3 ms·
> Real time raytracing was an utter fantasy just a few years ago We still don't have real time ray-tracing. Even the demos that only use ray-tracing are throwi
by ekianjo 6y ago
> Real time raytracing was an utter fantasy just a few years ago
We still don't have real time ray-tracing. Even the demos that only use ray-tracing are throwing the strict minimum of rays and they apply a series of complex filters (using machine learning) to remove the artifacts and the noise.
- jagger27 6y agoIt’s still pretty cool that these cards have enough oomph to get close enough to real-time for DLSS to work.
- jamwaffles 6y agoAs I understand it, the Quake RTX demo is fully ray traced but I could be wrong on that. The FPS isn’t super high but definitely playable.
- jiggawatts 6y agoIf anything, that's more impressive in a way. The NVIDIA presentation for the 30xx series was the first time it really "clicked" for me, despite having a 2080 in my PC for a while now. The RTX cards dedicate something like 30% of the silicon and power "budget" to neural-nets. This isn't something designed to appease only the ML crowd, it's used for gaming. The graphics you see is 30% ML noise reduction and upscaling. I used to think of "AI accelerators" as some sort of gimmick, one-trick ponies like Apple's face recognition. Useful for a handful of apps, a few seconds at a time. But no, in the RTX series of cards, the "AI stuff" is drawing nearly 100 watts and doing real work, making ray tracing viable and making 1080p look better than 4K.
- mhh__ 6y agoAnd? Everything is an approximation so if you can fake it 'til you make it does it matter? I assume by the end of the century we will end up with some kind of physically based rendering at a near photonic level of detail.
- rrss 6y agoBy this logic, we basically still don't even have offline ray-tracing. Both Renderman and Hyperion have denoisers that Pixar and Disney use on feature films. > And because we could not afford to render images to convergence, we needed to develop a robust denoising solution > The denoiser is used on most production shots, and is run automatically unless disabled https://www.yiningkarlli.com/projects/hyperiondesign/hyperiondesign.pdf https://www.yiningkarlli.com/projects/hyperiondesign/hyperio... (The fact that Hyperion uses a denoiser does not mean that it isn't rendering via path tracing. Similarly, the fact that real-time rendering uses a denoiser does not mean it isn't rendering via path tracing. dealing with noise is the name of the game, and machine learning isn't somehow "out of bounds")
- holoduke 6y agoWell we are still talking about few million rays per second. Without filtering you will end up with too much noise and blobs. Raytracing without noise filters is even for prerendered scenes unpractical and too expensive.
- formerly_proven 6y agoPretty much every raytracer uses denoising. Every "industry-strength" raytracer anyway.