4 ms·
> Most republics borrow most of their core concepts from monarchies that preceded them. In the early (modern) republics like the US & France, Presidents have a
by rsynnott 6y ago
> Most republics borrow most of their core concepts from monarchies that preceded them. In the early (modern) republics like the US & France, Presidents have a lot of power, especially military power.
While this is generally true, France is a weird case; it was a parliamentary democracy for a bit! The current semi-presidential setup is pretty new.
> Whatever the details, pardons (and clemencies) are a necessary device. Even courts need check valves and this is a way of checking courts without harming the court as an institution. Yes, it is open to abuse, but on balance I do think it's necessary.
Sure, but it shouldn't be at the behest of one person. It's fine if it is ceremonially, as in the UK and Ireland cases, but not if it is _in fact_.
- dalbasal 6y agoIMO, it needs to be outside of a court or court-like system. Generally, it's in the hands of a high ranking official. A president is high enough in the food chain to avoid motivations going unnoticed. In any case, aside from motivations, I think this is the sort of case where pardons should be considered. There were a lot of shenanigans. Motivations, political involvement, tactical levers (legal, espionage-ish, diplomatic..) that can't (won't, at least) be revealed. These are the kinds of situations for which pardons exist.