20 ms·
I detest sharia law in general and the whole idea of a religious authority making rules others then have to follow but... There are subtle and important differe
by LatteLazy 6y ago
I detest sharia law in general and the whole idea of a religious authority making rules others then have to follow but... There are subtle and important differences between Islamic finance and non Islamic finance and there are upsides to the Islamic approach. One example of this is that there is no chance of bankruptcy from debts or negative equity. This strongly encourages responsible lending.
- runawaybottle 6y agoI don’t think this is specific to Sharia law, those rules on lending is for Islam in general. I think giving away 30% of your income to the poor every year is one of the five pillars of Islam as well.
- fakedang 6y ago1.) Islamic law is the same as Sharia law 2.) It's 2%, and in the past often collected as tax.
- insulanian 6y agoIt's 2.5%
- fakedang 6y agoYeah, my bad. But still nowhere near the 30% mentioned by the original comment.
- doesnotexist 6y agoThere is no set amount or percentage dictated by the Quran. Usually the customary amount is ~2.5% of capital assets earned in a year. And apparently somewhere around 20% on mining income, which obviously is only applicable to small number of people who own interests in mining operations.
- doesnotexist 6y agoUnfortunately mainstream undercurrents of islamaphobia/orientalism have hijacked the english use of an arabic word "Sharia" and made it into a knee-jerk scare word. It seems weird to pronounce that you detest it in general since it's not a monolithic thing and is more of a general concept encompassing a law tradition informed by a moral/religious framework. https://bridge.georgetown.edu/research/factsheet-sharia/ https://bridge.georgetown.edu/research/factsheet-sharia/ https://ing.org/a-closer-look-at-sharia-in-the-united-states/ https://ing.org/a-closer-look-at-sharia-in-the-united-states...
- pc86 6y agoIs Sharia law not a religious authority ruling folks who do not belong to that religion? What exactly is Islamophobic about calling that out? The exchange between Bill Maher, Sam Harris, and Ben Affleck[0] is a great example of hamfisting Islamophobia into completely legitimate criticisms of Islam, Islamism, Sharia over secular society, etc. Not every criticism of Islam (and truthfully, the vast majority of criticisms of Islam) are not racist of Islamophobic. [0] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vln9D81eO60 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vln9D81eO60
- doesnotexist 6y agoThere is little to no difference between what the article is describing, a halal certificate on some financial instruments and the Kosher or Halal stamps you see on food products at the grocery store. In this case there is a consumer demand for products labelled Halal and it is being met by a body deemed to hold legitimacy in determining compliance, how this becomes a discussion about defending the entirety of a broad concept like Sharia is perplexing.
- pc86 6y agoIs a "halal certificate on some financial instruments" a relevant thing outside of Sharia law? This is a serious question. Are more moderate Muslims okay with interest, or is it pretty much across the board? I'm sure you can find some of any group okay with just about anything, I just mean in general. I'm not sure where on the spectrum of atheist to Islamist something like this falls. Right or wrong I have always associated refusal to use traditional banking a more hard-line Muslim belief.
- raverbashing 6y ago> One example of this is that there is no chance of bankruptcy from debts or negative equity I think there are some dusty luxury cars at Dubai airport that beg to differ
- thebean11 6y agoGenuinely curious, what's this a reference to? People fleeing Dubai to avoid debt, leaving their cars at the airport?
- davchana 6y agoYes, in 2008 recession it happened. Middle east & Dubai have way way lot expats as compared to locals, sometimes like 90%. Most of the Dubai expats had lots of disposable income for similar jobs as compared to income from same jobs in their home countries, so many of them financed luxury cars, expensive houses etc. Once recession hit, the jobs started disappearing here & there, & expats had no choice but to return back to home. Now, if they inform bank first, banks can stop them from exiting country by government assistance, so many of them just drove to airport in those cars, parked, took flights & never looked back.