12 ms·
> Time to see for myself if this is the computing future or an evolutionary dead end. There's a third possibility - VR is finally here and consumer market is w
by criddell 6y ago
> Time to see for myself if this is the computing future or an evolutionary dead end.
There's a third possibility - VR is finally here and consumer market is what it is. It's not going to take over the world but it isn't going away either.
- dougmwne 6y agoI'd say that is the same as a dead end. Right now this is a very expensive, multi-billion dollar toy with toy demonstrator apps and proof of concept games. It needs to be a game changer and the future of something or the research funding and developer ecosystem are going to dry up. And given the amount that Facebook must be losing on the Quest 2 and the all-in nature of this launch, if this doesn't take off now, the runway for Oculus at FB may be over.
- ben_w 6y agoIn my opinion it’s just like every other games console: an expensive toy that no one needs and lots of people buy anyway because it’s decent fun.
- Robotbeat 6y agoMeh, the resolution is super close to where it needs to be to read comfortably in the headset and do real work (and with wireless headsets with inside-out tracking, the annoying setup overhead is all but eliminated). That can make it a valuable peripheral, like a nice monitor without all the space requirements. It won't likely ever be as big of a platform as smartphones are, though. So I overall agree with you.
- munificent 6y ago> It needs to be a game changer and the future of something or the research funding and developer ecosystem are going to dry up. I hate that we live in a world so dominated by network effects, economies of scale, corporate consolidation, and shareholder value that there are fewer and fewer realms where "small success" still exists.
- dougmwne 6y agoMe too, but then given the complexity of this tech, I think it's much closer by order of magnitude to a moon landing worth of engineering than Pat's Sustainable Bamboo Bicycles. Big projects, big scale, big money.
- Barrin92 6y agoPalmer lucky literally did built the first Occulus in his garage. I don't think it's fair to compare this technology to the moon landing. You're right that some sort of ready player one metaverse thing is probably on that level, but creating genuinely interesting, fun VR experiences that may in many ways be more interesting and unique does not to me seem beyond the scope of small scale business. In a sense VR is one of the purest versions of that sort of cyberspace idealism, it's an escape hatch away from curated, corporate products to whatever people want to make. So I'm not pessimistic that creative people find things to built.
- smolder 6y agoMe, too. I think economic pressures like you described generally harm quality of life. We end up with less "real wealth" --all the work-products that would otherwise make net QoL better, for the sake of monetary wealth concentration. As usual this comes down to the incentives and disincentives we've baked into our system not aligning with the best overall outcome. They align with the perceived needs of the biggest fish only.
- kkdsafjid 6y agoBeing able to buy a VR headset for 400$ is "real wealth".
- nitrogen 6y agoI have to disagree. This argument comes up in every discussion about wealth inequality. 'The non-wealthy can't complain, because everything is so cheap now.' Real wealth is, you know... actual wealth. It's being able to start a high 6-figure to 8-figure business (or even smaller if you are satisfied) and not being laughed at as a failure. It's being able to buy rather than rent everything you want to buy. It's having productive assets.
- genghisjahn 6y agoHave you played Onward on the Quest?
- criddell 6y agoIf the market is about 10 - 20 million users, that's plenty to support developers and future development. The investors who made big bets probably aren't going to see much of a return on that money, but that's okay. VC money is probably bad for the sector in the long run anyway. Don't forget that the current generation of VR hardware has roots back to a Kickstarter project. Billions of dollars are investment aren't needed.
- koiz 6y ago>Right now this is a very expensive, multi-billion dollar toy with toy demonstrator apps and proof of concept games. We are far past tech demos and concept games.
- mjparrott 6y agoFor example?
- blackearl 6y agoBeat Saber is the obvious answer with the most general appeal.
- Animats 6y agoRight. Beat Saber works because the virtual world does not rotate relative to the real world. That rotation is what induces nausea. The player is confined to a small box in the virtual world; they never move very far, and the virtual world is locked to the real world.[1] Games with that constraint are limited. You could do ping-pong. Shooting galleries. [1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gV1sw4lfwFw https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gV1sw4lfwFw
- blackearl 6y agoOk but it's not a tech demo or some proof of concept. It's a fully fleshed out game with high profile DLC and a strong mod community. Nausea has nothing to do with this.
- andybak 6y agoI'm not sure your understanding of VR motion sickness is quite right. Most people are completely fine with teleport locomotion which is sufficient for a huge class ofs games. Also cockpits seem to reduce nausea thus opening up another broad category. It's mostly smooth first person motion with strafing and smooth turning that is problematic.
- koiz 6y ago
- alasdair_ 6y ago> proof of concept games Half Life: Alyx is a fantastic AAA game that in no way feels like a proof of concept. Strongly recommend playing it. (Beat Saber too)