8 ms·
When I was a kid, my father used to raise octopi in our basement in NYC as a hobby. He had about six 55-gallon tanks arranged in two rows. Every day, he'd com
by reaperducer 6y ago
When I was a kid, my father used to raise octopi in our basement in NYC as a hobby. He had about six 55-gallon tanks arranged in two rows.
Every day, he'd come home from work, throw his hat and tie on the coatrack, and immediately head to the basement to play with them. If you didn't play with them, they'd die of boredom, he said.
Their favorite game was "jar." He's put empty Gerber and Ball jars in the tanks, with lids, and they'd swim in and out and in and out of the open jars. Eventually, they'd learn to open the closed jars. And then they'd spend hours swimming inside the jars, and closing the lids behind them, and trying different sized lids to see which ones worked on which jars. It was all very fulfilling to my father.
I don't know what happened to the octopi when they got mature. My guess is that he sold them to pet stores or restaurants or something.
- Cro_on 6y agounfortunately and to shatter your dreams, as mine were, it is and has always been: octopuses* tis mixage of greik and latin eytymologies and wyll not bey allowed by the way is your dad thomas pynchon?
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- bgun 6y agoLanguages, especially English, are democracies - if enough people say octopi, it eventually will be (and may already be) octopi.
- LolWolf 6y ago> Languages [...] are democracies I think the French would like to have a word! https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Académie_Française https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Académie_Française (On the other hand, rules aren't binding, so it's more like a "will of the people (if the people's will is large enough)"?)
- jakevoytko 6y agoI took a French class last year, and the teacher spent a lot of time identifying differences between academy French and how people actually talk. Things like "Je ne sais pas" => "Chais pas," which sounded like "shay pa." It seemed like the people still had a lot to say about how French should unofficially be written and spoken, even if it couldn't be used in formal settings.
- MayeulC 6y agoWell, thus is, strictly speaking, the difference between "I don't know' and "I dunno". Speakers know this is a colloquial saying. There might be a few areas where official bodies are lagging behind usage ("postuler à" being one I have in mind), but I'd say that grammar nazis and teachers alike are actually somewhat effective IMO.
- simlevesque 6y ago> "postuler à" Today I learned that I used it "wrong" all my life.
- MayeulC 6y agoI know, right? Languagetool brought it to my attention the other day. "postuler" == "to candidate" seems absent from the dictionary, though it's in common use. http://www.academie-francaise.fr/postuler-postuler-pour http://www.academie-francaise.fr/postuler-postuler-pour
- jacobr1 6y ago> but I'd say that grammar nazis and teachers alike are actually somewhat effective IMO. We have no evidence this is true. Certainly historically we know it isn't the case, there very strong evidence surrounding how languages drift over time that exist alongside contemporary pendants later proving to have not made a difference. But we also haven't really had a society with near universal literacy before so maybe that changes the dynamic.
- 6y ago
- aqme28 6y agoBy that logic shouldn't it be octopodes? That way we're consistently greek.
- Cro_on 6y agoyes, they are almost the same the greek d was actually a hard th sound iirc, Δελτα being pronounced 'thelta' as opposed to 'delta'. hopefully that clarifies (and is actually accurate) how octopuses and octopodes are connected
- alteria 6y agoYes. I volunteered at an aquarium for several years, and we spent a surprising amount of time learning octopus etymology. It was a top 10 question for adults to ask.
- reaperducer 6y agooctopuses Like "Vaxen?"
- userbinator 6y agoOctopaxen.
- picodguyo 6y ago"The Oxford English Dictionary lists octopi, octopuses and octopodes (in that order)" https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Plural_form_of_words_ending_in_-us https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Plural_form_of_words_ending_in...
- DanBC 6y agoDoes it? octopus (ˈɒktəpəs, ɒkˈtəʊpəs)Pl. octopodes (ɒkˈtəʊpədiːz), anglicized octopuses.[mod.L. octōpus, a. Gr. ὀκτώπους, acc. ὀκτώποδ-α eight-footed, f. ὀκτώ eight + πούς, πόδ- foot.] octopus A genus of cephalopod molluscs, characterized by eight `arms' surrounding the mouth and provided with suckers; an individual of this genus (esp. one of the larger and more formidable species). 1758: Baker in Phil. Trans. L. 778 “The Polypus, particularly so called, the Octopus, Preke, or Pour-contrel.” 1835: Kirby Hab. & Inst. Anim. I. x. 308 “The body of the octopus is small, it has legs sometimes a foot and a half in length, with about two hundred and forty suckers on each leg.” 1880: Browning Pietro of Abano 401 “Help! The old magician clings like an octopus!” 1884: H. M. Leathes Rough Notes Nat. Hist. 46 “Saying that enormous octopuses existed on the western side of Panama, in the Pacific Ocean.” octopus b. fig.; usually applied to an organized power having extended ramifications and far-reaching influence, esp. harmful or destructive. 1882: Greg Misc. Ess. ii. 37 “We are the very octopus of nations.” 1893: Boston (Mass.) Jrnl. 25 Mar. 2/1 “The electric octopus. Formal organization of the New England Street Railway Company.” 1894: Westm. Gaz. 12 Mar. 2/1 “He was an administrative octopus, a cormorant of toil.” octopus c. attrib. and Comb. 1880: G. Meredith Tragic Com. (1881) 206 “Then they laid octopus-limbs on her.” 1894: Outing (U.S.) XXIV. 460/1 “An octopus power sought to tear the human limpet from its clinging place.” 1898: P. Manson Trop. Diseases i. 9 “A strange-looking octopus-like creature.”
