6 ms·
This is Apple business as usual. I worked at a company that got slightly disrupted when Apple blocked our dev credentials because of something else it didn't l
by shadowgovt 6y ago
This is Apple business as usual.
I worked at a company that got slightly disrupted when Apple blocked our dev credentials because of something else it didn't like we were doing. That broke our public-facing apps, but also broke our ability to deploy software we'd written in-house to our corporate iPhones, because it's the same code-signing credentials.
I'm glad this hippo-fight is shedding light on this aspect of the Apple dev ecosystem.
(Our Android devices, of course, had no such issues, since even if Google had objected, you can side-load an APK).
- heavyset_go 6y ago> but also broke our ability to deploy software we'd written in-house to our corporate iPhones, because it's the same code-signing credentials. This is an important point. Apple will retaliate and hinder your ability to get work done using your own in-house software if they decide they don't like you.
- Bud 6y ago"If they decide they don't like you"? That's simply not what occurred, here. Nobody at Apple blithely decided randomly one day that they "didn't like" Epic. Epic violated the terms of their agreement with Apple. It's as simple as that. Now yes, there has been a shitstorm of other conflict rising out of that, but on a fundamental level, Epic decided to blatantly violate a contract. That's what happened.
- elliekelly 6y agoWhere’s the part where Apple didn’t decide they don’t like Epic? Whether or not Epic’s actions were the catalyst for that decision (and I agree, they were) is irrelevant to GP’s point.
- ianmobbs 6y agoWhat does that even mean? Of course Epic's actions being the catalyst is relevant. It's the whole reason this is even happening. Are you trying to imply that Epic's actions are irrelevant, but "Apple just plain not liking Epic" is? When you make a claim that Apple is doing this just because they don't like Epic, you have the burden of proof for that claim, and you can't just flip that around with "where’s the part where Apple didn’t decide they don’t like Epic".
- hrktb 6y agoI think an aspect that is missing in our discussion is that not every company had to openly fight Apple. Netflix for instance got their deal without drama. From the court docs Epic and Apple were also negociating but it didn’t work well. What I am saying is there is no “simple as that” way to look at it, and things could have gone way differently, even if Epic didn’t budge on getting rid of the 30%. In an alternative world Epic and Apple would have inked a deal at a lower revenue share and it would be over. Just like how Epic and Sony had a standoff regarding crossplay that got resolved without titanic lawsuits.
- laegooose 6y agoCan you please give a link about Netflix deal with Apple? Brief google search yields nothing.
- hrktb 6y agoApple carved out a special ‘reader apps’ category for Netflix and other providers to bypass the standard restrictions of needing to implement all digital payment in-app. https://www.fastcompany.com/90519293/the-surprisingly-simple-fix-for-apples-convoluted-app-store-rules https://www.fastcompany.com/90519293/the-surprisingly-simple... While looking for it, I also stumbled upon the special deal Amazon has with Apple allowing them to only pay 15%: https://9to5mac.com/2020/07/30/apple-developers-equally/ https://9to5mac.com/2020/07/30/apple-developers-equally/
- ghostbrainalpha 6y agoI'm really glad things didn't work out that way. How are startups supposed to break into a market where they will always have to pay Apple 30% until they reach an incredible scale, and established players will have this huge advantage with Apple in addition to all their other advantages.
- scarface74 6y agoEvery large company gets better deals on everything than small companies. Try manufacturing anything where you have small tub rates? Do you think startups get the same deals from the cloud providers as the big companies with multi million dollar spends? Do you think no name artists get the same deals as Beyoncé or Taylor Swift?
- heavyset_go 6y ago> That's simply not what occurred, here. Nobody at Apple blithely decided randomly one day that they "didn't like" Epic. This was a response to an anecdote from a user working for a company that isn't Epic, a company that was punished by Apple for an arbitrary reason. As a result, they couldn't use their in-house apps on the hardware they purchased because of Apple's decision. According to that user, that decidedly did occur. There is plenty of evidence from developers all over the internet, and even here on HN, of Apple arbitrarily removing apps from their iOS and Mac App Stores, and of Apple arbitrarily enforcing rules.
- sreekotay 6y ago100%. Its especially the arbitrary/selective enforcement. Ive had it happen... even when we could demonstrate other apps doing the same and getting updates pushed through.
