5 ms·
None of it makes sense in the context of a well-run business with proper executives in place. That’s because these frauds don’t operate like a well-run business
by PragmaticPulp 6y ago
None of it makes sense in the context of a well-run business with proper executives in place. That’s because these frauds don’t operate like a well-run business.
Usually, the upper management teams are extremely lean. The business is broken up into different silos such that few people can see the big picture. Each is led to believe they are a tiny fraction of the overall revenue, giving them the impression that the bulk of the company’s revenue must come from another department where they have no visibility. As a bonus, this motivates siloed teams to feel like they need to catchup to the rest of the company, when in reality they might be the main driver of it. It helps to have separate offices and a culture of secrecy to prevent people from comparing notes.
The CEO positions himself as a controlling, micromanaging individual at the center of everything. This makes it possible for the CEO to intercept financials and other crucial numbers en route to people who might catch on.
The rest of the management staff might be filled with people too inexperienced to recognize that something is wrong. They might think the CEO is doing them a favor by giving them a golden opportunity to advance their career into an executive position at a rocket ship startup. They don’t know what they’re doing, but they think it’s okay because the CEO has taken them under his wing.
At scale it becomes difficult to do this without at least a few people being complicit, though. A fraudster usually has several close associates who can be trusted to be in on the fraud or at least look the other way for a while.
- liability 6y agoSometimes tribal/"team sport" group dynamics keep employees inline too. Executives can foster an "us against the world" mentality that blinds workers to that which is obvious to everybody else. When in this mindset, people have the ability to ignore even the most damning evidence. Here's an example: When Enron's CEO verbally attacked wall street analyst Richard Grubman for questioning Enron's accounting practices, Enron employees thought this was hilarious and adopted the insult as a sort of inside joke. They didn't consider Richard Grubman's position, they just took delight in 'their team' dunking on 'opposing team.'
- rapnie 6y agoThis is massively scalable. There are examples, but I do not want to get political.
- duncan_bayne 6y agoLeaving aside the specific politics, this is one of many reasons I advocate for replacing voting with sortition (picking representatives from the electoral roll, in much the same way as juries are picked).
- consumer451 6y ago> but I do not want to get political. The question I keep asking myself is, if not now, then when?
- xmodem 6y agoSee also: Theranos.
- hn_throwaway_21 6y agoBingo! I worked in the upper management team of an early stage startup where the CEO was lying through his teeth to investors as well as employees. There were only three people at the top level. He was a super charismatic guy and a great story teller. No one thought he was lying until it came time to raise the next round and the lead investor from seed round ran due diligence to find booked revenue was no where close to what CEO had been claiming.
- HappyDreamer 6y ago> No one thought he was lying until ... I wonder what happened after that? Could he continue working as if nothing special, just failing to raise money?
- jlarocco 6y agoI can't imagine that first seed investor wouldn't press charges and file a lawsuit.
- amorroxic 6y agoAgree, this being a cyber-fraud company I believe one could keep a team busy for a long time focusing on building secure systems rather than operating them to the point where no-one gets to see what's actually being stored within. The paper trail though I'm still puzzled about, he couldn't have acted alone.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- Uhhrrr 6y agoFun thought experiment: are there businesses where this structure is beneficial, or is it always a red flag?
- smabie 6y agoIn the past, traders were siloed and no individual trader would have access to the total positions of all the traders on the floor. Some firms still operate this way, though it's more common for trading operations to be broken up into "pods" or teams of traders and analysts. The industry has largely moved away from this structure for a variety of reasons. One of the problems is that traders start to try and undermine each other, since the only thing that matters is your personal pnl. Another problem is that traders can unknowingly all pile into the same investments, resulting in massive risk. This is part of the reason why the Great Recession was so bad.
- csours 6y agoThis reminds me of why traders are required to take vacation - it may be the only time their scams are unraveled. https://www.newsday.com/business/columnists/help-wanted-carrie-work-column-1.16723565 https://www.newsday.com/business/columnists/help-wanted-carr...
- nvr219 6y agoWhen done right the vacation is sprung on them without notice. In reality they usually know when their vacation is coming so they can alert their cohorts.
- dmurray 6y agoThe idea is everyone must take vacation (sometimes X+ consecutive days each year), not just the people you suspect of running scams. Giving all of your employees two weeks unannounced vacation at random times is a disruptive way to run a company. It's certainly innovative but I wouldn't say it's HR "done right".
- ghaff 6y agoYou have to take at least half you annual vacation starting tomorrow. Have fun! Yeah. That doesn't work. Forcing the same thing in a scheduled way may be a bit of an imposition but isn't unreasonable in general.
- Retric 6y agoDoing so in an unscheduled way is beneficial for similar reasons you want to test when services go down in controlled circumstances. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chaos_engineering https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chaos_engineering Large companies simply have different risks. If someone quitting randomly is a huge risk for your business you want to know about it ahead of time to mitigate it while they still work for you. 1 random week of vacation every ~3 years shouldn’t be a big deal, and discovering it was is valuable.
- op00to 6y agoit sounds easier and more lucrative to simply be honest.
- roymurdock 6y agoDamn what a good reply. You must’ve been burned/seen some shit in the past.
- fuzzfactor 6y agoThis all too often happens at other companies, many times inadvertently without any fraudulent intention, just by being not well-run. And even when they end up raking in the bucks, for the shareholders it's nothing compared to what it could have been.