- Cro_on 6y agoPerson with Volume X (Moul-Ovum) of the second edition OED in front of them here.. a simple reply to this would be that in no dictionary 'pu' comes before 'po' :) granted, octopodes comes under the heading of octopus, as it's plural, so it is technically after. but following the loose nature of the quote in hand, it is also in fact true that octopi comes before octopuses, it just so happens to be attached to the full word 'octopian' - suggestive of an octopus
- Anon4Now 6y agoI don't know, but I kind of like "i" being the plural of "us". It makes all my decisions seem unanimous.
- thunderbong 6y agoShouldn't that be unanimi?
- chrisweekly 6y agounanimoi? (pronounced "yew-nan-i-mwa" as in French "me") ;)
- blnqr 6y agounanimata
- toolslive 6y agosometimes the plural of a word ending on 'us' ends on 'i'. Sometimes it does not. Even if the origin is Latin, it varies (lupus vs fructus). However when borrowing words from another language, things become interesting and subject to ignorance and fashion (not necessarily in that order). Pro tip: Pizza Pepperoni (Italy vs US)
- drcongo 6y agoThat story took a turn.
- reaperducer 6y agoItalian neighborhood. As a kid, I don't think I ever had a restaurant meal that didn't have octopus somewhere on the table.
- ianai 6y agoThey have a gland or something that kills them before they live longer than a few years. The specifics probably vary.
- swyx 6y agowhats the evolutionary reason (i know there doesnt have to be one) for something like that?!
- phkahler 6y ago>> whats the evolutionary reason for something like that?! You can never really know the reason with evolution because every plausible effect is in play and part of the optimization process. Having said that, one reason for adults to die may be to conserve resources (food) for the young in times/areas of scarcity. Another may be to prevent excess breeding by an individual, which may reduce genetic diversity. There are probably other viable reasons as well.
- jbay808 6y ago> Another may be to prevent excess breeding by an individual, which may reduce genetic diversity. That sounds like group selectionism. In what circumstance would this be deleterious to the propagation of that individual's genes?
- reason-mr 6y agoSurely if genetic variation is introduced primarily by the breeding process, any factors which have a effect against like (competing for food, less genetic variation), etc, are going to get selected against? I have always thought this was the reason behind human lifespans - in neolithic times, up to 33 years. Just enough time to mate and raise another individual to maturity.
- jacobush 6y agoNo, medium 33, some could get old. Just not most. And median and medium got dragged by high child mortality.
- mamp 6y agoProbably living happily on a farm...
- social_quotient 6y agoI thought only my pet rabbits and turtles went there
- hmahncke 6y agoThis is a pretty incredible story - thanks for sharing it!
- toiletfuneral 6y ago“Wow what an amazing intelligent beautiful creature, lol let’s just eat it”
- simonebrunozzi 6y agoThe plural for octopus is not octopi, but octopuses [0]. I am telling you not to be pedantic, but because I would appreciate to be corrected. Hope you feel the same. :) [0]: https://qz.com/1446229/let-us-finally-resolve-the-octopuses-v-octopi-debate/#:~:text=Grammatically%20speaking%2C%20the%20plural%20for,in%20modern%20usage%2C%20it's%20wrong https://qz.com/1446229/let-us-finally-resolve-the-octopuses-....
- reaperducer 6y agoNo need to apologize. I used "octopi" because that's what my father always said. I have no opinion on the matter.
- Baeocystin 6y agoAnother point of view: https://www.merriam-webster.com/words-at-play/the-many-plurals-of-octopus-octopi-octopuses-octopodes https://www.merriam-webster.com/words-at-play/the-many-plura... Octopi, octopuses, and octipodes have all been used. I personally think octopi rolls more smoothly off the tongue than either of the other two, so that's what I tend to use. I find the arguments regarding Greek or Latin purity to be unconvincing- we are speaking neither language. We're speaking English, which is a head-on collision between the two, with Germanic trappings gluing it all together. I happily mix and mash whatever prefix, root, infix or suffix I like. If others like it and use it, success! Whether a theoretical Roman from centuries past would agree does not enter the calculation.
- GormHouj 6y agoYour argument is that all words are made up? You could say this about any language and of course, it still holds true.
- Baeocystin 6y agoNo. My argument is that applying rules from other languages as if we are speaking them, and not English, should not hold sway. Rather, we should pay attention to sound and flow in English when deciding how to pluralize, etc.
- hannofcart 6y agoYour dad reminds me of someone I know named Senkovi. :P
- shostack 6y agoThis reminds me of the beginning of Children of Ruin, the second book in Adrian Tchaikovsky's Children of Time series.
- commonturtle 6y agoWow, that is an incredible story. One day, when / if I have a big enough house I'll build my own octopus aquarium :)