4 ms·
This is one of these cases where the US appears to have borrowed concepts that existed in the British governmental system at the time of their independence (whe
by rsynnott 6y ago
This is one of these cases where the US appears to have borrowed concepts that existed in the British governmental system at the time of their independence (when this power still vested with the monarch in what was then England, AIUI), and then never got round to reforming them. Today, an individual having an unchecked pardon power is a bit of an anachronism, and very dangerous.
(If you want to be ultra-pedantic this power is still vested in the monarch, but they can't use it without the direction of the Home Secretary, who in turn is bound by convention to generally almost never use it, and certainly not purely of their own initiative.)
- bosswipe 6y agoWe in the US also thought the president was bound by convention to use it rarely. Trump has ignored the convention without any consequences.
- rsynnott 6y agoI mean, even presidents before Trump often used it rather arbitrarily, but Trump is definitely a new low in recent history. I think you could divide uses of this power into a few categories: - Righting past wrongs; pardoning people convicted under old laws now repealed and considered immoral - this is the primary use in most countries that retain a pardon. - Influencing policy; pardoning people convicted under existing laws that the pardoner is personally opposed to - this happens in the US a bit. - Electoral franchise; pardoning people to restore their right to vote - this one is mostly only US relevant, as most developed democracies (including large parts of the US) don't remove the franchise for this reason. - Patronage - Pardoning personal friends/contributors/etc. This historically happened quite a lot in the US. - Quid pro quo - Trump seems to be the main offender here.
- fortran77 6y agoIs Wikipedia wrong about Obama's 1200+ pardons vs Trump's 25? If you have a source, please correct it. (This isn't a political statement. I liked Obama, and I don't like Trump.)
- rsynnott 6y agoAddressed here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24517807 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24517807
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- krapp 6y agoLiterally no one who voted for Trump wanted or expected him to be bound by the conventions of the office, rather the opposite.
- mhh__ 6y agoSome people definitely voted for him on the basis that he would become "presidential" (imagine that) and be neutered by Pence etc.
- jessaustin 6y agoHave you ever met anyone who supports Pence? I haven't, and I live in southern Missouri.
- mhh__ 6y agoThe people I'm referring to are the "I'm alright jack" Trump supporters who basically will do anything if it means owning the libs. Also people who thought he would be non-interventionist (I have seen this on HN this year i.e. after Soleimani) despite "I'd bomb the shit out of ISIS"
- jessaustin 6y agoYou're talking about two different sets of people, neither of whom intersect with the (empty) set referenced above. Of course it's a mistake to believe a presidential candidate who promises peace. In my lifetime, maybe Carter (if one squints hard enough to obscure Iran) and maybe Clinton (if one squints hard enough to obscure Africa) kept that promise. The "lib-owners" couldn't care less about that issue. The idea that Pence would rein in either partisan nastiness or stupid wars, if he even could, is still risible.
- newen 6y agoPoint of order, there are no sets that intersect with an empty set ;)
- nlitened 6y agoWikipedia says that Obama pardoned 1927 individuals [0], while Trump pardoned 25 [1]. Am I reading it wrong somehow? [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_people_granted_executive_clemency_by_Barack_Obama https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_people_granted_executi... [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_people_granted_executive_clemency_by_Donald_Trump https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_people_granted_executi...
- rsynnott 6y agoIf you look at those, there's a significant difference in the _sort_ of pardons given, though. Most of the Obama ones seem to be retroactive pardons of mostly rather severe sentences, for random people (note how none of the names are links). This is essentially the traditional use of the power; random person appeals, says their sentence was unjust, his majesty/mr president/the committee agrees and issues a retroactive pardon. Most of Trump's appear to be pardons of notable people, often aligned with Trump, currently serving their sentence, and in the case of Stone actually convicted for activity relating to Trump. There are a few more traditional cases (eg Jack Johnson), but all in all they're two very different lists, showing a very different use of the power. To be clear, I'm of the opinion that both are bad and that the power should be restricted to a judicial committee or similar, as elsewhere, but I do think these two cases are _different_.
