3 ms·
I'll give you the benefit of the doubt, but I'm honestly not sure if you are trolling me here. Apple's track record for industry-defining products is fairly bas
by ineedasername 6y ago
I'll give you the benefit of the doubt, but I'm honestly not sure if you are trolling me here. Apple's track record for industry-defining products is fairly basic industry knowledge.
I may be leaving something off here but with 10 entries below + 4 honorable mentions. That's an average of redefining some industry or another once every 3-4 years. Over 40 years, I think it's fair to say that represents enough of a trend to expect that sort of thing from Apple. But we've had about 13 years of small annual incremental changes in iPhones.
--Apple II
--Mac
--Newton (though a market failure, its functionality was copied and gave rise to a new generation of smarter PA's similar to how the iPhone gave rise to the new generation of smart phones)
--iMac
--Physical Apple stores (strongly influenced retail store designs and had Apple's competitors like Microsoft & Sony scrambling to create their own retail presence)
--iPod
--iTunes
--iPhone
--iPad
--Apple Watch
--Honorable mentions would include voice control assistants, air pods, power mac pcs, and apple tv.
- pwinnski 6y agoOkay, so your list, like mine, includes a steady series of new products with huge impacts, and the most recent is just a few years old. You seem to be making the argument that one of the previous products (iPhone) must somehow deliver the same impact as an entirely new product, because... I guess I'm not getting that part. I mean, draw the parallel for the other products you mention. Apple II... was replaced completely by the next generation. Mac has reinvented itself a few times, but they've been spaced out a bit. They're currently in the process of transitioning to entirely new CPUs for the third time (68000 -> PowerPC -> Intel -> Apple Silicon), and have gone through a couple of complete overhauls on the OS side as well. Newton was innovative, ahead of its time, and... iMac is also Mac, but okay, specifically the candy-colored all-in-ones shifted the industry in some interesting ways and the current iteration is very nice, but essentially unchanged in a long time. I mean, using the same lens you seem to be using for iPhone, they haven't really changed the body style since 2004 when they replaced the half-melon with the currently style, or maybe since 2007 when they switched to aluminum. I mean, sure, they updated the screen quality, and there have been some minor tweaks, but put a 13-year-old iMac next to a new one, and they haven't changed that much. I think that's my point. You've picked iPhone specifically and insist that iPhone alone must somehow bear the fruits of Apple's history of delivering industry-changing products, but since 2007 they've delivered substantial iterations in iMacs, PowerBooks, Apple TVs, and iPhones, while also launching iPad, Apple Watch, and AirPods, as well as new record-setting CPUs every one of the last ten years. So I dunno. I think somehow you've convinced yourself that there is some new world-shaking innovation possible in the phone space, that Apple not having delivered it yet is somehow a failure, and yet I suspect you wouldn't recognize it if they launched it tomorrow. I mean, set a 2007 iPhone next to the phone they'll launch this year and aks yourself: is it the problem that they ship something every year? If they skipped a few years, and only delivered every three or four years, would they seem innovative, or just iterative? iPhone, iPhone 4 (Retina), iPhone 5S (TouchID), iPhone 6 (5.5" screen), iPhone X (FaceID). I think each of those is a substantial bundle of innovations over the previous, and I'm not even considering the CPU inside them, or many, many, many smaller things that we take for granted today. My iPhone X might as well have been a completely different phone, it was so different from everything that came before. That was announced three years ago. To recap: I think one can either say that Apple's only real innovations are the Macintosh, iPod, iPhone, and iPad, or that they've released innovations every 2-3 years for the past couple of decades, but saying that iPhones are a single innovative product rather than a series of at least 5 and probably closer to 8 real game-changers is mistaken.
- labcomputer 6y agoI think I don't understand your argument here. ineedasername listed about a dozen industry-redefining products, which span a 40 year period. You seem to be arguing that, because the innovative product continued to be sold with incremental improvements Apple is not innovative. * The point isn't that the 1995 Quadra is innovative. It's that the 1984 Mac brought the desktop metaphor to the masses (where it was previously a research toy with each seat costing as much as a house) * The point isn't that the 2020 iMac is innovative. It's that the 1997 iMac changed how the computer industry thought about the industrial design of home computers. * The point isn't that the 2020 iPhone 12 Max Excess is innovative. It's that the 2007 iPhone completely changed what a smartphone was, with multi-touch, on-screen keyboard, data plans that actually made sense, desktop-quality graphics and more. * The point isn't that the 2023 AirPods are going to be innovative. It's that the 2016 AirPods created an entire sub-industry of "totally wireless" headphones. The original point was the people hold Apple to a higher standard because Apple has a track record of introducing something every 3-6 years that makes people say "wow". That Apple continues to make incremental improvements after the "wow launch" doesn't diminish the track record of major innovation. Where I disagree with ineedasername is that I think it only looks like Apple isn't innovative right now because the next big thing hasn't been announced yet, and innovations don't happen on a fixed cadence.
- pwinnski 6y agoYou've really misread the thread. I was making exactly the point you're making. I am arguing that Apple continues to innovate, in response to ineedasername's claim that Apple has ceased to innovate like they once did.