3 ms·
> When reached for comment about yesterday’s news, Apple told The Verge that it was not doing anything to stop “Sign In with Apple” accounts from working with E
by judge2020 6y ago
> When reached for comment about yesterday’s news, Apple told The Verge that it was not doing anything to stop “Sign In with Apple” accounts from working with Epic Games.
Someone was lying.
https://www.theverge.com/2020/9/10/21431396/epic-sign-in-with-apple-will-keep-working-fortnite https://www.theverge.com/2020/9/10/21431396/epic-sign-in-wit...
- BoorishBears 6y agoI believe the company saying they were threatened over one as large as Apple, where one group could have said "yes we're threatening you with this" and another disparate group could say "we would never do that" - Actually looking at other sources it's very clear that is exactly what happened: - Epic Games doesn't just tweet they're being threatened with termination, they start updating all documentation on accounts to reflect this fact with a specific termination date - Verge reaches out, gets an immediate reply from Apple that they'd never do this - Epic Games gets an indefinite extension on the removal. - Verge reaches out to Apple about Epic's claims that they got an extension on a ban... no reply. Most likely the "lower level" developer relations people have the power to terminate access to the program, and did threaten Epic with it Higher level legal/strategy dealing with the fact this is a matter about to enter court and in the public spotlight step in and clarify this is not a case where the lower level relations people should terminate their access. Once the fact Epic had in fact been threatened with termination bubbled up, they stop replying. The problem is very much, most people never get that higher-level involvement. The fact these lower level development relationship people are showing it's a lever they were at some point willing to pull is more than a little worrying...
- partiallypro 6y agoI'd be interested to see if correspondence between Apple and Epic included threats to disable "sign in with Apple" though. This seems fairly possible to me, that someone made that threat without going through legal. Apple is pretty power drunk in this scenario, imo. So I wouldn't be surprised if that is the case.
- cma 6y agoApple's wording is loose enough not to preclude it. "Not doing anything" is present tense, but they could still have said they were going to. No one has to be lying. When Apple watched reached for comment on whether they just gave an indefinite extension: no comment. When earlier reached for comment on whether they were restricting it: immediate non-denial denial.
- chrisbolt 6y ago> When Apple watched reached for comment on whether they just gave an indefinite extension: no comment. Where does it say that? The Verge says “ Apple did not immediately reply to a request for comment about today’s development.”
- cma 6y agoThat was 8 days ago, still no comment.
- BoorishBears 6y agoIt's pretty clear the comment you're replying to means they had no reply. Especially if you've read the article. And the article is now a week old, Apple never replied to any follow ups from anyone. It's fairly clear that developer relations did give Epic a termination date against Apple's higher level strategy in this case. The higher level employees are who the Verge would be interacting with, so they gave a reply based on their intentions. Of course, then the fact there was indeed a termination bubbled up, so they went radio silence.
- dpkonofa 6y agoAlso important to note is that The Verge is notably anti-Apple after some previous litigation cost them a ton of money. They're not exactly unbiased in how they're going to present this information and are downplaying the fact to drum up more controversy.
- saagarjha 6y agoI thought people thought the Verge was pro-Apple?
- hrktb 6y agoI don’t get the lying angle. Apple could have told Epic that they would terminate the feature on their side at the given date, Epic would prepare for that, but in the end Apple goes back on that decision. Epic’s story stands, and Apple effectively didn’t do anything to stop the feature.