3 ms·
> How is that transphobic? This is a frustrating line of argument. What would make you the authority on what transphobia is? > Are the views[1] of the author
by UncleMeat 6y ago
> How is that transphobic?
This is a frustrating line of argument. What would make you the authority on what transphobia is?
> Are the views[1] of the author irrational and based in fear of trans people?
To "arrive" does not mean "to cross a river". To be "awesome" does not mean "to be terrifying". Meanings are not constructed by etymology. Transphobia is not "the irrational fear of transgender people".
The author is not a "rational skeptic", as clearly evidenced by her wildly biased choice of analysis presented as solid science. Her work has been widely criticized by the scientific community and is not far off from forming opinions about racial differences in IQ by asking aparthied leaders about their opinions and experiences and taking it as gospel evidence.
- alphachloride 6y agoI do not presume to be an authority. In fact, that is what my original comment was asking: What is transphobia? You have rejected one definition but failed to provide an alternative. That leads me to the second part of my original comment: is it something subjective that you'll know when you see it? I'll have to read her work in more depth to form an opinion on the rigor of her work. Suffice to say, I view your evaluation of her work with skepticism as well.