- DaiPlusPlus 6y agoI don’t understand that about Apple. They’re able to hire the best. And the best people don’t get emotional. Apple’s heavyhanded actions against Epic have the image of an emotional, irrational, vengeance-seeking person at the helm. The best lawyers working at Apple would (I assume) direct Apple’s management towards the best course of action - including keeping the company out of any legal trouble. I don’t know a fraction of the things Apple knows - but from what I do know Apple had zero rational reason nor cause to do anything beyond pulling Fortnite from the App Store for breaking the rules (fair-and-square). Everything - and anything - beyond that in a high-profile case like this runs a tremendous risk of PR backfire. In their position as custodians of their walled-garden that needs to attract developers to generate revenue Apple needs to project an image closer to Mister Rogers than Mister Burns. Apple doesn’t need to be petty or combative - it they’re the /good guys/ they sure aren’t acting like it. As I don’t know all the facts my mind is racing to speculate a reason for their capriciousness and I come up blank. If Apple’s playing some long-con to screw-over Google, perhaps by announcing some surprise 0% fee for IAP for “good citizens” on their platform or some alternative scheme then they’re going about it very poorly. I agree with the other GP posters that at this point Apple is actively doing harm to their own platform by both scaring-off major software publishers like Epic and reminding the rest of us devs that Apple giveth and Apple takeawayeth. I imagine a progressive EU state will pass legislation prohibiting walled-garden owners from abusing their position to extract excessive rent - and from inconsistent application of their own review guidelines, which will have a viral effect within the EU’s single market - which will severely mess-up Apple’s strategy because within the EU single market the rules mean that Apple cannot decide to withdraw from a single country that it doesn’t like but not the rest of the single-market (but before people point out that Apple is a US company remember that Apple’s tax-advantaged Irish corporation is central to their worldwide operations).
- dragonwriter 6y ago> They’re able to hire the best. They are probably fairly able to hire the people they want the most, that is, the best from their perspective, sure. > And the best people don’t get emotional. Perhaps that's how you define best, but not what Apple filters for or intends to filter for.
- 6y ago
- Lammy 6y agoIf you’re talking about Onavo then I have to side with Apple on that one :)
- tripzilch 6y agoMeanwhile, all the people who saw this coming years ago and never bothered developing for Apple: ¯\_(ツ)_/¯ Was it because nobody spelled it out for you? Or because you thought it wouldn't happen? Or because you thought it couldn't really hurt anyone supporting such a shitty developer relationship? Or because really, you thought you could still make a quick profit before you got screwed over? Surely the next megalomanical super corporation will be fair to humans, or something. Just to make it perfectly clear; Just because there's a lot of people using a certain platform, doesn't mean that platform actually supports those people. It's not a vote. Flies didn't vote for the spider's web. Look at users/consumers/etc anywhere they get the shitty end of the deal too. So developers lose, consumers lose, Apple is the laughing third. And "Apple" isn't even human, but mostly made of pieces of paper, enslaving humans. Meanwhile developers develop, and consumers consume, keeping them both in this ecosystem circling the drain. You realise that there is an actual possibility that at some point, a few of these megacorps will win, at the same time, just cutting off our access to general purpose computing forever[0]. A battle that is already partially lost on certain fronts (chips). That's what you're risking playing stupid games. Yes I'm getting a little bit annoyed because it's been pretty obvious for at least a decade now. [0] yes Google/Android is also not supporting you being a dev on their platform, they WISH they had the power over devs that Apple had, and would make the same anti-consumer / anti-developer choices in a non-human heartbeat
- shadowgovt 6y agoIn our case, it was because there was high internal demand for support for our internal tools on the iPhones our employees already had and were familiar with. The risk analysis made it a cost worth bearing.
- shadowgovt 6y ago> You realise that there is an actual possibility that at some point, a few of these megacorps will win, at the same time, just cutting off our access to general purpose computing forever Actually, I don't. How would that scenario go? For starters, you just brought up Android, which I can install quite swiftly on any number of the mobile devices in my house with no proprietary Google software whatsoever (and even the F-droid app store if I want that "store" experience). https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_custom_Android_distributions https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_custom_Android_distrib...