail, especially when owned by a foreign government which wouldn't even blink at blackmail.
There are other more paranoia-centered concerns around essentially-real-time location data being used to "know where in the country to attack".
Basically there are definitely legitimate concerns around large-scale data collection, but the "National Security" concern definitely seems to be "China is less trustworthy than any American company".
This is just my understanding, and am open to being proven wrong here.
Update:
I forgot to mention that I do believe there is a legitimate concern around a foreign government having what is effectively editorial control over a platform which is used by a rather-easily-influenced group as a "news source". Whether or not social media should ever be considered a source of news is a different discussion, but if a large section of the US population is believing what they see on TikTok as fact, and the content on TikTok is editorialized by a foreign state actor, it is a legitimate concern.
- netsharc 6y agoHmm, why just foreign governments? The last 3.5 years (if not more) the US government doesn't seem to have been acting in your or my best interests, unless you're of the "Koch brothers"-class elite. Meanwhile it's not the government, but Instagram hides unfavorable "related hashtags" when you search for Trump-related hashtags, but doesn't do the same for Biden: https://www.buzzfeednews.com/article/ryanmac/instagram-related-hashtags-favoring-trump-over-biden https://www.buzzfeednews.com/article/ryanmac/instagram-relat... Viva la democracia! /s
- xorcist 6y agoTo put it more bluntly: People have studied how to weaponize Facebook, and are have finally got around to make sure others can't to them same to them. It's the classic two sides of intelligence and counter intelligence. I would expect the big IT companies to be treated more and more as intelligence assets over time, if we aren't already there.
- valuearb 6y agoSummation: Censorship by US is good, if it keeps you from hearing things the current administration does not want, such as ways to troll the presidents rallies.