- buzzerbetrayed 6y agoEven if "most" of Obama's pardons were "good ones", the fact that he pardoned 77x more people than trump leaves a lot of room for more than 25 "bad ones". I'm not saying this is for sure the case.. just that your comment smells of bias to me.
- rsynnott 6y agoWho on Obama's list of pardonees was a witness in a criminal investigation of Obama? By the way, at the end of his first term, Obama had pardoned _17_ people. Expect a flood of pardons from Donald in January (or, if he's re-elected, in January 2025) as is traditional.
- logicchains 6y ago>Today, an individual having an unchecked pardon power is a bit of an anachronism, and very dangerous. Of all the things a ruler with unchecked power could do, I'd argue pardoning people is possibly the least dangerous. "Oh no, please help me, the evil dictator is going around flagrantly pardoning people, hope he doesn't pardon me!"
- jessaustin 6y agoIt's telling that in a nation with 4% of the world's population and 25% of its prisoners, one still finds complaints about "unchecked pardons". That's before one even considers the odious racial history.
- rsynnott 6y agoMy concern about unchecked pardons is, well, the subject of the article; the use of the pardon power to arrange a quid pro quo. Obviously, separately, the US has major criminal justice problems, but you won't solve those by letting an individual pardon anyone they feel like.
- jessaustin 6y agoAssange's case is a perfect example of USA's (and, by extension, USA lackey UK's) "major criminal justice problems". This is a man whose only crime was exposing war crimes to the consideration of the general public. His persecutors have argued in court that he doesn't have 1A rights because he's not a USA citizen, but he is still bound by the most maximalist interpretation of an obscure USA law because "fuck him". I wish I still wondered where this vehement hatred for innocent victims of the state comes from...
- rsynnott 6y agoAssange's prosecution can be bad, and yet attempting to gain favours from him with the offer of a pardon can also be bad... In fact, in _very_ corrupt systems, it is common to put people you need something from in legal jeopardy _for the purpose_ of dangling a pardon to get the thing you wanted in the first place. To be clear, I don't think that's the case here; Trump was attempting to get a quid pro quo but probably didn't set up the initial situation.
- dalbasal 6y agoMost republics borrow most of their core concepts from monarchies that preceded them. In the early (modern) republics like the US & France, Presidents have a lot of power, especially military power. Many later Republics (eg Ireland) inherited from monarchist systems with more of a ceremonial role for the king, and presidents tend to have more of a ceremonial role too. Anyway, to various extents and with lots of caveats... Presidents have the power to pardon in a lot of democratic countries. In Ireland, for example, the power is constitutionally with the President, but in practice the power is with the government/parliament. Whatever the details, pardons (and clemencies) are a necessary device. Even courts need check valves and this is a way of checking courts without harming the court as an institution. Yes, it is open to abuse, but on balance I do think it's necessary. I agree that this sounds like an ugly politicisation... but everything about the Assange case is highly politicised. The content of the offense publishing politically damaging information about parties, politicians, defense and intelligence bodies. There have been tactical indictments in multiple countries. Secretive proceedings. Etc. This was never a case where blind justice reigns pristine. It's an inevitably political shitshow. For analogy, think of US impeachment. It's an obviously political, and whether or not the President has enough friends in Congress matters more than evidence. It's a whole lot better than nothing though. If you want to see what not having anything looks like, you can look at the shitshow going on in Israel currently. Sometimes you need a way around standard rules. Standard rules exist for a reason, and bypasses aren't without a cost... but I do think they're necessary.
- rsynnott 6y ago> Most republics borrow most of their core concepts from monarchies that preceded them. In the early (modern) republics like the US & France, Presidents have a lot of power, especially military power. While this is generally true, France is a weird case; it was a parliamentary democracy for a bit! The current semi-presidential setup is pretty new. > Whatever the details, pardons (and clemencies) are a necessary device. Even courts need check valves and this is a way of checking courts without harming the court as an institution. Yes, it is open to abuse, but on balance I do think it's necessary. Sure, but it shouldn't be at the behest of one person. It's fine if it is ceremonially, as in the UK and Ireland cases, but not if it is _in fact_.